Software
Houzz Logo Print
nancyjane_gardener

seeds or starts?

16 years ago

This is my first year of starting tomatoes, peppers, eggplant and some others from seed. We went to a seed bank this spring to try to keep things totally organic.

I started them under lights on a heat bed about March 1st (now I know that's too late!), but it was 6-7 weeks before our last frost date.

Here we are in mid MAY, and my babies are barely 6" tall! No flowers yet. I'm grimacing at how slow everything is going!

I' re-thinking doing the from seed thing! I might just go back to the organic nursery next year!

My other option is that we are building a greenhouse this summer and the seed starting might work out!

What has worked out for you????

Comments (11)

  • 16 years ago

    Eggplants are very slow growers and so can peppers. I would start those two earlier personally. Having said that, you'd be amazed at how fast things grow once they are planted outside. The lack of flowers may even be a good thing as I heard that planting transplants with flowers will not grow as good of a root structure as the ones with no flowers. Whether this is true or not, experts here can tell us that. :) Can you plant your seedlings outside now?

  • 16 years ago

    I think you are doing just fine. If your plants are 6" tall in mid may they will be perfect for setting out when the weather warms. I never expect flowers on my plants until they have grown for a while in the garden.

    I know that nurseries these days sell very large, even full grown, plants in large individual pots. I've even seen tomato plants with fruit on them. That is a way of having instant gratification but it doesn't make economic sense and is not a practical gardening technique. Your 6" plants will grow fast once they are set out ans they will soon catch up with some of the larger ones.

    I wouldn't change a thing.

    Jim

  • 16 years ago

    I planted in March outside because we had an unusually warm spell, and my cabbage are between 4 inches tall for the runt and about 9 inches tall for the taller ones. Everything is developing an unusually long root, or so I say because of the turnips, I haven't dug up anything else.

    Why would something root so deep before it starts making a few leaves? They are unusually deep, but maybe that's normal. The garlic did the same thing, it was about 12 inches deep, but it was only about 8 inches tall with only one or two green leaves.

  • 16 years ago

    scarletdaisies,

    Does your question have something to do with the topic of this thread? I ask because I'm trying to relate your concern about root length of cole crops and garlic growing outdoors to nancyjane's concern about starting heat loving seedlings indoors. I don't see the connection but I would say long roots are nothing to worry about.

    Jim

  • 16 years ago

    everything is an experiment in your garden. the more you garden the more you get to know the environment you have and how it affects your plants. I am amazed at how sensitive I am to the changes in my plants, they are like my kids lol! Unusually deep may be normal for your environment, and as long as they are healthy and not bleeding I dont worry bout them or the plants!

  • 16 years ago

    Nancyjean - peppers and eggplants are usually started 8-12 weeks early as they grow much more slowly than tomatoes. In the GH we start peppers a month before we seed tomatoes. But 6-8" transplants are still considered ideal for all three of them and you definitely don't want them to be blooming until AFTER they have been transplanted to the garden and settled in there..

    scarletdaisies - like Jim, I am missing the connection to the original post? As to "Why would something root so deep before it starts making a few leaves?" that's normal for direct seeded plants.

    Dave

  • 16 years ago

    What size pots are they in? I found potting them up before they get rootbound REALLY makes a difference in growth. In my experience, any plant that stays in a small pots stays small.

    I started my peppers and eggplants on March 5th. They are about 8-10 inches tall, and look great. I started them in seed starter cells, potted them up at the end of March into 2" pots, then potted them up again into 16oz. cold cups at the end of April. They need potting up again, since they are close to outgrowing their pots and it will be another 2 weeks before I can put them out in the garden (with protection). Having large enough pots for the roots is really crucial to getting good top growth. Trying to "hold on" in small pots until planting out will only stunt the plant growth as it has a rootbound ball to deal with when you do plant them out.

    Some of the peppers have flowers on them, and with all due respect to Dave and Jim, I will leave the flowers on. My experience has been that those early flowers give me an early, mid-summer crop. Other flowers higher up on the plant, which develop after planting out, give me a second, late summer crop.

  • 16 years ago

    I do both. At this time I don't have money to invest in grow lights. I also rent out my basement (about 45% house) so I have no space to set up grow lights. Almost all cool weather plants are planted from seed, except broccoli and cauliflower. I also do cukes, onions, spinach, swiss chard, peas, carrots from seed. I pop all those seeds in the ground, and see how many come up. I think you should do whatever works for you.

  • 16 years ago

    Thanks for all the responses!
    If I grow from seed again, I'll start much earlier!
    I rarely start a thread, but sometimes it seems like we're playing telephone/telephone!
    Hmmmmmm, where did THAT come from????? Or I didn't ask that question!
    LOL, Happy Gardening! NT

  • 16 years ago

    Hi Nancyjane, are your seedlings already transplanted outdoors at this moment?

    I too find my own seed grown seedlings slow to establish when they're first transplanted. But sometimes the store bought seedlings are so early, they're way ahead of the season. I have to cut off their flower heads every day because I prefer them to be growing root when they're young rather than fruit.

    What worked really well for me from seeds are tomato. I've been planting toms for over two decades and find them very forgiving. if I can grow tomato from seeds, anyone can! Most of my toms are the late variety, so what's important to me is not their size, but how soon the fruits ripen. If you're planting early variety, then it sure makes a big difference to be early.

    What really hasn't worked for me are peppers. My pepper seeds always grow so slowly, I get tired of waiting every year and simply just buy seedlings from the store.

    In recent years I really started veggie planting and found the ones really worth starting from seeds are brussel sprouts, chinese broccoli, swiss chard, basil, mints, etc. Then of course what veggiefaery already mentioned things that prefer direct sowing such as legume, squash, gourd, etc.

    But you'll have so many early seedlings in your new greenhouse next year, you may wonder why you ever bought starts from the nursery :-)

  • 16 years ago

    This is my first year of successful seed starting, too. (I got heat mats & lights - wow, what a difference!) I wanted to chime in & sing the praises of potting up. I like to recycle, so I saved all the yogurt containers my family goes through. All my peppers are now in 32 oz. yogurt containers. I don't bother with eggplant because I'm told it's just not worth it in this climate. (New Hampshire). The peppers certainly do grow slowly, but I'm surprised at how well they're doing, compared to the starts I've always bought. I'm hoping I'll finally be truly successful with peppers this year.

    My tomatoes are another matter - they're ridiculously huge and a bit of a problem. I'm certainly making some changes in my seed starting calendar next year! I started my tomatoes on 3/19 and my peppers on 3/26. I think the cooperative extension had it backwards, if you ask me.

    I've been using fish & seaweed emulsion. I've heard seaweed emulsion really helps things grow - something about a hormone in seaweed. What do others think?