Software
Houzz Logo Print
dbotemple

Backsplash Mistake - Help Please

4 years ago

Hello!!! My backsplash doesn’t look like I thought it would! They are not done but I don’t love it. I was obsessed with this backsplash for months and ambivalent about the countertop/waterfall. Now, I love the countertop/waterfall and not feeling good about the backsplash. It’s not too late to do the backsplash over but it has to be done on Monday (tomorrow) because they are wrapping up! Any thoughts on how to save this??

Comments (20)

  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    I probably wouldn't have picked something so dark for a dark kitchen. You really need some recessed lights in the ceiling. I would do four 4" recessed lights. I hope you have under cabinet lighting as it will make a big difference in the space.

    Is the tile going to run down to the floor under that floating cabinet? I hope so.

    The tile goes with the other elements. Sometimes the picture we have in our head does not match the look in real life, but it usually works out ok once you get used to it.

  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    the kitchen is an alcove and its a bit dark. Lighting is your bigger issue really. I think i'd leave the tile.....let them finish up...It makes no sense to have the fancy counter like that and leave the single old fixture with no style and inadequate illumination. Keep moving on with the most important things. if loving stuff in the kitchen is the criteria ddnt you meet that with the counters? i think the splash is fine..kind of interesting between the plainer cabs and counter but recedes enough as things will be sitting out , remember.

  • 4 years ago

    Common mistake, choosing everything you love instead of what compliments each other. I dont think you will ever love this, I would stop it now before you finish and grout it.

  • PRO
    4 years ago

    Think it will be fine and look good with your countertops when finished.

  • 4 years ago

    @Tanya! Thanks so much! @chispa - the ceiling is low which is why I didn’t do recessed lighting but I am definitely doing under cabinet lighting. I was resisting running the tile to the floor. It just feels like too much. @chispa - what do you mean the single old fixture with no style! 🤣 Are you referring to the light? The light belonged to the former owner. I keep going back and forth about it - it actually doesn’t look as bland as it does in the photo. It is lightly textured. BUT renovating this kitchen has involved so many choices that I figured I would think about the light fixture last. Thank you for flagging!

  • 4 years ago

    Maybe it is not exactly as you envisioned but to me it looks nice. The backsplash is often the hardest choice to make.

    But, the backsplash is the easiest to swap out down the line if you choose to.

    The waterfall edge looks fantastic. So many issues talked about here and yet yours is perfect.

    I would not tear this out.

    Do you have a sample of how this tile is grouted? I have never seen tile like this.

  • 4 years ago

    I also wanted to say that it really blends very well with your lower cabinets. And with the floor being a white marble look tile. I think you needed something a little darker to balance all of the white. I really do think it will look beautiful when you are finished and you will have a fabulous kitchen that is a reflection of your style and not just cookie cutter white, with white subway, etc. I just redid my kitchen. Did black lower, white uppers, white quartz and black 4x4 square backsplash. I wouldn’t trade it for anything, def not a kitchen with white subway tiles (blah). I hope you keep it, you loved it for a reason!

  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    I didn't mention your one light, just said you needed more light!

    Wait ... so you are going to leave the backsplash floating on that back wall???

    I hope I misunderstood. That backsplash has to come all the way down to the floor based on what you have done so far, no other way around it.

  • 4 years ago

    You may be noticing the difference in tone and colours between the backspalsh tile and countertop. Is it the same countertop going on the perimeter? If so, put them together to see how they work together. I would have chosen a more neutral backsplash tile in that white/off-white of the counter- because the countertop has lots of big patterns. (Love it!) You might be able to make it work as the backsplash appears to match the cabinets very well. Use a grout very close to the tile colour to help to recede them in your design. With under cabinet lights and a new ceiling fixture, it will be amazing!

  • 4 years ago

    The tile looks good but I agree lighting is the real issue. You need more / better lighting. The one fixture is not working. Also add under cabinet lighting which will highlight the counter and tile. Best of luck. If really does look good

  • 4 years ago

    If the ceiling is low, even MORE of a reason to do recessed lighting. I also agree that the backsplash needs to come down to the floor on that back wall.

  • 4 years ago

    One minor observation. If you can get new molding get something that will go to the ceiling thus eliminating the shadow.

  • 4 years ago

    Yeah! I was upset with that!

  • 4 years ago

    @chispa @hillside and others - so you really think the backsplash should go to the floor? I was thinking of adding tile trim where the wood is and then adding large white tiles with light veins so that it appears as if the floor tiles run up the wall.

  • 4 years ago

    Hey. I would do the tile all the way down. The floor tile looks like a way less exciting version of your counter. Which would make that look like a way less exciting version of your waterfall.

  • 4 years ago

    Yes that herringbone will need to go to the floor. Otherwise it will look like a belly band around the room - not a good look.

  • 4 years ago

    And I hope you have under-cabinet lighting to lighten things up!

  • 4 years ago

    Definitely to the floor.

  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    Definitely to the floor with the same backsplash tile.