Software
Houzz Logo Print
jorieny

dark finish or light ?

12 years ago
Hi Designers.
I am about to purchase the 84" http://www.restorationhardware.com/catalog/product/product.jsp?productId=prod150011 for our new dining room.

Other components in the Dining Room will be:
Wall color: Not selected yet but cool silvery white (Benjamin Moore suggestions welcome.)
Floor: whitewashed maple 2" strip flooring satin finish.
Windows and sunlight: great sunlight (mostly western) and is approx a 14' square with several doorways or doors to living room, kitchen, powder room and pantry off of it. We have 1 south-facing window, four west facing windows, and 1 north facing window. Views of mature yard.
Dining chair: We intend to use citrus green and chrome modern chairs that we currently own for the next 1-2 years (see attached images).
Sideboard/china cabinet: we will be keeping our mid-century sideboard (about 4'6" tall and 4' wide) in the room (see attached picture). It has a glass front and a typical reddish wood finish.
Overhead pendant or chandelier: TBD. I like http://www.potterybarn.com/products/3388303/?catalogId=33&bnrid=3318529&cm_ven=Google_PLA&cm_cat=Lighting&cm_pla=Pendants&cm_ite=CFL_Capiz_Flower_Pendant&srccode=cii_17588969&cpncode=34-128620937-2 but the stores don't inventory this lamp. Have any of you seen it or used it ? How much light does it provide ? Should I buy one or two for an 84" table ?

We want to create a modern-farmhouse aesthetic, light and airy, cohesive with the rest of the house, which is a 3-story, 100-year old farmhouse, simple, full of character, sunny.

So HOUZZ Braintrust, I need to make a decision about whether to order the table in the GREY Acacia finish or BROWN Acacia finish. In the RH store, the grey reads as a matt finish natural. Surface is absolutely smooth. It has a greater visual bulkiness. The brown, which is a dark brown, looks more refined. The legs tend to visually disappear, unlike the grey. The surface is grained and not absolutely smooth. Its more of a satin finish. If scratches were to appear on either finish, I think they would be easier to hide on the brown acacia. If we ever needed to change the look of the table, I think the grey acacia would be an easier surface to paint or wrap in sheet metal or leather. The brown is the safe bet. The grey challenges me aesthetically but I think might be the right choice for the look we want to achieve in this house. I need thoughts from all of you.

Comments (15)

  • PRO
    12 years ago
    I agree, a dark floor can blend with lots of different styles. Here is an oiled charcoal finish over white oak as an example. Let me know if you have any wood flooring questions. joel@oakandbroad.com
    jorieny thanked Oak & Broad
  • 12 years ago
    Thanks to you both but the question is about the DIning Room table, not he floors. I love those floors you showed here. But I have 2" maple floors that we are going to heavy whitewash. So the question is dark or light dining table from RH...
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    Hi! I think the gray would work lovely as a compliment to your whitewashed floors and your hutch. With the color of the hutch, I think the darker color of the table would try to compete, rather than compliment. I checked the link to the chandelier and the size shows 15" in diameter. Definitely 2 for a table the size you are going with. I have also seen them clustered in a group of three, hung at varying heights and they look beautiful. I will try to see if I can find them at another store for you. I know One Kings Lane had them previously. I will also try to find a grouping photo and show you. Good luck and I'll make another post if I find any info for your.
  • 12 years ago
    last modified: 12 years ago
    Love the idea of the Lime green accents with the table. As far as wall color, you might want to go with a more brown-gray. (suggestions below)

    And what I think is very stylish is mixing your chairs up as far as the dining table. You do not have to match them all as done years back. You could put 2 of the chairs separate with a small round table to add a nice seating area nearby.

    This color could go on one wall as a Accent:
    Kelly Moore · More Info


    The second one has that Brown-Gray look that would so complement your dining area.

    Honore-Transitional Dining Room · More Info


    Read about the colors in the third picture. Light color but very nice and rich.

    Traditional Family Room · More Info


    Here is where I got the ideas from: http://www.houzz.com/gray-brown-paint-color
    jorieny thanked Lynnie
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    Try this link for the 15" version of the chandelier. They come in other sizes, but I need to find them for you!

    http://www.lighttrends.com/product_p/wa-venus.htm
    jorieny thanked Arielle and Archer
  • 12 years ago
    I cant thank you guys enough. Still waffling about dark brown or light grey table. Both will be nice. Just cant figure it out?! Not typical of me at all.
  • 12 years ago
    If you can, post pictures of the 2 tables and we can compare.
  • 12 years ago
    Hi Lynnie,
    This link below will show u the dilemma. Im choosing betw Brown and Grey Acacia.

    I am about to purchase the 84" restorationhardware.com➤ for our new dining room.
  • 12 years ago
    Shoot, the link didnt copy. Its in the 1st line of orig discussion post.
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    Grey!
  • 12 years ago
    Okay, I would go with Grey Acacia
  • 12 years ago
    I ordered the grey acacia table tonight, thanks to all of you experts, the opinion of a friend, and a 3rd visit to the showroom. I really appreciate your thoughts everyone. Once we are moved in and the table is set for a dinner party, I'll take a photo and post it here so you can all take a collective bow. :)
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    Congratulations jorieny! I hope you love the grey and can't wait to see it all set up.
  • 12 years ago
    OMG, I just got to the bottom and you've decided! Good for you! Gasp, I know, scary gulp! It was a difficult choice because neither is a bad choice. You will be thrilled!