Software
Houzz Logo Print
katskan41

Deer protection ideas?

19 years ago

Hi all. It's nearly that time of year again when the deer start browsing and/or rubbing our conifers. I believe that the word "fir" means "salad bar" in deer language!

I know the best solution to keep deer away is to build very tall fences or place wire cages around conifers. Since that is not feasible in our situation I was wondering if any of the many spray chemicals on the market are successful at keeping deer away from conifers. I've found that in our area firs are prone to deer browsing while the spruces are prone to antler rubbing by the males.

Anyone have suggestions about the "anti-deer" chemicals? I've tried bars of smelly soap and shiny aluminum pie tins but neither has prevented rubbing and browsing.

Thanks.

Comments (8)

  • 19 years ago

    Katskan, there is a product developed in Sweden called 'Plantskydd' that has gotten good reviews. It is a pigblood based material that has stickers in it to really help it remain on the plant through many months of exposure to weather conditions. I've used it on herbaceous plants this summer that were being decimated by bunnies, and it really worked. It is messy to mix and clogs up sprayers at times, but still the best I've seen so far. I'm going to be using it this fall to protect plants from rodent damage, so this will be my first trial of it in a winter setting. But nevertheless, worth a look I should think.

    +oM

  • 19 years ago

    I agree with Tom... Plantskydd kept the rabbits and deer from munching up my Euonymous shrubs this year (after being nearly decimated the previous year). It does clog up and is not easy to use (and it absolutely REEEEEEEKS! -- but then what would you expect for blood... lol), but it does work. I have never used it on conifers though. It will turn whatever you spray it on bright RED. Hmmm.... a 'Red spruce'.... interesting! ;)

  • 19 years ago

    Thanks for the suggestion of Plantskydd. Never heard of that before but will see if I can find it. Most of the deer sprays that I've seen are made from eggs I believe and need to be reapplied every so often.

    Thanks again!

  • 19 years ago

    Hanging bars of soap may not be sufficient--you have to spray a soap film on the foliage itself.

  • 19 years ago

    Hey Katskan...... i too have a big deer problem..... i found "Repels All" by Bonide. It works great, dotn have to apply often ( applied twice so far this year) and nothing is eating mt garden. It too reeks of eggs..... but whatever else is in this Repels All really works. good luck. Aco has on sale week! Deb

  • 19 years ago

    Cool, glad to hear Repels All works on deer! I have that stuff, but only used it for the rabbits and voles. It also appears to have successfully chased a groundhog from it's hole as well! YES! [doing a victory dance here]

  • 19 years ago

    Thanks Deb for the "Repels All" recommendation! I have seen that at the local garden shops in my area. I think I will try it out. Do you buy it in a premixed gallon or a concentrate and mix your own in a sprayer?

    Someone at work recommended "Liquid Fence", another egg solid product. Don't know anything about how it works but assume it's similar to Repels All.

    No luck locating the Plantskydd in my area. I will go to the website and find a local dealer.

    Thanks for your help. Hopefully we will have fewer buck rubs on the conifers this year!

    Dave

  • 19 years ago

    Dave, I ordered the Plantskydd online (none in our area either)... just google it and you should be able to find it.