your gable isn't steep enough for a shake accent to look appealing.

I agree that the white accent siding does nothing for the look.

Yes, replace the white siding with a gunmetal color.

I would remove the shutters, they don't fit the windows.

Here's your house in gray siding, white trim and wood accents. Remove the shutters, enlarge the column, replace the sconce with a black larger model, and large black street numbers can be installed on the column. I also suggest a wood front door to balance the wood accents. Large pavers would look better than asphalt if you need so much parking space.

I think if you made the house all one color it would look better, no matter the color. You don't need a cedar accent. Gray with white trim is great, but so would be all white, a blue with white trim, soft green with cream trim --- you name it.

Agree with the all one color being the most appealing.

So many houses are gray go for something different. What company are you using for the siding - what are their color options?

No shutters, I know a lot on here say the sidelight is part of the door but I disagree - paint the sidelight the same color as the trim. Sage green is a great house color. Wrap the post so it is more substantial looking.

Move the house numbers ao they are visible.

There is too much stuff on your house. I agree that the all one color approach might be best.

Here's your house once some unnecessary elements are removed: shutters and railings.

You'll want to beef up that column that holds up the end of the overhang.

Thank you all for your comments! I really appreciate your help with this