When you ask about a specific thing please post pics of that item. I di go look IMO even the small one is 1/2 the width of the island and the large forget it .I do not see much other lighting so what else do you have for lighting?

Thanks. We also have a built in l shaped Bench in kitchen that will have this pottery barn Lucca chandelier above the table

similar sized island like yours.

are there diff sizes for these PB lights?

some of the pics of them look very large

I also don't care for larger lights w/shortened chairs.

Here's a guide

Seems fine. You can try hanging a balloon or cardboard cutout to see how it feels.

Agree that you need other sources of light, though -- especially over the working surfaces in the rest of your kitchen! Sink? counters?

Not a comment on size but I have a similar style all clear glass pendant that I can't wait to have replaced next month as the glass always looks filthy. Dust, smudges, etc. I clean them and they look gross the next day.

I agree the clear glass pendants in the kitchen require regular cleaning. They simply don’t clean up well unless taken down and washed.

Just some ideas for your inspiration:

https://www.lightsonline.com/42456nbr-kichler-everly-1-light-mini-pendant-in-natural-brass?page=1

https://www.lightsonline.com/pd470108bggo-halston-1-light-pendant-in-brushed-gold?page=1

https://www.lightsonline.com/6551801en3-848-visual-comfort-studio-norman-1-light-pendant-in-satin-brass?page=1

https://www.lightsonline.com/trade-winds-templeton-12-pendant-in-natural-brass?page=1

https://www.lightsonline.com/z-lite-743p8-hbr-z-studio-linen-pendant-1-light-pendant-in-heritage-brass?page=1

😆Yep I climb up there to clean mine. Which I need to do before Thanksgiving.