Love them both, but I'd pick the smaller. No wait, the subway tiles. No, definitely the smaller!! I see your dilemma!!

I like the bigger stone on the left. Beautiful kitchen.

Right? It's hard I'm leaning toward the larger tile I think the mosaic might be too busy and too trendy

Gorgeous kitchen. Smaller feels more modern, larger feels more traditional. No wrong choice. Since I prefer classic, my vote is for the larger.

Thank you I'm happy with it too not quite finished but getting there

I'm also having the matching crown to the cabinets wrap around entire space including stairwell to finish the space do you agree?

Why don't you use the subway and the use the little as an accent under the hood or look at other small tiles, like chicklets. There are some with sparkle pieces scattered. It's a little of a glitz look, but gorgeous! Big subway fan!

I vote bigger on the left!

Bigger is better. I like the kitchen.

Love moldings! I would paint the railing white also. :)

The left, a classic subway tile is always a great choice!

Both beautiful choices. I am leaning towards the larger tiles though.

Beauty of a kitchen. I prefer the larger and yes for molding.......very classic.

Replying to Lisa731 my floor is ebony mixed with classic gray I was debating on matching floor on the oak and white on the rest suggestions?

I would not say that the smaller tile is more contemporary as artisans have been making mosaic tiles since the dawn of time. I would say that the larger tile has a more tailored and streamline look to it versus the smaller tile. On the other hand, because this tile is going behind the range and installed up to the bottom of the hood (I presume), from a cleaning and maintenance standpoint.. I would go with the larger tile. In addition, I too TRULY like what you have done with the kitchen. However, there is one thing that I see in the cabinetry above the hood. I am not sure if it's the angle of the picture, but it looks like the cabinet doors are slightly off center to the hood.

Another vote for the larger subway tile. The smaller tile is too busy.

Match the stairs to the floor stain. I would also look for carpet (thin) for the steps to run down center. It will cozy it up and help for sound. But go thin. It will be easier to clean. The sides would be exposed, so f the stain is not exact, it won't noble noticeable. Staircase should be all white.

I think the left looks more high end!

definitely subway tiles!

Subway looks more classic and will probably be easier to clean

Hi, Joey, I agree with Barbara, vote the left, big size. Not only expand the space, but also matches your cabinet.