Software
Houzz Logo Print
ania_ca

Do you really need trellises and/or cages?

17 years ago

Do cucumbers, vining squash, melons, etc....really need trellises? Does anyone just let them sprawl out on the ground? I have my cucumbers and squash in containers. Can I just let them vine out of the containers and on the concrete around them?

Ania

Comments (11)

  • 17 years ago

    No of course they don't need trellises. Home gardeners typically grow them on trellises to save space. However growing on concrete could be a bad idea. I remember I once let a pumpkin vine grow on concrete, it had two beautiful pumpkins on it. They eventually turned orange and I picked them. Sadly, I discovered that the concrete was too hot for them and the back of them had completely rotted away. I wouldn't grow anything on concrete, it gets too hot.

  • 17 years ago

    Trellises save space, and like weirdtrev indicated can prevent rotting... on concrete, or even in mud. You might want to put a wood board, or straw under anything that's growing on the ground, especially winter squashes, or anything that needs a lot of time to ripen. I also have the clumsy gardener problem of accidentally stepping on my plants that grow on the ground.

  • 17 years ago

    Probably the only crops that absolutely MUST grow on some type of trellis are pole beans and vining varieties of peas, along with a few unusual crops like Malabar spinach and hops. Like others said, the main reason for trellising is to be able to use your limited space much more efficiently, so you can squeeze more into the space available.

  • 17 years ago

    Thanks for the advice. I'm kind of at the limit of what I want to spend for my garden this year. By the time I bought containers, soil and a watering system, it ran into quite a bit on money. I'm not handy enough to build a trellis either. I was thinking of making that investment next year. I'll start looking for some solution. Do cheap tomato cages work for any of those plants? What would be th cheapest and easiest solution? In the meantime, if I do have to let them sprawl, I'll put something under the fruit so they won't rot.

    Ania

  • 17 years ago

    If you have freecycle in your area, check regularly for people offering free fencing. You can use it to grow your vining crops, just remember that if the fruit of the crop is heavy it might need to be put in hammocks made of old nylons so that they don't break the vines or fall off the vines. You might want to check the "free" listings on your local craigslist as well. I've seen people giving away all kinds of fencing, support type material and other items that would be so great for gardens.

  • 17 years ago

    Use your imagination! I have used old ladders for pumpkins, metal closet shelves with the wire shelves, a metal CD holding tower for cukes, bamboo and twine made into a teepee. Anything tall with string running from bottom to top for beans.
    I even have a mannequin who sports some green beans growing up her torso! LOLOL
    As bcskye said, check out freecycle and craigslist. Also check your local dump if they have a recycletown for interesting tower type thingies!
    I love to add interest to my garden! I often hide things such as gargoyles, turtles, gnomes and such throughout for people to discover!
    Have fun! NT

  • 17 years ago

    Like ninjabut said, it really is fun to repurpose items. My DH threw away the swing and canopy from our set (wanted to throttle him when I found out), but kept the frame. Well, that dark green frame is now home to peas and Kentucky Wonder pole beans and soon will be sporting some Scarlet Runners. Towards the end of July, it will be supporting a lot of peas. I have been watching for another frame that someone has gotten rid of or wants to.

  • 17 years ago

    Right now, my cukes are "trellised" using el cheapo wooden stakes and free twine from Lowes. Place the stakes in a triangle shape around the plants then just tie the twine between the stakes at varying heights (mine around about 5-6 inches apart, but I'm finding that is too much and I need to adjust). Right now, I've got tendrils galore that I just guide to the twine and they do the rest!

    This is an older photo of my blackberry cane, but it is the same idea. You can actually see the cukes in the background. They are about 10x bigger now with a 6" baby begging to be picked (must...restrain...self...) No updated pics of my cukes. Need to get on that tonight!
    {{gwi:74432}}

  • 17 years ago

    * Posted by denninmi 6A SE Michigan (My Page) on
    Fri, Jun 19, 09 at 20:11

    Probably the only crops that absolutely MUST grow on some type of trellis are pole beans and vining varieties of peas, along with a few unusual crops like Malabar spinach and hops.

    Are you kidding? There isn't anything that MUST be supported. Years ago I read The Joy Of Gardening by Dick Raymond, and in it he describes an experiment where he planted tall peas very thickly in a big block bed, with nothing but themselves to climb, and he ended up with a much bigger harvest than he had when he planted peas with space and trellises. I've planted peas and beans this way ever since, no matter the type (planted this way it's really hard to even tell the difference between pole and bush beans and peas).

    To the OP: My squash family plants are all sprawling now, with the exception of my Telegraph Improved cucumber, which has fruits with thin skin that are easily marred by pillbugs when they are on the ground. The Telegraphs are climbing up tomato ladders. It all depends on your individual circumstances, and you'll know what you need after this season is over, that's for sure! It's really a matter of taste and convenience, and nothing at all to stress over, wondering if you've "ruined" your season.

  • 17 years ago

    I lost my mind this year and decided to try to trellis everything... *including* a Dill's Atlantic Giant Pumpkin. The plant hasn't even fruited yet and it's already heavy! Methinks I'm going to be adding additional supports all throughout the year ;)

  • 17 years ago

    I really dont post here much at all, but sometime back I read about people using cattle panel for trellis. I have never looked back. I use cable ties to secure it to 8 foot snow fence poles and that trellis could withstand a tornado... Just love them, and they are about $20 at any farm store.