Software
Houzz Logo Print
gelman_laurie

Please help me pick tile and counters after flood

3 years ago

We had a major plumbing leak three days ago, resulting in loss of our kitchen ceiling and requiring replacement of back splash tile and one countertop. The trouble is I have no idea how to go about matching what is there. We’ve been very happy with the kitchen since buying 8 years ago. The only thing we would have like to change would be lighter countertops (the espresso shows every crumb!) and converting the dual height island to one counter level. The counter we lost is the one under the windows. So insurance is covering replacement of both espresso countertops and all backsplash tile. What would work well with the existing finishes? And, should we take this opportunity to lower the island too? Unlike most islands, it has an induction cooktop (not the sink). Thank you so much for any and all ideas! We were not planning to renovate and I am feeling overwhelmed, not to mention trying to function without a kitchen with two kids and two dogs :)

Comments (7)

  • 3 years ago

    I think you could do a simple subway tile, with a little surface pattern, with white grout so that the island counter becomes the centre point of a classic white kitchen. Counter wise, pulling from the island, you might be able to move towards dark shade in a solid colour, say a charcoal or dark grey, but probably not go into the solid blacks.

  • 3 years ago

    Gives a little movement

  • PRO
    3 years ago

    How does a flood ruin a stone countertop please?

  • 3 years ago

    Thank you! We have similar tile in our bathroom with some movement. I’m having a hard time picturing a counter that would work. Re the flood, the stone is not damaged directly from the water but is likely to be damaged when we demo that wall (which is soaked). Our priority is to save the cabinets.

  • 3 years ago

    I think simplifying your finishes would be an update. Since you have two cabinet colors, I'd go with one countertop everywhere. Can you replace the island counter? Even though leveling it out would be an updated look, if you aren't moving the cooktop, I'd leave it as two levels. Or if you keep the island stone, I think you should choose a plain off-white that is the color of the lightest part of your island stone. And is that tile where the counter stools are? Is there a way to make that section the same color as the rest of the island? Your kitchen is nice but I think some simple changes would give it a refresh. If you wanted to go a step further, you could swap out the hardware and pendants too. I'm sorry you're having to go through this unexpected remodel--it's so hard to not have a working kitchen!


    Here are pictures with dark wood + white cabinets. A plain white or stone with subtle veining for the countertop would be pretty. The subway tiles recommended above would look nice.





  • 3 years ago

    Thank you so much Stiley! Your picture is perfect and really inspiring. What a gorgeous kitchen. That’s not tile where the counter stools are, but some sort of wood paneling with a blue grey pattern. I would love to lower the island because it would be much more functional with small kids. I’m curious why you wouldn’t do that without relocating the cooktop? Safety concerns?

  • 3 years ago

    Yes, just for safety. I would worry about hot oil splattering or steam from boiling water etc. Or kids' papers getting onto the cooktop, although that's less of a concern with induction.