I love chrome

Chrome works fine

Brushed Nickel would look great with the paint color. Chrome scratches too much. I think the tile should be a little bolder color... darker.

Brushed nickel. You didn’t ask but here’s my other input….I like the cabinet, counter and floor tile but the picket tile is an outlier…..it looks like it has a pink tone in it.

We are building a house. Kids bathroom has similar tones. Have chrome fixtures and they look nice installed. But I think brushed nickel would too. Either seems like a good choice.

Either will work. Satin nickel cost more but doesn't show water spots as much. We upgraded faucet and hardware to nickel but are keeping chrome shower and towel bars, the silver tones play well together.

I like polished chrome. Classic , timeless…
Very nice choices…

(Would you consider a white floor tile? Or a different color, to break it up some…?)

Here are just a few bathroom designs of ours that use similar colors to the ones you seem to be using. Take a minute to look at the hardware used in each:

Life of the Party · More Info

Smart Craftsman Remodel · More Info

Chatham Model Home · More Info

If you get chrome, you'll be constantly cleaning the water spots. I'd go with the brushed nickel.