Software
Houzz Logo Print
kendrahhendra

What to do able these cabinets?

3 years ago

I find these gaps unappectable. Our apartment is in an 80 year old building with crooked walls and ceilings. The whole reason I went with expensive custom cabinets is so they could scribe well to account for this.


Our CG aaid there is nothing to be done. I asked about caulking and painting the gaps. They are about 1/8” to maybe 1/4”. He doesn’t advise bit says he can do whatever we want but cautioned ”that caulking those areas would be irreversible. Cutting out the caulk would ship and scratch the paint and walls.”


I just got a call from the cabinet installer saying he is on his way to come caulk them.


Is caulking ok or not?






Comments (8)

  • 3 years ago

    Caulk is not a substitute for an inability to scribe. That gap is too large for caulk. Caulk will eventually separate and look pretty bad. It is the solution that the unskilled use to mask their lack of skill. This is a classic case of "custom does not equate to quality".


    That trim needs to be removed, and redone, with actual scribing to the ceiling happening. If that cabinet maker cannot do that, then a different someone somewhere else can. On the GC's dime.


    "Caulk is not an acceptable solution. An acceptable solution is redoing the trim, and scribing it to the ceiling. If he can do that in this visit, then he can keep the appointment. If he can not do that, who can? And if he can not do that, he does not need to keep the appointment."

  • 3 years ago

    How much money are you still holding on to? More than 10%? Collecting that last draw should be motivation enough to fix some of your issues. He needs a serious conversation about that too.

  • 3 years ago

    I owe 50% so still motivation.


    Sounds like I should have them remove fill pieces, scribe new piece, and install those. I honestly dont know how scribing is done. Can someone explain?

  • 3 years ago

    I would want it done right. Caulking is not the right way to do this.

  • 3 years ago
    last modified: 3 years ago

    who installed the cabinets? scribing is finish carpentry 101. this is our moulding scribbed to the ceiling in our 1952 house


    im not a pro so not sure if the fillers can be removed and replaced or if all cabinets would have to come down first.

  • 3 years ago



  • 3 years ago
    last modified: 3 years ago

    If it were my house, I'd be okay with caulking for the gap on the right side--that one doesn't look like it's more than a quarter inch at the widest spot, which is the most I'd want to caulk. (1/8" or less would be better.) I'd be less happy about how they wrapped the corner of the door moulding. The one at the top would be unacceptable--that is too big to caulk and should have been scribed to the uneven ceiling. Once they got it to 1/8" or so, I'd be okay with caulk there too. I'd want the top and side trims to look seamless, though, and they don't even seem close.

    All that said--from your past posts, it's not clear to me that this contractor is skilled enough to do that work. You might have to cut your losses and look for someone else to come do the final cleanup of the trim, unfortunately. I think they should be able to do the trim without taking the cabinets down--we had our cabinetmaker out at one point a few years after our cabinets were done to redo some sections of trim where the house had settled and created new gaps at the ceiling, and he did that in half a day on site without touching the cabinets themselves.

  • 3 years ago

    Update - Millworker came and BS'ed me while his worker caulked the space. That evening we sent an email to our GC, through whom we make payments, saying we are withholding our final 50% for the millworker because of the poor finishe job. We want new panels scribed. Our architect called and said they want to do whatever they can to make us happy and will remedy the situation. I told them newly cut panels. I had not even noticed the other side of the kitchen where the whole side of a cabinet was horribly installed. This is not a fill piece. My architect suggesed a very slender piece of trim cover this gap. That sounds most reasonable to me. Who knows if this second go round will be any better - do they actually have the skills to do it correctly this time? Who knows.