No vessel…go rectangle it gives a clean updated style.

Agree no vessel...too much splashing. I'm in the middle of doing a bathroom for a client. Going with Corian with integrated sink.

As far as ovals or rectangles go, they all basically look alike and are with in 1" of each other. I happen to prefer a rectangle but mostly because I have always had an oval ( better for a small vanity ). The Devonshire adds a nice detail to the sink and the semi recessed really makes a nice statement ( just watch the height of the vanity - they can sometimes be a little too high )

Except for the vessel, you really don't pay attention to a sink until you are washing your hands.

I can say that we had flat bottom sinks in our showroom bathroom and they were horrible . You would have to splash the water around to rinse them ( they were about 21" wide). So glad to get rid of them.

Good luck - any of the ones you are looking at are great!

None of the sinks on my list are flat bottom. There is a "matching" Kohler Artifacts sink, but I decided against it because it has a flat bottom.

I've had vessel sinks and I don't think I would select one again. If I did it would have to be extremely low to the counter & then use a wall-mounted faucet.

Thanks. I considered wall-mounted faucets, but have several issues with it:

1) the faucet selected, Kohler Artifacts, does not come in a wall-mounted version

2) for resale -- the primary user for this bathroom is my young adult son; but young children may have trouble reaching levers mounted to the wall

3) the electrical panel for the house is on the other side of the bathroom wall, directly behind where the sink will go -- not sure that I would want pipes running close to all that electrical wiring

No vessel sink.

Absolutely no vessel sinks. Too much splashing...always a mess around them that you have to clean up.

Definitely no vessel sinks!

My young grandgirls have no trouble reaching their wall-mounted faucet handles. They have a stool under the wall-mounted vanity anyway. Your other two reasons for not wanting wall-mounted faucet carry more weight with me.

I have a rectangle sink at work and don't like to clean it... need a bottle brush. I have one old shell-sculpted 1970s sink at home I hate, because I can't use a plunger with it and am constantly using Drano to keep it running.

I like your oval recessed sink selection.

IMO a huge overthink for a simple choice a nice undermout sink in either rect or round depending on the style of the vanity which we do not see. I do not prefer wall mounted faucets when something goes wrong it really goes wrong. I like my faucet to suit the space so show us that.

Thank you for all the comments on a vessel sink -- I have taken that one off the list.

Patricia, this will be a full gut and remodel., without moving walls. I don't know that showing the existing space will be helpful in choosing the sink. But here it is. Everything in the photo below will be changed, except for the entry door and the location of light switches. The current vanity is 22 x 46 inches. I think I can stretch the vanity to 52 inches wide. The original drop-in round sink is centered on the vanity. I would like to offset the sink toward the right-hand side, but I do not know if that is possible because of the electrical panel on the other side of the wall.

Yes overthinking