Software
Houzz Logo Print
ilikewinter

Bone Meal Smells Terrible- solution please!

17 years ago

I used Dr. Earth's fish bone meal this past week and thought the smell would die off (like with liquid fish emulsion) but it has just gotten worse. I live in an apartment building and my plants are by a shared stairway; I feel terrible for my neighbors who are having to deal with the smell as they use the stairs.

Please tell me there is a (organic) way to solve this problem quickly! I am also having a group of women over on Wednesday (in three days) who are going to be looking at my garden for tips and ideas and I'm nervous that the smell will turn them off to organic gardening! Hopefully there is a solution that will solve the problem before then...?

Thanks in advance!

Comments (6)

  • 17 years ago

    Perhaps flush the containers under water to remove the rotting organic matter that is making the odor and then fertilize with something less odoriferous?

    It's difficult to put dead fish parts in an indoor container and not have some odor ;)

  • 17 years ago

    I'm with justaguy: treat it as you would an old houseplant that needs to have the salts run thru. Run as much water from the top out (remove the drip tray) as you can. Yes, you will leach out some of the desirable stuff, but it sounds like you're in a time crunch here.

    Alternately, you could (EEEHHH I hate to even suggest it--I don't know what your planting is and if it will just keel over from this kind of treatment; use your best judgement) unearth the pot onto its side and start over. Remove all the offensive soil material and replace it with some new, and skip the stinky stuff this time? Maybe check the package directions; if you have the plant in an enclosed area and the product is for outdoor-only use, then look for another way to add the nutrients you need.

    My guess is that you won't recommend to use this stuff when your group comes over! Good luck, and be sure let us know what works for you--just in case the same thing happens to someone else!

  • 17 years ago

    Maybe you could buy a small bag of aromatic bark mulch and put that over the soil, at least temporarily, to cover the odor.

  • 17 years ago

    Hi All-

    They are all outdoor plants- vegetables and such and the fish bone meal was so highly recommended (by a balcony gardening book!) that I thought I really had to go out and get a box of it. (Not cheap, sigh.) It was my first application and there is still so much of the box left that I'm a little saddened about it.

    I do always flush the plants through whenever I water and there are no drip trays underneath, but maybe I just need to run a lot of water through them. The problem is also the neighbors underneath dealing with water gushing down on them (especially fish water!). I will give it another go, though, when everyone's at work and will also give the mulch a try as well.

    There's not a liquid out there that might neutralize these kinds of smells, is there?

  • 17 years ago

    no, nothing safe for plants is going to neutralize the odor of rotting fish.

    My personal suggestion is to stick with non rotting, water soluble ferts for container plants.

    It gets the nutrients to the plant immediately and has no odor or critter attracting properties.

  • 17 years ago

    I've been using fish and seaweed emulsion (fish emulsion smells for a short time then goes away in a few hours), but I don't have anything for phosphorous- any suggestions?

    Thanks!

Sponsored
Columbus' Home Design Experts Specializing in Custom Cabinets