Both choices look like they have a LOT of variation. That can end up looking stripe-y or patchwork-y, which I personally dont care for. I guess if you like all that drama on the floor, then do you want fairly dark floors, or lighter? Personal choice. purchase a box or two and lay it out in your home to see if you still love it.

I like the slab a lot!

Must it be porcelain tile?… so cold… hard… slippery?… you don’t dare drop any thing on it that is breakable…or that is heavy enough to crack the actual tile…

This is a great color / pattern in LVP

In any case .., the 2 choices you offer are not copacetic with the slab in style or color

The soft ash looks like barnboard on the floor. I have selected an alternate from the same supplier. See below.

I would not select such a busy pattern for the counter top and island.

Thank you!