Siding issue - house next door extremely close

5 months ago

We're thinking of buying a 100+ year-old home, however the place next door is a mere 10 inches from our potential place (also a 100+ year-old place) on the west side. The siding from what we can see seems to be okay-ish with places that look old and worn... but nothing falling apart. No person would be able to fit through in order to fix it if an issue does pop up. Has anyone dealt with this before? If we buy it and do notice an issue (mold, water, etc.), how the heck would we be able to address the issue (assume having to go from the inside)? Because the homes are so close, I'm guessing it means it's fairly protected from the elements - but also it likely means siding has never been fixed in 100+ years. We don't want to purchase the place and just immediately have to throw a crazy amount of money at the problem. Attached is a picture that we can see, along with a google view of the narrowness. Any help would be appreciated!

Featured Answer

cat_ky

5 months ago

I would keep looking. That looks like a problem in the one area already, and will only get worse. Find a house, you can get around on all sides. A 100 yr old house, usually has other problems, that will require money on too, but, sometimes, they are well worth buying. This one would be a big NO for me.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (12)

millworkman
5 months ago
last modified: 5 months ago
You cannot fix or replace exterior siding from the interior effectively. Keep looking.
Related Professionals
Port Charlotte Kitchen & Bathroom Remodelers · Three Lakes General Contractors · Canandaigua General Contractors · Hagerstown General Contractors · Vincennes General Contractors · Anchorage Architects & Building Designers · The Colony Home Builders · Glassboro Painters · Lompoc Painters · Lynwood Painters · Mastic Painters · Hainesport General Contractors · Mansfield General Contractors · Springboro General Contractors · Wheeling General Contractors
PRO
Minardi
5 months ago
The only "solution" here would be to join one home to the other as a type of rowhouse. I don't even know the red tape for that, if the other owner would possibly agree to it. I mean, they have the same issue. And, who would want to live in a municipality that allowed only a 10" setback?
klem1
5 months ago
"And who would want to live in a municipality that allowed only a 10" setback"?

My thought exactly and could be only the first of many problems that follow.

HTH did they manage to build the second building in the first place?
PRO
Joseph Corlett, LLC
5 months ago
Apparently the adjacent building is brick, which explains how it was able to be built so closely. And 70 years ago, they didn't enforce setbacks too well. If you can't work out an ironclad agreement such as Minardi has suggested, I'd pass. A proper independent repair would be catastrophically expensive.
3onthetree
5 months ago
Can't really opine on whether you should buy the house. Looks like multi-family next door, maybe you're looking for land value in the future. It might be slightly helpful to know where the property line falls, but if reasons exist for buying that supercedes fixing the siding (and what looks like a porch that was enclosed), anything can be done and figured out with enough money and brains.
0
Nick Pennebaker
Original Author
5 months ago
Thanks all - really appreciate the comments and help. Yeah, it is multifamily next door that was built 30ish years after the original home. Obviously don't love hearing the words "catastrophically expensive" but I guess that's to be expected. All frustrating because it's a great place, but the building next door is definitely the issue.
0
Sigrid
5 months ago
If you like the house, you can get a quote from some contractor. Most sellers will allow that, unless they know the answer is "crazy expensive". You may need to put a deposit on the house, but you can be explicit that you'll want your money back if it fails inspection.
0
cat_ky
5 months ago
I couldnt stand living that close to my neighbor either, and since it is also multi family, that would be even worse. No privacy at all.
0
thinkdesignlive
last month
I’d pass.
0
millworkman
last month
" It might be worth reaching out to a contractor to assess the situation and explore solutions like extra protection or adjustments to the siding. "

Did you look at the pics and read the description @ HU-907127668 ?
klem1
last month
"It might be worth reaching out to a contractor to assess the situation and explore solutions like extra protection or adjustments to the siding."

You can't put a price on this kind of advice. 3 cheers for HU-907127668.
0