Software
Houzz Logo Print
gsevens

Carrots keep coming up short?

17 years ago

I tried growing sweet treat carrots. Before seeds were planted I mixed a little of 9-9-9 fertilizer into soil. Some time after growing, I used miracle grow vegetable fertilizer. I don't remember the numbers. I watered regularly. I picked a few different bunches spaced out timewise to make sure they had grown all the way. After all carrots were picked NONE seemed to be longer than 3-4". Most had a skinny root that went about 6-10" but the fat part of the carrot never went all the way down to the bottom.

My question is:

Could this be a result of just not watering enough to get moisture to bottom of roots?

Thank you

Paul

Comments (30)

  • 17 years ago

    Sweet treat carrots are described as being 5 inches long. Yours aren't much shorter than that. If you want long carrots, plant a variety known for growing to 8 inches or longer. Soil that is deeply dug, adequate fertilizer and water, and early thinning help any variety reach full size....but a genetically short variety will never grow a long root.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Sweet treat carrots

  • 17 years ago

    I personally never use Nitrogen on root crops esp. carrots. I always go with the fact that my compost will have enough N and just focus on adding bonemeal and Potassium. I also think it is way smarter to leave the "Miracle Grow" on the shelf at the store.

  • 17 years ago

    Naturegirl,
    Thanks. I think Mine came out a little smaller than I first thought. They look more like "Short n Sweet" carros with a long root at the bottom. Even the short n sweet look longer than mine though. They are delicious though, so I will try this variety again next year with some changes.

    Zebraman,
    Thanks for the info. Now that my miracle grow is gone, I may just leave it on the shelf at the store. I'm trying to go more organic. I can't say 100 % but I'm trying. I only used MG when things didn't seem to be growing like I thought they should. It probably didn't do me much good anyway. It makes sense not to add any more N to root crops.

    If I do the bone meal and potasium, would I put it in ground now or wait until spring? Also I have some finished compost from this year's garden. Should I add that now or in the spring? Next year I think I will stay away from the MG. Compost tea worked really good for me this year. I think it worked better than the MG anyway.

    Thanks
    Paul

  • 17 years ago

    As I am typing this I am munching on a Sweet Treat carrot from my garden. There's a ruler on my desk but it's too late to measure the length. It is fully two inches wide at its widest point near the top. Three to five inches long is not unusual. This is definitely a blocky carrot. It's supposed to be thick and short. Longer might be nice but the short ones are OK and don't require such deeply cultivated soil.
    If your carrots aren't cracking, I'd say they're getting enough water.
    What I really like about this carrot is that it has totally humongous seeds, for carrots anyway. Much bigger and easier to deal with than your average carrot seed. The seedlings are naturally larger too. Makes planting and thinning considerably easier.

  • 17 years ago

    I always had a miserable time with carrots until the last two years. I have mixed alot of compost and sand into my soil and fertilize twice with fish and seaweed emulsion. On the first feeding I soak the soil with the solution 2TBLS per Gal of water and the next time, when the tops get big, I spray the leaves with the same mixture. Also, thinning is very important. I'd sure like to know how to plant carrots and beets so that there wasn't so much thinning involved. Anyway my carrots and all root crops that I grow seem to be working out for me. By the way, I do keep them watered during dry spells. Luke

  • 17 years ago

    Thanks for the ideas everyone.

    Soil has been tilled down about 12". Nice, loose, and dark. Not sandy, not clay. I am definitely going to mix in some compost though. I think next year I'm also going to space better. I also saw a Nandrin Hybrid carrot at Park Seed. It is supposed to grow up to 14" and thick too. I wouldn't have to grow as many if I can get those to grow right. I will plant the rest of the seeds I have because they were delicious carrots, then see about some of them big ones.

    Paul

    Here is a link that might be useful: Nandrin Hybrid Carrot

  • 17 years ago

    Your soil description sounds like you could grow a long type carrot. Sweet Treat is designed to a short carrot. Short carrots are great for heavy soils, as the long ones under that condition tend to be misshapen.

  • 17 years ago

    luke_oh "I'd sure like to know how to plant carrots and beets so that there wasn't so much thinning involved."

    I've been making homemade seed tape for carrots and beets. Take a narrow strip of newpaper or toilet paper. Dab tiny bits of glue onto it with a toothpick. Add a seed to each glue spot...I use a moistened toothpick to do this. I space them about an inch apart and end up thinning if most grow. However, with this spacing it is easy to thin without damaging the ones you leave to grow. Let the tape dry well before rolling it up. When planting just lay it on the ground and sprinkle a fine layer of soil over it. (More for beets) I like being able to do the fussy spacing at my kitchen table rather than having to bend over a garden bed. I have the best carrots I've ever grown in a 4x7 foot bed right now. They were all planted with seed tapes I made inside. It does take a bit of experimenting to find paper that doesn't leak through and glue to the table and a bit of practice to get small, yet big enough dabs of glue in place. I plan to plant all my small seeds this way. Makes a pack of seeds go a loooong ways and avoids some sore back time. It doesn't take much time once you do a couple.

  • 17 years ago

    Naturegirl, Thank you! It makes sense. I assume that you use a water soluable glue. Like white school glue? I appreciate the info. Luke

  • 17 years ago

    Naturegirl,

    That is a great idea. I'm gonna make up some seed tapes this winter to be ready for next spring. I was going to place seeds 2" apart using tweezers if I had to. It would take me all day to plant carrots. Now I can actually set myself up with a lot of seed tapes and probably get more carrots this way as apposed to hand seeding. Thanks for the idea.

    Paul

  • 17 years ago

    I too make seed tape. Maybe I could call it receipt tape or calculater tape. Can you still buy it I really don't know. I bought a box of 4 about 20 years ago, and still use that. It really breaks down nicly and will not cause root blockage on root vegetables not even fast radish seeds. I do the same as naturgirl, cut the paper in stripes , put speck of glue on paper with tooth pick, then place seed with medical tweezer. I like to space mine every 2 in. also you can alternate radish seeds and carrot seeds every 1 in. or so this seems to help carots break the soil. Oh I foregot elmers school glue is water soluble and works great for this . You could use receipt tape from your local store. I know people compost it, Hows that for recycling.
    curt:-)

  • 17 years ago

    If you do the seed tape in the winter, where/how do you store them? The site has the bestes ideas.

  • 17 years ago

    Yes indeed I make tape during winter. About Febuary I get cabin fever. seeds are ordered ect. I just put the finished tapes in a drawer in my porch or in a paper bag on the fridge. Never had any trouble with storage, of course I am using new seed and 2 3 mounths is about as long as I keep a finished tape. I can't plan ahead any father than that.

    Curt :-) Lets all try to be a little greener~

  • 17 years ago

    Glad to hear lots of others make their own seed tape. It is a fun winter garden activity and really speeds up planting and thinning for me. I usually drape mine over the kitchen chairs for a day to be sure they are completely dry and then roll them up and put them in a plastic zipper bag. Don't let them get damp or they will stick together! I use school glue, don't know what brand it is, but the bottle is labeled "nontoxic". I guess if school kids can eat it, it will be safe for me after decomposing in the soil for a few months. I've read of people making a paste from flour and water but I'm not that organic.
    {{gwi:117618}}October 2009

    The bed above was planted with double rows. I seeded each edge of a long strip of toilet paper with carrot seeds and covered the entire width with fine soil. The spacing seems okay and the carrots are sizing up nicely now. The photo is from early September.

  • 17 years ago

    Nice carrot beds naturegirl. I want to build raised beds like what you have, for my garden. Planning them out has been a little hard. I wish my carrot bed was that neat. Mine looked like I just threw the seeds down and walked away. I'm definitely going with the seed tape idea for next year.

    Paul

  • 17 years ago

    Yes, you can buy the tapes for cash registers, calculators, etc, but it is expensive. Why not just save your recipts from the grocery store, etc, that you don't need to keep. I know when I get home mine is usually about 2 ft. long, wouldn't take many. Good idea, I'll be making some this winter too.

  • 17 years ago

    I wonder if twine would work just as well.

  • 17 years ago

    I am going to use newspaper or toilet paper. Some of the receipts from stores around here feel almost like a plastic material. I'm not sure if it would break down the same. Toilet paper would allow the root to grow right through it without a problem.

  • 17 years ago

    gsevens; I Just looked up the thermal printing they use on most tapes on wikipedia. I could not find a definite answer on plastic used on the tape. I think I will switch to strips of paper towel or Toilet paper. Sounds safer to me.

    Curt.

  • 17 years ago

    Nah I must have been tired when I wrote the last post. As I was making dinner tonight, fish I caught last spring and froze in plastic vacuum bags, with oil packaged in a plastic bottle, in a skillet cleaned with a plastic scour pad, ect. ect. well I will tell people that the tape works the best of any thing I have used.It breaks down very quickly and holds moisture.

    Curt:-) Lets all try to be a little greener.

  • 9 years ago

    WARNING!!! If anyone from the future reads this, 2017 or after, BEWARE! Do not use receipt tape. It's full of BPA's More than plastic bottles. http://blogs.discovermagazine.com/d-brief/2014/10/27/receipts-expose-high-levels-bpa/#.WdkEdLpFyrw Happy gardening!

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    "Hand Hazards

    Thermal receipt paper, the kind that turns dark when scratched, is often coated with BPA as a developer. A team led by Annette Hormann from University of Missouri set out to measure how much BPA moves from this receipt paper to a person’s hand. Previous studies have looked just at dry hands handling receipts, but Hormann knew that certain hand sanitizers and other skin-care products include so-called “dermal penetration enhancers– chemicals that help the liquids get into your skin.

    With this in mind, the researchers had ten volunteers each coat his or her hands with hand sanitizer, then handle unused receipt paper for 4 minutes. Then the subjects ate a basket of French fries – a scenario that could play out, for instance, after someone grabs their food at a fast food counter.

    An hour and a half later, researchers took a blood and urine sample to compare to subjects’ baseline BPA levels. They found that blood levels in some people had elevated more than ten times what they originally were. And they found total BPA in urine clocked in at 20 µg BPA/g creatinine – a level that has been associated with a significant increase in the likelihood of developing cardiovascular disease and type 2 diabetes in previous studies". from the article.

  • 9 years ago

    One handles receipt paper for four minutes? That's a "scenario that could play out"? Boy, I'd have to be really bored to do that. Anyway ...

    https://blog.americanchemistry.com/2014/10/enjoy-your-french-fries-and-ignore-the-hype-about-bpa/

    Enjoy your french fries -- grab the receipt and trash it.

  • 9 years ago

    Let me add that the lifetime of BPA in soil is 1-10 days. Microbial degradation takes care of it pretty quickly. If you apply it to grown plants, however, there will be some uptake. But the effect on plants from seed tape has to be essentially zero. Be aware that BPA is a serious air pollutant, from plastic bottles being burned. If you want to avoid BPA entirely, don't breathe.

    FWIW, just use single-ply toilet paper for seed tape. Works a charm.

  • 9 years ago

    I recommend pelleted carrot seed.

  • 9 years ago

    This is just a great idea to use seed tapes especially for the smaller seeds. I can't wait to try it. I will use toilet paper or paper towels when I make mine. Some seeds are so tiny it is hard to see them in the garden after you place it down with these older eyes.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Patti - Pelleted carrot seed is about 3x the size of a radish seed. I sowed a 70' row of carrots at 2" spacing in about 15 minutes. Got probably 90% germination and didn't have to thin at all. Yes, pelleted seed is more expensive but well worth it IMO.

    Johnny's selected seeds offers pelleted seed for many of the smaller seeded veggies and flowers....lettuce, carrots, beets. There are a few other online seed vendors that offer pelleted seed too. Territorial is one.

    Here is a link to all of Johnny's pelleted offerings.

  • 9 years ago

    I like Touchon variety, smooth 6-7" carrots and quite sweet and tender. Autumn planted carrots are always the sweetest and have a longer harvest with in-ground storage.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    I make my own seed tape, using strips of paper towels and flour paste glue to hold the seed onto the strip of paper. The flour paste is just flour and water.