Siding is bar harbor beige and shutters are deep caviar

An Architectural bronze wouldn't look bad there. What vinyl window? Most are available in any number of painted colors now.

I'd go with the bronze and the matching muntins for the windows.

The bronze matches the brick perfectly. Then get rid of any remaining white at trim and front door. Sharp.

I'd choose the Bronze.

Bronze, no shutter and a new color for the siding No white .. Nothing tricky .

Thanks everyone for the comments. When the bronze was mocked up (pics below) I was taken aback by how bold it looks

The white is too stark. Just a suggestion but would you consider removing the shutters? The bronze might be less bold without them. The windows aren’t really the right style for them, especially the uppers.

We considered removing the shutters! And are trying to make the uppers more symmetric remove the fake window/wood piece on the right.z

I am torn on the bronze because I feel it looks dated. One of the designers mentioned we have a tricky exterior.

Bronze is and always will be a color option for contemporary homes. It's not dated. The mock up is darker than the sample of bronze in your photo.

The color on your siding is too light nd that should be adjusted IMO.

Another vote for bronze. Very nice match with your brick and siding, and on trend with darker colors that are popular these days. White can look nice in the right color scheme, but on your home the stark white would look like you just chose it because it was cheaper, just doesn't fit well IMO.

Bronze windows, no shutters. You could opt to go darker on the siding, or if it's time to replace, switch to a more updated look w/this board and batten.

would look similar to this:

Here's a photo shop w/the windows, a diff door (more glass)

Some landscaping, address plaques, (two diff styles) and an updated light.

I gave you one light above,

This type of landscaping would look great in your flower beds.

here's another one in a bronze that would also work.