Software
Houzz Logo Print
twhitmeyer

Skara Brae Matte for kitchen counters, island & backsplash?

4 years ago

Up until a few days ago we were confident in our decision to use Cambria's Skara Brae Matte on the perimeter counters, island and backsplash. Now we are beginning to question that decision.


Because of how our counters are divided, there will be no seams anywhere. The island will be a single slab with a mitered edge, 2.5". The backsplash behind the range top will be full height up to the bottom of the rangehood.


Our concern is that the kitchen could look too busy with such a bold vein everywhere. Baesd on everything I've read, the matte finish from Cambria creates a more subtle look than the high polish, so that will help.


The argument in favor of our choice is that it can be difficult to match other materials with bold patterns such as Skara Brae, and therefore using the same quartz everywhere eliminates that challenge. I've seen people use other stones on the permimeter and backsplash and it it worked out great, but I've also seen photos where it turned out badly.


For a variety of reasons, I think higher end kitchens can pull of these bold quartz options better than budget kitchens. Our space is not a $200K kitchen, but it skews more toward what most people would consider a high end kitchen.


I'm not sure if this will be helpful, but here are some details about the rest of the kitchen:

- new shaker cabinets to the ceiling / custom drawers with Top Knobs Amwell knurled pulls in ash gray

- leaning toward Chantilly Lace for the cabinet color, the island might be BM Cheating Heart (paint colors will be finalized after the counters are installed)

- Wolf range top and stainless appliances / sink

Comments (18)

  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    it is a pretty personal decision - not sure how i would feel with such dramatic veining everywhere (but i am def a ”less is more” girl) it can also be hard to get the pattern matched up well w/ BS - here is a thread where they talk about it

    https://www.houzz.com/discussions/5358296/new-cambria-quartz-color-skara-brae

    Below is a photo from the thread




    Eta ^ looks like they used black on the perimeter?

  • 4 years ago

    I came across that first photo during my research. I think it looks bad for several reasons. The first is the layout - that particular kitchen doesn’t have the right counter layout for Skara Brae. That long and narrow section of backsplash doesn’t work well with this quartz. The only large section of backsplash we will have is behind the range.

    Also, I think you need a higher end kitchen to make a bold quartz work. Everyone has a budget, of course, but personally I don’t think bold quartz works well in budget friendly kitchens.

  • PRO
    4 years ago

    Skara Brae is very dramatic in person. I think it would look gorgeous on an island painted BM Cheating Heart or SW Iron Ore. I think that it is too much to do on all the counters and a backsplash too. Save yourself the money and do a white, dark grey, or black quartz on the back counters and pick a solid color tile backsplash a shade or two darker than your chantilly lace cabinetry. You can use a different brand other than Cambria for the back counters and still pull everything together and save yourself a few thousand dollars.

  • PRO
    4 years ago

    It will be great. You've got to be bold to be bold. I'm sick to death of the safety of the gray and white nothingness that's trending.

  • 4 years ago

    Thanks for the additional feedback. I think they demonstrated how to pull it off well it in this kitchen:

  • 4 years ago

    That kitchen below is GORGEOUS! Love Skara Brae, and yes, as Joseph says, you've got to be bold to be bold!

  • 4 years ago

    We are using it on all of our flat surfaces, and our stove wall backsplash, very similar to the last picture you shared. Except, I didn't add the upwall or 4" splash anywhere else, and opted to tile on adjascent walls to the ceiling (sink and breakfront wall). Skara Brae is beautiful, and yes it's bold, but well worth it IMO. Our install is this week. If you end up going through with it, I hope you come back to share. I'd love to see the outcome.

  • 4 years ago

    Beautiful @Robyn Segreti. Love the vault and beams in your ceiling, as well. Your open shelf/lit cabinet section helps me visualize what our breakfront will look like, too. It will be a bit different, but similar. Smaller of course.


    Our Skara brae went in last Thursday, and the appliance company just left this morning after finishing the Range. The kitchen isn't done yet, but we're in love with it so far. No regrets. We hope to have the tile, lighting swaps/removals and last of the cabinet/trim done over the next couple of weeks. There's a wine cabinet/fridge section yet to be built, but first I just need a kitchen back.




    This cabinet has a bit of work to go before it's done. Tile in the center, open wood shelves, wood veneer on the interior side cabinets and wood shelves. Plus the lighting and glass.


    You can see our seam on the right below. Because we have a cabinet coming down to the counter (yet to be trimmed out in the first picture), we were able to forgo any seams at the 90 degree bend or near the sink. Now that the cabinet is in place, you can't see the break visually. It worked out well in our favor. Thankfully, because the pattern isn't always so forgiving.


  • 4 years ago

    Great photos. We ended up with skara brae matte on all the counters, and the backsplash behind the range.

    The other perimeter backslashes will be some sort of tile. Probably a diamond or hexagon style, not standard subway.

    We didn’t have a choice on the backsplash - the stone company messed up the cuts for the skara brae backsplash pieces (except the piece behind the range, which we kept). This gave is the option to move to a tile, or wait six weeks for more stone. We chose to switch to a tile, and ultimately I think it’s going to look better.

    I’ll definitely share some photos when complete.

  • 4 years ago

    I’m sorry to hear you had some issues, but glad you found a solution. I can’t wait to see your final outcome.

    We are adding Montauk gin subway tile. We didn’t want a basic either. I’m still torn on stacked vs traditional layout.

  • 4 years ago

    Here are two tile backsplash options we are considering.

  • 4 years ago

    I really like those. The bottom one was in our initial group pick. I ended up going with a slightly shorter tile because our tiled area isn’t very big. When we switched, we went with the pearlized/satin tiles. But these look great with it. I loved the subtle interest in the glazing.

  • 4 years ago

    We are definitely leaning toward the one pictured below since it is more simple than the distressed option. We wanted more of a matte finish, but we couldn’t find any honed marble that we thought would look good with the skara brae.

    A slightly shorter tile would be nice because our area is also small, but I wouldn’t want to go much smaller since smaller tiles tend to look busier.

  • PRO
    3 years ago

    Can you tell me what tile this is? I am using skara brae and this looks like a good match. The bottom one Thanks.

  • 3 years ago

    Tribeca Gypsum White 6x24.6cm (26871)

    Note that the tile we received has a lot more distressing around the edges compared to the store display.

    The flow of our kitchen didn’t allow for us to have the quartz veins run parallel to the tile backsplash. Tile paired with SB would look better if the veins weren’t perpendicular to the backsplash.

    If I could do it over, I might not have used Skara Brae on the perimeter. We love it on the island (we did a 2.5” mitered edge) and around the range, though. We are pleased with the result, just might have considered something else on the perimeter.

    I would discourage anyone from using Skara Brae as your perimeter backsplash - with the exception of the range area. For every photo I’ve seen where it worked, there are 50 where it doesn’t.

  • 3 years ago

    I am researching this very topic. I do believe I will use the Cambria Concrete on my counters with a black backsplash up the wall.
    Do you know if i should use Quartzite around the cooktop?

  • 2 years ago
    last modified: 2 years ago

    How did it turn out? I decided not to do black counterbin perimeter but its not too late please share photo