We ordered new quartz countertops for our kitchen, except the 'new' arrived with a bullnose edge instead of the eased (square) edge I specified. Finger-pointing aside, I am now faced with the following options.

Expensive option: Place a new order to get what I want, and suffer the disruption, delay, and inevitable debate about who bears what additional cost.

Suggested option: Re-fabricate the new counters and create the eased edge I want. However, this will reduce the depth of the counter and necessitate installation of a quartz backsplash to fill the gap. This will change my tile design (subway tile to abut countertop) and complicate or eliminate tile placement under two windows. And it's only a partial solution - an entirely new cut of quartz will be required for the island.

Quickest and cheapest option: Accept the bullnose countertops (for a negotiated discount?) and keep the subway tile design as originally planned. I have read that some people prefer the softer edge of bullnose in the kitchen and that it is less prone to chipping. Aesthetically I prefer eased edge, but perhaps bullnose edging would be less obtrusive than a quartz backsplash.

Voila, my kitchen (below) in its current state of disrepair. The selected quartz and subway tile are also shown; paint colour is BM 'Thunder'.

Please weigh in - all opinions and recommendations welcome!