Software
Houzz Logo Print
margarethartman

Neutralizing red oak using Duraseal with hint of Special Walnut

2 years ago
last modified: 2 years ago

I think I have read every post on red oak flooring and I have yet to find any posts on someone using Duraseal special walnut mixed with either neutral or fruitwood. Has anyone tried a blend? I need to come up with 3 blends to try before samples go on our floor. For now, I am playing with stains on a plank swatch. Straight fruitwood is too yellow and neutral too red. I have mixed 3 parts Fruitwood with 1 part country white and like how it came out. The grain recedes a bit which is preferred, and the white tones down the yellow. Duraseal told me not to use white unless I want to see a fair amount of pink. They recommended Special Walnut. However, Special Walnut is too dark a stain for us. I have both dark furniture and walnut and cherry cabinets. I want a relatively light colored floor to contrast and complement. (close to natural with hint of pigment to curb the red and yellow). Has anyone mixed Special walnut with fruitwood or neutral to keep floors light yet minimize the red in the grain? If so, what ratio did you all use and do you have photos to share? Any assistance is most welcome. Thank you.

Comments (8)

  • PRO
    2 years ago
    last modified: 2 years ago

    First is the plank the same wood exactly as your floors ? I have never had liuck with doing red oak lighter without the pink being obvious so speacial walnut to me is the right choice .Dark floors are beautiful and even with dark furniture area rugs help break up the all wood look .

  • PRO
    2 years ago

    Stick with the stains straight out of the can. Or you will never be able to replicate it for a touch up or repair.

  • 2 years ago

    Thank you all. Patricia, yes - the plank is from the wood that will be used for the floor. The company doing the floors will also do a sample of the stain on a section of the actual floor so I can see it in my home with the light we get. I am currently just trying to narrow it down to 3 stain blends to try without making fancy concoctions.
    Pgjs, thank you for the photo - those floors are beautiful. And it’s a good starting point for me. I will try a 1:1 sample and a 2:1 sample of neutral/special walnut. I definitely don’t want pink but I don’t mind some red tones. I want to soften and ‘brown’ the res. I may be one of the few people who still likes warm red tones.

  • 2 years ago

    I did have another 2 questions. One pertains to number of finish coats. We are using Bona Traffic HD. How many coats should we put on the floors? 2 or 3? My floor guy thinks 2 is plenty to last a very very long time. I know some use 3 coats but is that overkill and unnecessary? The other question is more of an opinion request pertaining to sheen. I love the look of both matte and satin. Satin is classic. Matte is modern. We have a contemporary home with medium light. We do have a dog and a child. We do not wear shoes in the house. Does one wear better or show fewer scratches? I have never tired of our current satin floors but wonder if the same would hold true of matte. Any thoughts, comments and feedback is most welcome. Thank you

  • PRO
    2 years ago

    Most of your questions should be answered by reading the manufacturer's instructions. They are who provide the product warranty, if those instruction are followed. Your florring professional should also read and follow directions. Many don't.

  • 2 years ago

    Has anyone ever mixed Special Walnut with Fruitwood?


  • 2 years ago

    Has anyone used Bona Naturale as a sealer? I know it has some white in it and gives floors the appearance of raw wood. Does the color settle a bit after a few weeks? It can look quite bleached. Any thoughts and comments are welcome