If that is the color family you are going with, they are so similar, flip a coin.

Agree they look similar. I might lean toward AG. Shutters should be half each window’s width which can be problematic on double and triple windows.

Hard to tell from online, but I see a pink-ish undertone in Loggia. Just make sure to get sample cans to test the colors. You can also order large swatches (9” x 14.75”) from samplize.com that are the actual paint, not computer generated.

I did see the pink tone too when I put it on my house to try all 3.

Your windows shouldn't have shutters - they aren't appropriate for triple/double windows (unless you get folded shutters that when opened up cover 1/2 of the window = fully covered window when both sides opened up.

Even when you don't install functional shutters, they should appear to be functional. Your home will look better without faux shutters that are too small.

Re: paint colors - between the two colors, I prefer the Analytical Gray. Loggia def appears to have a pink tone to it.

Are you set on only using this shade of paint for you home?

NO place for shutters so no . As for color what is driving the choice IMO a drak gray then wood garge doors with some glass would be my choice I think you see pink in the gray becuase you are testing it on green siding which BTW I see no where on that house

Agreeable Gray with off white trim. The painters will need access to the area behind the large and lovely tree, so you may want to have it professionally trimmed (lightly) before they arrive.