Software
Houzz Logo Print
lesley_delle_grazie

Ceramic or hardwood flooring?

We are currently in the process of putting a kitchen addition on our home, as well as replacing the flooring on our entire main level. We also took down the wall which used to separate the dining room and the kitchen. My husband, always practical, wants to have porcelain tile installed on all of the floors apart from the living and dining rooms, where we plan to install new hardwood. I, on the other hand, want to install hardwood throughout, except for a tile "carpet" in our entryway. I believe this will keep everything so much more cohesive, and also help to keep everything open and "bigger, which was the point of the renovations in the first place. I need an argument as to the durability of hardwood floors today. I know that hardwood will not be as impervious to knicks, dents, and scratches, and that spills need to be wiped up quickly. I also cannot delude myself to the fact that our 14 yr. old twins will suddenly become conscientious, wiping up spills as they happen. Please help! I will try to post floor plans if I can figure it out.

Comments (16)

  • 12 years ago
    In my current home, I ripped out a mishmash of carpet, hardwood and tile to replace with all hardwood...the place looks more cohesive and also much larger
    Lesley Delle_Grazie thanked dclostboy
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    last modified: 12 years ago
    I would run the hardwood into the kitchen (I have had hardwood in every kitchen I have owned…no problem) and I would put the porcelain in the front hall.
    m.a.p. interiors · More Info
    Lesley Delle_Grazie thanked JudyG Designs
  • 12 years ago
    This is the floor plan.
    I guess what I really want to know is, how practical is hardwood in the kitchen? There is no argument that aesthetically it will look great, but for those of you have it, do you REALLY use your kitchen? My hubby and I, as well as our teenage daughter, all love to cook, and I've seen so many photos of pristine kitchens, which you know nobody cooks in.
  • 12 years ago
    Always hardwood in kitchens and "really" use them :)
    Lesley Delle_Grazie thanked dclostboy
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    In my opinion, ceramic or porcelain tile is more practical in a kitchen. Hardwood shows wear and tear and requires more upkeep to maintain. That being said, I have seen hardwood on many kitchen floors with carpet runners in the high traffic areas to keep it looking nice.
    Lesley Delle_Grazie thanked Mary Porzelt of Boston Kitchen Designs
  • 12 years ago
    There are porcelain tiles that look amazingly like wood. Perhaps this may be a compromise worth considering.
    Lesley Delle_Grazie thanked bellesum
  • 12 years ago
    I've had hardwood in my kitchen for over 10 years - no problems at all. The kitchen gets a daily good "workout". Once every two weeks I steam clean the floor and in between I use the moist swiffer sheets to wipe up cooking spills. Like I said - no problems - the floor still looks like new.
    Lesley Delle_Grazie thanked tara_1993
  • 12 years ago
    We have hardwood in the entire house, kitchen included. There is absolutely no problem with it. If there is a spill, I just wipe it off. The kids (9 & 12) wipe off any spills. There is no upkeep,,just vacuuming and wiping from time to time
    Lesley Delle_Grazie thanked printesa
  • 12 years ago
    last modified: 12 years ago
    I find porcelain tile to be so antiseptic...and impersonal. Especially if it's absolutely everywhere.
    Mine...100 yo hardwood except for black hex tile in my bathroom.
    Lesley Delle_Grazie thanked bungalowmo
  • 12 years ago
    Thanks for your input everyone, much appreciated! I've noticed a lot of the photos with hardwood floors have carpet runners in the heavy work areas, although I think I would use something more washable than oriental carpets. Bellesum, I had thought about the porcelain plank tiles, but I didn't want to use them in the living and dining rooms; too hard and cold (and in-floor heating for the entire main floor is definitely not in the budget!). I had actually found some that were very similar to the hardwood I had chosen, but the saleswoman in the tile store talked me out of trying to put the real wood and the tile "wood" next to each other. I like the argument for the lack of grout-maintenance Laurence, thanks! Looks like I will have to train the kids a little better about wiping up spills (not to mention Hubby!) and invest in a steam-mop.
  • 12 years ago
    I had porcelain tile in my last kitchen and hated it every second I lived there (12 years). IMO, if you have any sort of back, leg, knee or foot issue, you will hate standing on tile for any period of time. Every (and I mean EVERY) dropped dish shatters - including Corelle. Don't get me started on the HUGE hassle of trying to clean grout, especially after someone has dropped a full glass jar of tomato sauce on the floor.
    Lesley Delle_Grazie thanked orangecamera
  • 12 years ago
    Wood planks may have gaps. Think about cleaning tomato sauce between the gaps!
    Lesley Delle_Grazie thanked bellesum
  • 12 years ago
    Lou Manfredini "Mr. Fix-it" from WGN, states that hardwood floors have been in style for a hundred years and continue to be desireable in every market. You can refinish the floors every ten years or so and have them look new. But a patina of well worn wood floors has a charm that new wood doesn't.
    Tile, painfully hard on feet for any length of time, especially awful in kitchen if it's cold in there. Slippery when wet for you and toddlers. If you age in place, you'll slip and break a hip.
    Lesley Delle_Grazie thanked gailbk
  • 12 years ago
    I have hardwood floors in my kitchen for 16 years and they still look great. I just wipe up any spills. I am planning to build another house next year and will use hardwood again. I have tiles in my bathrooms and laundry rooms. Hate tile/grout.
    Lesley Delle_Grazie thanked Brenda Seals
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    In an earlier post someone recommended Porcelain Plank Tile. Check out Arizona Tile and Bedrosians...........wide spectrum of styles and sizes from those that look much like wood or the more contemporary ones that just "hint" at the look of wood without the heavy grain, etc. I just specified for project and Client loves it. It is extremely resilient and may answer both you and your husbands wishes. Good Luck!
    Lesley Delle_Grazie thanked Charette Design