I like the arch top the best. I think the rectangular is too geometric with the tiles and window. Do you have plans to cover the windows?

I'd do a rectangular mirror, frameless, with the top edge even with the window trim.

https://www.lowes.com/pd/Better-Bevel-24-in-Silver-Rectangular-Frameless-Bathroom-Mirror/1000815830

Thanks Lyn. Thats an intriguing idea, thanks.

@katinparadise- thats what I thought when I spec’ed and ordered arched mirrors. Maybe I need some more dimension on the arched mirrors. they glued a gold arched mirror to the tiles and it looked awful!

I have since changed the light too to be horizontal…The windows will bot be covered.

I would not glue framed mirrors to a tiled wall. I would hang them on a french cleat or picture hanger.

I had 2 bathrooms with hanging framed mirrors on tile walls in my previous house, one on a french cleat and the other on a picture hanger. No issues with either.

No frame on the mirror and the exact size of the window and hung exactly the same as the window

I think the window is throwing things off visually, so could you maybe add trim to the window frame, then go on to the mirrors? I am obsessed with the tile wall, omg that is pretty

This is purely just a suggestion, but maybe finding a full-length mirror to hide that window completely, you still get the pretty tile, but it looks a little less off. The window messes the flow a tad, or lean in to the window and frame it and make it feel more connected

like this