Software
Houzz Logo Print
lilrosa

Awkward Front Door - swing in left or right?

3 years ago
last modified: 3 years ago

We live in a 100 year old house. Previous owners replaced a crumbling fireplace by adding a closet to the 2nd room (our current office). This closet wall juts out partially in front of the front door entrance.

Currently, the front door swings in to the right. When we try to open the door to greet guests, it's very awkward because the wall makes it super cramped for us to open the door and for them to get in. To make it less awkward we have to get out of their way and open the door completely into the living room.









We're replacing the front door and now I have the option to change the swing of the door. However, if it swings to the left, it will bump into the frame/molding of the office door. We can add a corner stopper for this.

LEFT SWING

Cons: Will open toward & block office door. Is this a hazard? Will need stopper to protect office door frame. Husband is also concerned that the front door entrance will be reduced by the thickness of the door & we lose a bit of space to bring in large items. That's less of a concern for me because it's only 2 inches or so.

Pros: Smooth entrance flow. Can let guests in easily. Easy to bring in packages.

RIGHT SWING

Cons: Awkward cramped guest entrance, unless you swing it completely open to the wall. Also awkward and annoying bringing in large packages. I have to bump door completely open with my body to get in. A regular occurrence. The entrance flow just sucks.

Pros: Can swing door fully to the wall and move extra large items in if necessary (and use office opening for this as well).

Other notes: I wish I could move the door opening over into the living room, but it changes the face of the house on the outside. The porch columns frame the front door symmetrically.

What would you do?? Suggestions?

Comments (14)

  • 3 years ago

    This is a tough one! I think you want the door to swing to the left for a more welcoming entrance. Is there another door for bringing in larger items? Would it be possible to reduce the depth of the office door frame at all? It seems unusually deep for an interior door.

  • 3 years ago
    last modified: 3 years ago

    @msjoan Good observation on the deep office door! That doorway is 100 yrs old and so is that wall with shiplap. No idea why that wall is so thick & why it was built that way. I wonder if the wood for framing was just thicker?

  • 3 years ago

    In a number of other countries, exterior doors often swing out. It could be worth considering.

  • 3 years ago
    last modified: 3 years ago

    @S Mil Hmmm. That's interesting. Thanks for the tip. Didn't know that about other countries.

    I had only briefly considered this option & for some reason dismissed it previously. It might be the only comfortable solution! Any downsides to outward swing?

    I just read up a little more on outward swinging doors and there are security hinges to make the doors safer. Neat.

  • PRO
    3 years ago
    last modified: 3 years ago

    IMO remove the closet and have a proper sized entry or swing the door to the other direction.I just looked and you have a porch so maybe the outswing could work . I will say they seem odd to me since the guest is standing in the way.

    Rosa M thanked Patricia Colwell Consulting
  • 3 years ago
    last modified: 3 years ago

    @Patricia Colwell Consulting Thanks. It does seem awkward to open out toward guests on the porch. But I wonder if it feels better than the in-swing options?

    im not sure how feasible removing the entire closet is. Old homes are so limited in storage space as it is. We need the storage. But i agree that it wasnt well placed or thought out. 😣

  • 3 years ago

    Rosa, sorry for delay in my response. I have a home improvement project underway and was preoccupied with that.
    I have lived in homes with outward swing and found no drawbacks. Where space is limited they increase interior use. You cannot have a storm door, but your current photo did not show one in use now. Culturally, here in the States it may seem awkward at first, but it takes little time to get used to it. I do not recall any security issues.

    Rosa M thanked S Mil
  • 3 years ago

    Not common in most of the states, but Florida has one of the most stringent building codes in the United States, as all exterior doors must open outward if you live in South Florida. Outward opening doors provide you with an added layer of protection, as an inward swinging door only has a latch and a deadbolt to prevent it from blowing into your home.

    So it could easily work

    Rosa M thanked Diane
  • 3 years ago

    As Diane said: an outward swinging door is needed to get flood or hurricane insurance (in Florida), so if your area experiences high winds, it’s an addtl benefit.

    Rosa M thanked coray
  • 3 years ago

    We have an outward swinging door on the side of our house. The only downside we see is that sometimes deliveries placed in front of the door and we have to go around the house to get the food or package :)

    Rosa M thanked ohgoodness
  • 3 years ago

    If the front door can swing fully open for access to both the office and the living room, leave it that way. If someone is coming to your office, open the door halfway so the access to the office is the only choice.

  • 3 years ago

    @Andrea C This is so helpful! Thanks so much for adding the photo and your own experience. It's exactly our situation. So glad to hear it's working out for you. I think I'm leaning in this direction.

  • PRO
    3 years ago

    Agree with Andrea. Change the door swing. You’ll likely have to get a whole new door, but it’s worth it.

    Rosa M thanked Sabrina Alfin Interiors