Software
Houzz Logo Print
hzdeleted_19705527

How does one make suggestions in instances like...

17 years ago

Well before I get going here, I don't want this to proceed as if I'm bashing someone. I'm just using this image as an example simply because it's a good example...but it's an example ONLY.

How does one make suggestions to a person on these forums who requests input, who needs help on a project but...it's pretty obvious that that person has no sense of composition or design? I mean, I see this so frequently where the person obviously really needs help, but I'm like...where could I possibly begin?

Ok, to the example. I ran across this image in one of the other forums. The person was asking for help. The project seems like a relatively easy one, if it was my hillside. I'd like to think I have somewhat of an eye for basic composition. I was good at art in school. I was lousy in math. I liked natural and biological sciences but I wasn't so good at chemistry or physics. So how does one make suggestions to another who pretty obviously has absolutely no sense of composition or design?

{{gwi:49113}}

-Ron-

Comments (12)

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    First, you just don't respond to a lot of posts when your first feeling is, where could I begin?
    Then, it's usually safe to start with the old form vs. function discussion and what are the goals--erosion control, pleasing design, colorful plantings, etc. Then you have to rely on some general principles like, the eye tends to "like" some things in groups vs. scattered about, your vision tends to like to move from grouping to grouping--heck, I don't know!

    And you can always preface with something's being your personal preference/opinion rather than from the stone tablet of design --"When using stone in the garden, I prefer to try to attempt natural groupings, partially buried stones, to make it look like they were meant to be there..." that sort of thing.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Gently!! or "if it were mine I think I would" or I think on that slope I would do......" People want ideas given to them not to be told they are doing everything wrong. In the above pic I think this was their "starting point" wanted to get started before the slope washed out. Money is often a constraint also, people put everything into getting the house & then find that there is work to do to keep things from "slipping away" My house was a piece of ground & we came every night & did things they don't do out here, insulated all the walls by headlights of our car, stained the mopboards as I hated white dirty looking ones, insisted on outlets on each wall of a room, & in the bathroom & not outside in the hall. We had my dad put in the flashcoved Congolum in bathrooms, we hired company to do carpet. So thought we handled it all & moved in & stood looking at back yard & after staring awhile realized they had the entire thing sloping into the LR area where patio would go. Builder would not do a thing about it & said if we wanted it changed to do it ourselves.Lucky for us a wonderful old wheelbarrow was left behind & we did, about 2 ft of dirt down to make yard slope out not in towards sliding glass doors. We decided that wasn't enough in case of major rainfall(rare)so ran a drain all the way to front of house to the front sidewalk as did the neighbor following our lead. It was smart choice as it did end up taking water out when it was heavy rain. Earthquakes have changed yard some- 1 low spot but not much of a problem, my dad built total of 10 homes so I had hammer in my hand when very young & learned from a true craftsman. He's 93 now & can't do it anymore as eyesight going. Anyway no matter how carefully you thought you checked out the house before you moved in, things can come up & this is wonderful place to get help!!

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I'd probably take the poster's photo and open it in one of my graphics programs. I'd draw in red where I might place the stones if I were doing the project, adding visual representations of anything else I thought was needed.

    Then I'd post the altered picture, saying that something like 'this' looked better to me, and I'd explain why in the simplest terms possible.

    Sometimes it's easier to show somebody something, than try to explain it. It's easier to grasp a new concept that way, too, imo.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Many requests for help are beyond the scope of my experience, including your example, so I read and move on. Other requests that I could answer leave me with that feeling, "where do I possibly begin" and it's too time-consuming to explain everything -- I'd have to write a book -- so I don't respond. Time permitting, I'll at least point the person in the right direction, i.e. "gather up the scattered tombstones and rearrange them into a dry streambed on a diagonal." Or show a photo of a completed, well-executed garden of similar elements and structure, and hope it gives the poster an 'aha!' moment.

    Very often my objective is to try to get the original poster to view the garden differently -- big picture instead of small picture, exuberant instead of ordinary, imagine the mature result beyond the moment of installation; I like to encourage spatial awareness, get people to think three-dimensionally while considering context. (Your example above is two-dimensional thinking devoid of context superimposed on a very 3-D location.)

    I love, love, love this example of fresh thinking, and I hope the Deziner does not object to this link.

    Here is a link that might be useful: 3D thinking made real

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Playing Devil's Advocate a bit....Maybe the starting point, particularly in the example above, would be to ask what they are trying to achieve. The example does look a bit weird but if I try to think of what it would look like in a few yeas' time when the plants have grown a few seasons and there is accumulated dead organic matter obscuring the rocks, I can see that it might have resemblance to a rocky bank that would look more natural. The rocks and decaying organic matter would help hold moisture and reduce erosion. While bigger rocks spaced more randomly and buried deeper in the sand might look better as a starting point, the bank might not look as bad or unnatural a few years out. Maybe the OP was trying to recreate some paticular scene that appealed to him/her. Maybe the OP of that photo was expecting people to 'see' the future as he/she did. Or maybe he/she just has no design sense. But I think the starting point is to give the OP the benefit of the doubt by asking what they were aiming for, try to connect with their vision, and link your suggestion to how to make improvements to achieve their vision - not yours.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    It all depends on how the question is asked. If this picture was posted to show off the posters design skills it would be impossible to say anything that wasn't rude. Another thing to take into consideration is that due to the medium there will be others reading, for a variety of reasons and some will be looking to the responses so that they can learn and a thread is not owned by the original poster.


    In a professional situation someone would show their work, as Michelle does, and state what the criterion is (its amazing transformation and tight spatial layout) and this is where criticism should be aimed. To go on about the lack of lawn would be missing the point.


    On an amateur board such as this it is difficult to know what a person wants or how serious their intentions, when someone asks a specific question, "do you think I have too many rocks of the same size in my hillside garden?" for instance what is the answer they are looking for? Yes? No? or yes because ....and it would be better if....look at this web site, read this book etc. Remember that some are reading to learn so for them and not necessarily the OP a fuller answer is better as a discussion often follows.


    Then: the first response is often the one that sets the tone and says that at least one more person is interested in this topic. If this first response has words like wow! and thank you for sharing in it the thread is doomed.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    fouquieria,

    When you chose to highlight this, did you bother to read the responses I posted? Your comments seem a little disingenuous to me-are you really concerned about how to answer or did you want an opportunity to highlight your own skills over the OPs?

    The OP titled her post, "I need help with my rock garden" which indicated to me that she was sincerely looking for help. We went back and forth a little and she really does want ideas. She posted in the Hillside Garden forum, if anyone wants to pick up the thread. I think sunnyca and woodyoak are exactly right and I wish I had said more of some of what they suggested.

    This was my first response to her: "Is this a full-sun spot? Are you near the coast (sand?) I would put some natives in the garden. I would be sure to have a mix of sizes for variety. You could put a tree on the hill. Crape myrtle would be pretty, or a shrub that has a weeping shape to enhance the hill. Some grasses might be nice (if you are near the coast, sea oats are pretty). If the garden gets shade, hostas are always wonderful. Some evergreen plants are nice, too, so you have winter interest-do you get winter in zone 8??? Natives may do better for you, although maybe that is what you have-hard to tell from the photo and I'm no expert, anyway! You may also need to water a fair amount until everything is established.
    I would also partially cover some of those rocks, so they look as if they belong and aren't just dropped like marbles. Some look as if they are laid out in rows, but that could just be the camera angle. Maybe you could roll several closer to each other to make a threesome in a triangular shape (just not in a row) to mimic a larger boulder. I think it might have worked better if you had some really big stones in there, but you can still get that effect now if you want it.
    I think this will be lovely once your plants fill in and you did a great job with your steps. I need to do that on my hill, but I just can't lift and dig like I used to. Oh well Hope this helps. I am sure much wiser folks will give you even better ideas."

    I tried to give her some positive comments and to encourage her. Gardening is truly a learning experience and we all have strength and weaknesses-hers may be garden design, yours may be a lack of empathy or social skills, whatever-we all make mistakes, some more severe than others; some easier to fix than others. I know a lot of people don't appreciate the advice they get, but if I can, I will still try to help someone who asks for it. I know a lot of you are pros and your input is always terrific, but sometimes we amateurs can help some, too. Now I know she lives near Augusta GA, but in S.C., has sandy soil, etc., etc. I added a few ideas after my first follow-up. I had hoped someone would give her better advice than mine, but at least she got a response. Seems no one else was willing/able to help her and I wondered at the time if this was her first foray into posting on GW. It can be disappointing when someone gets no responses-not that any should feel obligated to answer. I think it is fine to pass when you don't feel you have anything you could say.

    Nonetheless, I do think it is unkind to post her pictures and then make the comments you did. Next time, just ask without showcasing someone else's weaknesses and without his/her permission.

    Cynthia

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Cynthia, I see you went right where I was trying to avoid. I probably shouldn't have used an image at all.

    My reaction was like Kim's--beyond the scope of my experience, so I read and moved on.

    I do agree with you Cynthia on this, "It can be disappointing when someone gets no responses-not that any should feel obligated to answer. I think it is fine to pass when you don't feel you have anything you could say."

    And that's the quandary I felt. I've seen instances where the person requesting help either got no response or one response at most and it was apparent they were new to the forum.

    Since this has been personalized, I apologize if I've come across as disingenuous or rude.

    -Ron-

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    No worries, Ron. I think I was feeling a bit defensive on the OP's part since I was little help and no one else had any thoughts for her. You didn't need to apologize, but thanks just the same.

    Cynthia

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    With only a couple of exceptions, each of the rocks in the photo is just downslope of one of the plants. So I'm assuming she wasn't aiming for a rock garden effect so much as trying to prevent erosion that would compromise her new plantings. The rocks are sort of in rows because the plants are.

    (Forgive me for pointing this out if everyone has realized it.)

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I went back over & reread the lady's problem! Soil erosion 101!!! I told her what the experts do, no I'm not 1 I just am so used to seeing the solution that I never give it any thought. I live in land of quakes & fires(all week over 2nd ridge-very smokey & allergic to smoke so lots of headaches)so thanks to you all discussing this & Cynthia telling us where she is (I've been checking lot of forums just to see what they were like) I found her & told her what to do. I see the hills denuded by fires, quakes & heavy rains & have sat at signals & watched them put this stuff on the hills. Drove by it all the time after fire last Nov. Surprised nobody told her. She probably should have said "Help, my hill is sliding" but we all jumped to conclusion that she was wanting help with her rock garden, not what is under it!!LOL

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I'm really glad you posted this question. The original question is this, as I see it:

    How can you help someone who is desperately in need of help, without being unkind?

    Like the original poster, my strength is for design. I've worked professionally in design, although not landscape design. I find neighbors and friends who see my garden asking for advice. I think the problem comes when someone who has an instinctual eye for design, but doesnt know how to express the design concepts and principles that make for good design i.e.: symmetry, repetition or contrast of form and texture vs. asymmetry, formality vs. informality.

    I find myself in a situation right now where someone has offered to pay me for helping her with design problems in her home. My first reaction to one of her problems was this: You have a formal home with classical columns, that fake waterfall over field stones looks really cheesy and completely out of place with your beautiful home. (She wasnÂt happy with it, thatÂs why she was asking me. She just didnÂt know why it didnÂt work). Instead hereÂs what IÂm going to tell her. The formality and architectural style of you home would be more in keeping with a symmetrical pond surrounded by some architecture with presence, i.e. two gazebos or pavilions. The pond could be surrounded by bluestone, repeating the material used elsewhere in your patio.