You do know that tile should be removed before installing the LVP? As for color I don't love any of those but lighting has such a huge effect on flooring my advice change all the lighting to LED 4000K then see what looks right . Remember the flooring you have is also having an effect on the new samples .but from those 3 samples and what I can tell the one you think is too brown is the one I would choose with your cabinets.

Grand Canyon definitely. Carlsbad is too gray. Smoked Pearl is too busy. For durability, make sure the specs are:

• at least 5 mm
• waterproof

Agree with Grand Canyon as best choice.

Thank ALL of you. We were told by our contractor we do not have to remove the tile but I'll double confirm with him. Yes, all the flooring we are considering are waterproof and 20 mm. Please give me ideas if you have specific flooring colors/brands you think would work better if you have time. It's not too late for me to find others.

I vote for Grand Canyon as well.

Grand Canyon! Very pretty!

I would worry about doorways and appliance clearances (esp the DW) if you’re going over the tile so make sure to talk with your contractor about the plan

Yes, he has checked all of that even baseboard issues. He's done a LOT of these so we are pretty confident he knows what to do. Thank you!!!

I vote for grand canyon.