Software
Houzz Logo Print
kazukoono1

Your Siding Choice?

3 years ago

Have to replace ALL of our siding. What is your choice of the least maintenance, most sturdy and reliable against the extreme weather elements.

Comments (12)

  • 3 years ago

    Vinyl. Hardie board. LP Smart Side. What style? Application? Exposure? Location? Context is key.

  • 3 years ago
    last modified: 3 years ago

    Thank you Millworkman, Contemporary home,

    Looking at Hardie Board but some say it retains too much mositure leading to mold. Not interested in painting every few years, we also have birds that love to peck out challenging rhythms. We live in some extreme weather so high heat, freezing cold and humid summers. We have experienced hail too. Want to add study insullation, any siding with a bit of thickness is helpful too

    Not interested in vinyl

  • 3 years ago

    Maybe, you need to consider having your house stuccoed?

  • 3 years ago

    Vertical steel siding is another option. A friend had a woodpecker problem and replaced his T-111 siding with vertical steel. EDCO product out of Minnesota.

  • 3 years ago

    kazukoono1-

    . My house was built 22 years ago with board and batten style Hardie siding. It's been repainted once...because the paint has faded a bit and I wanted to change the color. The siding is still pristine; no moisture problems. And I live in the rainy Pacific NW where you can count on some form of precipitation almost daily for about 5 months. Hardie products are great. You just want to make sure you use an installer who is certified as competent by Hardie so you'll get the best result.

  • 3 years ago

    Windows...-

    Not my experience at all with Hardie. Please explain...

  • 3 years ago

    My barn is Hardie and does not stand up to horses. It also crumbles if you try to screw or nail anything into it.

  • 3 years ago

    Any suggestions for alternative to Hardie? I recently heard Hardie may chip. Crumbles with screws or nails? This is concerning

  • 3 years ago

    Vinyl is pretty typical here in Northern Utah. It's not my favorite but the no maintenance makes it my favorite.

    But all vinyl is not the same, color matters. Our home is a light green-grey. The west side looks good 7 years later. Another home that is 6 years old has dark green siding. The west part of their home is starting to look a little warped. Another, even newer home, has dark barn red. Their west side is very warped and, on south side, they put board and batten, and its also warped and looks terrible. This is my long way of saying I'd stay away from dark colors in vinyl.

  • 3 years ago

    "I recently heard Hardie may chip. Crumbles with screws or nails? This is concerning"


    I don't know where you're hearing this. It is true that Hardie is very rigid and could be damaged by an incompetent person bashing away trying to hammer a nail into a corner of the siding. When I've had to mount things on the house, like house numbers or a garden hose reel, I've pre-drilled the screws holes with masonry bits and never had a problem. It's going on 22 years and I don't think you could find a chip or flaw anywhere. I also have three friends with Hardie siding and their experience is the same. Qualified Hardie installers know how to side with Hardie and not damage it. And once it's installed it will last longer than you will. I suggest you look at a couple of houses with Hardie installed; that may be more instructive than anecdotes.

  • PRO
    3 years ago

    Have to pre-drill it as mentioned. Requires more delicate handling on installation, but if handled by competent installers, it's a non issue. Again, if you don't live in a fire belt, zero reason to run it over and LP product.