Software
Houzz Logo Print
rebecca_brack11

Raised Panel Cabinet Doors?

4 years ago
last modified: 4 years ago

We are rebuilding our home after a tornado. Gone are the 1993 honey oak cabinets. We are going for a cozy, traditional vibe. "Natural Linen" by Sherwin Williams is the color on the walls on the first floor with "Creamy" (an off white color) as the trim. I'll be using shades of sage green for accents and decor. The living room and kitchen/dinette are open to each other. I am considering these cabinets. Mainly because our builder gets them with a discount. This distributor has shaker style cabinets only in a dark espresso color, gray, or white. I originally wanted shaker cabinets but I feel like the white is just too stark so I'm considering these raised panel doors because they are a softer, warmer color. I'd love some reassurance that I'm not making a mistake because all that I see when I look up photos for kitchen redos is the shaker style cabinets.






Comments (23)

  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    ask for a door sample....put it in the space.... its the only way. make sure the lighting is correct.....led of 4000 is usually recommended...that door could read peach /pink or bisque or cocoa. you want to know and whatever the case may be that you can work with it. are you getting some glass door uppers? that breaks up things right at eye level.....stainless appliances .....things like that have an impact....long runs of cabinetry w nothing breaking it up would make me think hard about it.....this one is similar w coppers and browns on the other surfaces . raised panel is fine ..I like it many times but normally in white......if the color isnt suitable dont hesitate to get white as its a classic look...with the relief detail its never stark .

    2013 Whole House Remodel · More Info


    Rebecca Brack thanked herbflavor
  • 4 years ago

    Thanks for your input and the picture reference. Greatly appreciated! We will have stainless appliances that will break up some of the cabinetry. I had the option for glass front doors but I wasn't sure that I wanted people to be able to see inside my cabinets. I'm second guessing that decision now.

  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    I’m no pro, but I think it should be your preference whether to do Shaker or a raised panel. I’d also choose the cabinets I really wanted rather than letting a wall color dictate.

    That said, I did very simple raised panels last year (simpler than the above photos); no regrets. I jokingly call them ”Shaker ajacent”… Good luck.

    Rebecca Brack thanked Julie R.
  • 4 years ago

    Nothing wrong with raised panel, but is there a simpler option?

    Rebecca Brack thanked emilyam819
  • 4 years ago

    Talk to the cabinetmaker. If he does one type in a color, he may agree to do Shaker in the same color. I prefer 3500k lighting. Test whatever lights before you make a final color choice.

    Rebecca Brack thanked dan1888
  • 4 years ago

    Raised panel are classic and timeless if done with little embellishment.
    You could use glass that is not clear - with a pattern like rainfall or other to your liking. It would give a hint of what is in the cupboards without the need for precise order.

    Rebecca Brack thanked S Mil
  • 4 years ago

    Why were you drawn to the shaker? Raised panels were in vogue for decades and happen not to be at the moment. They may well come back. They are more fussy, harder to keep clean, lots of nooks and crannies for dirt to collect.... I question the white if cozy is your goal. White is cold, formal not a warm hug as you described.

    Rebecca Brack thanked arcy_gw
  • 4 years ago

    Pay attention to your lighting…..4000 seems very cool to my eyes and I went with 3000.

    Rebecca Brack thanked plf12652
  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    Wow. These are all insightful and helpful tips!


    @plf12652 - Can you explain what you mean by 4000 and 3000 lighting?

  • 4 years ago

    I feel like you are compromising your forever kitchen. If you aren’t sure about the door style, you will regret it the rest of your life. You need to love your cabinets because they don’t get changed so often.

    I would revisit the white shaker. You can make that work with sage green. It can be lovely together. Can you post photos of the adjacent areas of the open concept?

    Rebecca Brack thanked RedRyder
  • 4 years ago

    @RedRyder - I think you might be right. I've been thinking about this a lot today. I didn't sleep at all last night. At the beginning of this rebuild process I really wanted to do shaker style cabinets with two shades. After reading these comments, I am considering getting the white shaker cabinets from the company our builder uses and then having our painter customize them with the shades that I want.

  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    Can you explain what you mean by 4000 and 3000 lighting?


    3000 in a kitchen is too dim and too yellow. fine for a living room.


    this should give you a visual between the dimmer 3000K and the 4000K




    4000K (kelvin refers to temperature of the light) is much better. it's more natural.

    5000K is a bit too cool (think large stores or commercial kitchens)







    I did 4000K LEDs in my kitchen and it's perfect. If you have a lot of natural light w/windows, and don't mind yellowish tones, go w/the 3000

    Rebecca Brack thanked Beth H. :
  • 4 years ago

    Regarding lighting, one measurement is based on kelvins, so you'll see references to 3000K, 4000K, etc. The kelvin level can make a significant difference in how colors look. Here's an example showing various levels of lighting: link. And an illustration below:



    Rebecca Brack thanked chicagoans
  • 4 years ago

    My cabinetmaker (Amish, custom) offers a simpler raised panel cabinet door. (Most of mine will be this style but different stain and paint colours.) As mentioned above, you might see if your cabinetmaker offers different styles in the raised panel.


    The two rooms I did with shaker style doors have a 45° slant instead of 90°, similar to the door in this photo. I think this has a softer look than the 90°.


    Rebecca Brack thanked cwcf185
  • 4 years ago

    Rebecca, I’m glad you’re rethinking this. It’s a huge decision and you said you wanted shaker, so find a way to get what you want with your cabinet doors. The other decisions are secondary when you walk into a new kitchen. I’m sorry/not sorry you didn’t sleep. 😊

  • PRO
    4 years ago

    I would go with recessed cabinet doors. Raised ones look dated, out of style.

  • 4 years ago

    Check out the pillow edge style. If I had it to do over I'd choose it.

  • 4 years ago

    Here's a picture of pillow edge style.

    Pillow Edge Door Style in a Light Stain Accented with Mocha Glaze. · More Info

  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    Does one need authority to voice an opinion on whether or not something is dated?

    Orange formica and avocado green appliances. dated. you disagree? great. your opinon.

    Arched oak cabinets, raised panel doors from 1990, dated. You don't agree? great, that's your perogative.

    If anyone on here thinks what any of us say is gospel, that's their interpretation. People come on here to get ideas, advice and opinions. People who answer those people give their experiences w/said ideas and advice relating to those experiences. Nothing more. It's up to the person posting if they want to accept or reject it.

  • 4 years ago

    Yes Beth I agree with you!

  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    @Beth H. : & @chicagoans - Thank you for that detailed post regarding lighting. My husband and I went to the home improvement store a few nights ago and I was able to see, in person, what you laid out in the post.

    @BeverlyFLADeziner - Thank you so much for all the detailed advice. Believe it or not, I hired an award winning designer to give me advice on colors and she gave me the go ahead for Natural Linen with Creamy trim. I painted samples all around the house of Natural Linen and I do like it. But, upon reflecting on your words, I can see your point. I am attaching pictures of our home here so that you can see that the color of the trim and walls are very important in relation to the cabinets. (These pictures are from when we put on offer on the house so please keep in mind that none of the decor or furniture is mine...lol).

    The house is currently completely gutted. We will be putting in stainless appliances. I have decided to go with the shaker cabinets and I'd love to do a two tone cabinet scheme. I love green. My house will be cozy and traditional with shades of beige and green throughout. I am thinking about SW Evergreen Fog or maybe Willow on the bottom cabinets? If I did Alabaster on the walls what would you suggest for the upper cabinets. I don't want something too stark white. Some kind of warm white is where I am leaning.

    The pictures show when you come in the front door. There is a entryway with the stairs. To the left is the living room with large windows that bring in light from the east, north and south. Walking through the living room you will connect with the dining area and kitchen that has large north facing windows. Their is a den on the opposite side of the entryway that has it's own walls and south facing bay window.


    Entry



    Living Room with light from the East


    Living room with light from the South and East


    Living Room with light from the East and North


    Walking from the Living Room into the Dining Area/Kitchen. Light from North.


    Kitchen - Light from North


    Den - Room on the other side of the Entryway. Light from the South.

    I'd appreciate your thoughts!

  • 4 years ago

    I apologize for my comment re what is considered dated. My opinion is of course, just that, my opinion and we're all different. That's a good thing. Thank you, Beth, for pointing out my error. I stand corrected.