Post a picture of the outside of your home so we can see what works with your paint color.

And where are you located. Some colors work best in cooler or warmer environments.

Sorry about that, I posted but it did not come through until this time. I am in New jersey. Thanks so much.

I would go with Slate over Weather Wood if it were me.

Are you keeping the green shutters?

Slate is pretty but may need to change the accent colors.

Pretty house! I don't think I could commit to a green roof - but that is me. I'd probably lean more neutral with a nice charcoal (not too tan but not too cold) - and remove the shutters to see if I liked the simpler façade

We had green shingles on a house once. I was so happy the day a tornado caused enough damage for insurance to pay for a new roof.

I don't think the green looks bad on your house, I just like the weathered wood better.

I think your house would look better without the shutters, also. Make sure you get some big samples and hold them up to your house or at least set them beside the house to see what they look like in real life.