Software
Houzz Logo Print
critter77

Keep or ditch the 70's built-in bookcase and cabinets?

12 years ago
last modified: 12 years ago
We just bought our first house and it comes with this massive built-in.

We can't decide if we want to keep it or demo it, as that it is included en suite to the master bedroom, and is made out of wood, so it is solid. We do have a lot of books that we could store there, but we don't think that is enough of a reason to keep it. We plan on refinishing the floors in Jacobean (dark brown) so we threw some white paint and a new handle to get an idea of what it could look like. (Excuse all the junk in the last photo.)

The first two photos show the built-in on the right, as well as its context to the master bedroom. The last photo is when we tried to prime it, but sanding and painting is going to take awhile, since it is covered with some kind of waxy finish that you really have to use elbow grease to sand off. Since we've never owned a home before, we've been learning by YouTube. :)

Any thoughts if we should keep it or for the space?

Thank you!!!!

Comments (29)

  • 12 years ago
    Great set up for a "study/reading" area! Would keep the built-in, maybe glazing over an off-white paint to give it some interest/age-
    critter77 thanked athtex
  • 12 years ago
    last modified: 12 years ago
    I would keep it too and paint it (or have it professionally painted...if it is solid wood, you have to know what you are doing and I am not very good at it...:-) ).
    I would transform this place into a nice home office and maybe divide from the "bedroom" with nice curtains... Unless of course you need a walk-in closet, because this place looks ideal for this!
    critter77 thanked despinach
  • 12 years ago
    I would keep it too. It's a great place for your books and other stuff, in the cabinets below. If you have the time , paint it, like you already did. Finding something else that fits there, will also take your time and probably more money than you're spending now.
    The lay-out of the built-in is timeless( I assume it's only the colour you don't like - neither do I- the white looks great.
    And like despinach suggested you can use curtains as a roomdivider, or sliding curtainpanels.
    Wish you luck in you new home!
    critter77 thanked Monique Barrow
  • 12 years ago
    I would keep the built-in and use the room, as others have said, as an office or huge closet! If you keep the natural wood color, you would need something large on the opposite wall to balance the room.
    critter77 thanked dianecourbat
  • 12 years ago
    If the waxy stuff becomes softer once you use spirit on it, it might be 'french polish'. It's a pain in the *%^$ to remove, but paint won't hold, so removing is the only option. Use scrapers instead of sanding paper to remove it and clean it with spirit afterwards (some old cloths and heavy rubbing). It could also be softened old stain (from furniture wax and such), which still is no fun job to remove (paint stripper might help).

    I'd say keep it if you have the patience to give it a new coat and handles. Most of these old built-ins are good quality and since you have the filling already, keep the cake ;)
    critter77 thanked rinked
  • 12 years ago
    From the second picture, I would say definitely keep it . Also, change out the handles to stainless or brushed nickel knobs, and move them more to the corner. There are tons of photos on this site for inspiration, if you search for "built in bookcase bedroom."
  • 12 years ago
    Keep it for your books. You're very lucky to have it.
  • 12 years ago
    I would definitely keep it.
  • 12 years ago
    I love bookcases and have 4 scattered around my house, but this is one I just don't like. It's too big, and overwhelms the room. See if you can break it apart and keep, but split if up, repaint it and go from there.
    critter77 thanked hayleydaniels
  • 12 years ago
    Keep it! Built in bookcases are very expensive to install and it sounds like these are in really good shape. Sanding, priming and painting is a pain, but I think you will love them in the end. They don't take up much space and they are so useful for book/display storage.
  • 12 years ago
    Even with the finish that is on the bookcase, you may not have to sand. Try, for one section, to wash all with TSP, prime with Zinsser (two coats) and paint a soft white. I have done this countless times on old Ethan Allen maple pieces and other furniture.
    critter77 thanked edithsmom
  • 12 years ago
    I wanted to thank everyone for their input. Just got home from working on it, but have a long way to go. Unfortunately, I have to sand everything, since the primer was sticking (despite washing with TSP.) Anyways, the sanding away the varnish has improved it, so I'm confident it will look great when it is painted!

    Interestingly enough, it looks like the rings in the wood were painted on - I sanded down some parts, and it looks like there is a light ring, but it was enhanced with paint.

    I'll definitely post photos of my progress!
  • 12 years ago
    I would keep them but i wouldnt paint them white as the one you have painted looks plain and cheap - sry thats my opinion
  • 12 years ago
    Keep it. I won't advise on painting because others already have. Having built in storage is a blessing in most homes. Change the hardware like the pulls on the cabinets, but trust me, you will find all sorts of things to fill it with, and you'll be amazed at how much it can hold.
  • 12 years ago
    Get rid of it. Too heavy and large.
  • 12 years ago
    How does it look nowadays?
  • 12 years ago
    I would paint white possibly put some moulding on doors to dress up add new handles. Some of the doors could have mesh door inserts. Lots of options. Good for storage wouldn't get rid of. Built ins are expensive. Just paint would be an improvement
  • 12 years ago
    Could add beadboard or wallpaper to the back of open shelving
  • 12 years ago
    probably won't look so nice with your wall color, but gray paint would look very nice on them. Also maybe wallpaper the back of the shelves?
  • 12 years ago
    I am a veteran do-it-yourselfer, and IMO you do not need a pro to do this. If there are any removable shelves or doors, remove them and paint separately. Rent a spray rig and prime, then paint the entire unit, same with doors/drawers/shelves. Use a satin, semi-gloss, or (for a modern pop) gloss white, like Benjamin Moore White Dove or Decorator White. Heck, you can even go to Lowe's and grab their off-the-shelf white.

    If you don't need the home office abutting your bedroom (I would not, but to each his/her own), that unit would make for an amazing dressing/prep/display room. I'd put everything I loved on that unit. It would be expensive to replace. However, if you are only "making do" and have an even better purpose for that room, don't hesitate to pull it out and repurpose those parts. You can install them elsewhere in your house, sell them to a worthy and needy buyer, etc. It's your home, do what you will love. Good luck!
  • 12 years ago
    I would keep the built in but it really needs updating. What you have could be the bones of a really fabulous feature in your master. I would replace the solid doors at the bottom with updated panelled doors, perhaps shaker style. And for the uppers, I would install coordinating glass doors. The bottom could be storage for almost anything and the upper would be a great place to store and display purses, evening bags, cool shoes, jewellery, etc. Paint out the whole thing white and add some funky clear glass hardware. Good luck!
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    I would keep it too... it looks like a great place to store stuff. I would look into painting it, and possibly hiring a pro.

    Good luck:)
  • 12 years ago
    Show us how it looks when you're finished.
  • 12 years ago
    My first instinct was to say rip it out, but when I saw where it was in relation to your bedroom, I think you should keep it. Don't paint it. You should probably have it professionally restored to it's original wood color/texture - or to whatever color compliments your other furniture. I love the suggestion about a walk in closet - but if you don't need that much space, the sitting room/reading room is a great use of the room. If you want to lighten up the look a bit, how about adding glass shelves - maybe smoke colored glass? Do you have any recent pix of what you've done?
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    It has potential so I wouldn't demo it. Painting it and changing the hardware are the way to go. Dress it up with accessories, small sculptures, books, and photos and it will give a completely different feel to the room.
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    Are you keeping it just because it came with the house or because you like it and will in fact use it? If you like it and will use it by all means keep it otherwise demo it.
  • 9 years ago

    If you need the storage for books, etc. and will benefit from using it, keep it. If you don't need it or will not use it, remove it. The space is nice for a reading nook/ small personal library or home office. If you keep, It definitely needs a make-over. I would refinish by painting and replace cabinet doors and update hardware. You may also consider replacing a couple of the lower cabinets with drawers or file drawers to more efficiently use the space. You could add lighting in the shelving. I would do something with the interior of the shelves. That paneling back of the unit has to go. The back could be painted to add a pop of color or you could wallpaper the back with a pattern and color that would complement the other items in the space.

  • 9 years ago

    I think you should keep them, definitely fills that space and is super convenient