Software
Houzz Logo Print
madmarchie

Phosphorus Deficiency-- Quick Fix?

17 years ago

Hello everyone,

The leaves on my brassicus started looking funky so I reviewed my soil test and did some research. Found photos that look exactly like my problem ---> lack of phosphorus (and nitrogen...but N but we'll get to that :)

I have only ever gardened organically (and have only been gardening 2 years at best and first season at my current site, so I'm still learning alot) but I'm not religiously devoted to it. I am open to trying IPM (integrated plant management).

I think I am going to buy some single superphosphate as I understand using guano, which has the highest P of the organic options, whether bird or bat is very destructive to habitat. I know superphosphate comes out of chemical plant but it's kind of a darned if you do darned if you don't.

I considered soft (colloidal) rock phosphate but my plants are pretty stunted and sick and they need help NOW. My soil is already so alkaline (7.9) I do not want to use bone meal.

Whether I use soft rock phosphate or single superphosphate (P=20) how much should I use, how should I apply it and WHEN will I see results? I'm worried about burning the plants in any way with the synthetics. But I want to use the synthetic because I CAN'T lose these veggies. It's a community garden of sorts and I don't want people to be disappointed.

Thanks in advance for any input on the situation!


PS: I did get some slow release granules 10-30-10 today and buried a tablespoon, 2 inches deep, 4 inches from the stem on 6 plants. Tested 6 more plants using a tablespoon of granules scratched into first inch of soil, in a 6 inch circle from the stem. Then I watered the 12 test plants with plain water and gave the other 100 brassicus plants a 8-1.5-2 sea/fish, foliar feed/soil drench.

Comments (3)

  • 17 years ago

    Rock Phosphate is not water soluable and will dissolve very very slowly depending upon the acidity of the soil. Superphosphate is mostly water soluable, so will be available to the plants immediately. I don't use either. For chemical phosphates, I prefer Diammonium phosphate, which is also 18% nitrogen and dissolves in water better (so is available to the plants sooner) than superphosphate (OSP). Sometimes Diammonium phosphate (DAP) is sold as yeast nutrient. Not knowing your exact soil chemistry, I would guess that sprinkling a teaspoon of DAP or OSP around each plant before watering would work. Either way read labels.

    As for organic, chicken manure is usually quite high in phosphorus. In my opinion fresh chicken manure works in every way better than cave mined bat guano. People just don't like to use it much because of the smell. Second best organic in my opinion is fresh rabbit droppings. No need to compost them. Plants love them just the way they are.

    Good luck.

  • 17 years ago

    Madmarchie - can you tell us where you are gardening ie which zone? And some pictures would be good. 'Looking a little funkie' would be perfectly normal for Brassicas in many places in November. Are these leaves all over the plant or just at the bottom? It is natural for the lower leaves of overwintering hardy brassicas to turn yellow and drop off and for the rest of the plant to get a bit weatherbeaten. And what Brassicas are they? If they are broccoli or sprouts the appearance of the leaves doesn't matter that much as long as they are feeding the plants. Plants often look scruffy but it doesn't necessarily mean they have specific chemical problem or that there is a magic bullet solution. If you have only been gardening for 2 years you may be expecting shop-like perfection in your homegrown produce whereas you can afford to accept much more natural-looking vegetables for the sake of flavour and freedom from chemicals. Also in your 'test' you don't have a control group because you gave all the other plants a feed which was not given to your test plants. So it will be hard to decide which effects are due to which actions. I can't help feeling you might be overanalysing normal winter wear and tear and killing your crops with kindness. Personally I'd give them a break from your attentions for a while and see how they get on. Like kids plants will often grow out of a problem by themselves with time. Fussing just makes them hypochondriacal.

  • 17 years ago

    Most plants don't need anywhere near the phosphorous once believed, in fact most need more calcium than P.

    I wouldn't go too crazy trying to add P unless you have a reputable, lab test indicating it's need.

    N is another matter, but home tests can't test for it accurately and most labs don't do N tests either as it is so volatile.

    Just add a source of N at planting time and again 4-6 weeks later and that should be enough for most things. Synthetics are fine, but if you want to stay organic grain meals like alfalfa and soybean and to a lesser extent corn all do the job well.