Software
Houzz Logo Print
tesmith_gw

What did I do wrong

14 years ago

Decided to grow broccoli from seed for fall planting

I studied, and planted and nurtured

Got great results in sprouts

As they were doing well, I thinned them out suddenly almost overnight they all fell flat on their face so to speak

{{gwi:84074}}

{{gwi:84075}}

{{gwi:84076}}

Here are pictures of a few of them (I planted a bunch they were for myself and a neighbor) I am wondering If I over watered, with our oppressive heat spell we had going I did keep them moist. Looks like I am buying seedlings for fall planting But for future reference I would love to know what went wrong so I can try again next time.

Comments (15)

  • 14 years ago

    Damping off. To prevent, use a clean seed-starting mix and don't over-water. A fan providing circulation can help. Also a drop or two of peroxide in the water.

    Also the seedlings are spindly, looks like insufficient light.

  • 14 years ago

    not nearly enough light made them spindly

    What were the conditions they were grown under?

  • 14 years ago

    I used 1/3 miracle grow soil in the bottom of each cup followed by 2/3 seed starting mix on top

    As they were being started in the heat wave I placed the packets in a larger container with water in the bigger container Covered with plastic. I have a walk around porch on my house {{gwi:84077}} I set the containers on a table on this porch. Until I had sprouting, I had the bigger containers covered in plastic wrap, I uncovered as soon as sprouting became visible. Because of the intense sun and heat I kept water in the bottom of the big container holding the little containers, and kept them on the porch where they go limited direct sunlight and a great deal of ambient light......As I said before they seemed to be doing well and flopped over in a day.

  • 14 years ago

    Its definitely "damping off".(google it for more info) Constantly wet soil will promote it.

  • 14 years ago

    Agreed, too little light and damping off.

    Another option to control damping off is to use topical strength peroxide (3%, the stuff you buy in the brown bottles for putting on cuts) and put that straight into a spray bottle. It won't hurt your plants (they'll tolerate up to about 10% concentration before it starts getting dangerous), and it will kill all the fungus and mold and bacteria on the surface of the soil.

  • 14 years ago

    You don't give your zone and location (state, region etc.) If you go to your profile page you can update that info there. It is difficult to answer questions without this...besides, how will I ever find my way to that wonderful porch for some good old fashioned evening sitt'n.

    Broccoli can be directly seeded at this time of year for a fall crop, but my experience is that it does much better started indoors and grown for the first several weeks under lights. The lights are within an inch or so of the emerging seedling. I found at this time of year, having a fan moving in air in the room where the starts are is important because of the danger of overheating. Catch 22...have the area warm enough for good germination but not fry tender starts.

    I have cabbage going now and will soon add broccoli, more lettuce, and bok choi to my growing table under fluorescent gro lights

  • 14 years ago

    South Central Pa

  • 14 years ago

    I'd say what you did most wrong was the plastic wrap.

    Fluorescent light is the way to go for seedlings. It not only has the right spectrum, it won't overheat and cook the baby plants. Your porch just was too shady.

  • 14 years ago

    lonmower Thanks for your kind words of the porch
    We bought the home needing much work It is 112 years old as you can partially see, I have started stripping the paint from the railings, some places have almost 3/16 of an inch in built up paint. It is a slow and tedious job but will be worth it when it is all done.

    For all of you, thanks I appreciate hearing your thoughts on this.

  • 14 years ago

    Perhaps, it's not too late to start over.

    It seems enough responses have told you the problem:
    Give them more sun.
    Do not have them sitting in water.
    They need well drained soil to prevent damping off, so potting soil was fine.
    Plastic wrap works until you see green sprouts, then remove.

    Go for it!

  • 14 years ago

    Wow! I live in scPA! Probably you were starting the seedling just in the wrong spot! Also we've had some extreme heat lately, and could be heat stress!! Maybe also you did not transplant them soon enough when they were looking good before this happened!
    I'd just go buy some at your local nursery now!! I was thinking of doing some broccoli now, too! Don't give up! Let's compare notes!! lol!

  • 14 years ago

    Tesmith, I don't think lights are necessary and I don't think the porch is too shady. But I do think that they were kept too wet and that the plastic blocked light and retained humidity. I'd try again but just sow in the pots and leave them on the table uncovered with drip tray underneath. Don't keep the tray constantly full of water. It's meant to protect the table not act as a reservoir. I raise all my indoor seeds in a glazed porch and have never considered artificial lighting despite the overcast nature of my climate. Lights seem to be very popular in the US but are a rarely used in the UK, except by commercial and specialist growers. Somehow we manage to grow stuff. Good luck.

  • 14 years ago

    This is a tough time of year for growing new seedlings.The heat discourages germination, and then the intense sun causes whatever few plants that make it to wilt. Last year I went through a hot spell unable to get a single seed of several varieties to break ground. This year I am having to keep seedlings (broccoli included) in partial shade,and they are fighting to stay alive. They look awful, but it's out of our control until the weather moderates, which will make it too late for planting.

  • 14 years ago

    I recently set out my fall broccoli and cauliflower [sown on June 16th].

    I started a later batch of broccoli on July 5th. I kept the seedlings out in full sun as much as possible [except for some afternoon shade on the hottest days [90s]. This sunshine will dry out the soil from getting fungal diseases!!...and will keep them from legginess.

  • 14 years ago

    Wow I am having a hard time trying to decide, reseed and try again, hmmmm I wonder how Broccoli would do direct seeded in the ground?

    Oh, part of me is thinking maybe I should just go buy some plans and try again next year when possibly weather could be more moderate

    I planted 40 plus broccoli this spring, fought bolt constantly. I have gotten a few side shoots to have, however with the heat have even been fight bolting with them......I have all ready made up my mind most of them are coming out and new is going in place either way I am hoping for a much better fall crop, Last years fall crop was amazing and I was still getting some broccoli into February of this year!

    Lisbeth, I live in New Freedom Pa