one shade darker than the light tile....the other two are too dark/not attractive at all.....there are so many good looking tiles....why the dull gray monochromatic look for your great elements? if search time has stopped then take the light tile. here is dark tile at least in a pattern and w less matte look gives a little more showy appeal without overdoing it. second is tile in a wood look which can easily coordinate with your choices. pick something other than a back door entry type tile where dogs and kids come and go. dont fear a nicer dark look if that what you want.

Grant Park Kitchen Remodel · More Info

Porcelain plank wood look tile installations Tampa, Florida · More Info

I like #3 (however the written description doesn't seem to match)

The polished brass hardware seems wrong (a bit too fancy) for any of the finish selections. I'd select something with either natural brass or brushed brass

@ak10503. Did you choose the 2nd option with the most votes? Is the small square sample for the counter? Can you give me the names of the tiles and counter? Would appreciate if you could post a picture of completed project.