Software
Houzz Logo Print
ncage

JB Strategy for this year?

20 years ago

Ok guys for the last two years ive had a heck of a time with JB (japanese beetles). Getting up early morning and trying to get rid of them by flicking them off the branch into a pail of water just isn't cutting it. For every 1 i flick off 5 replaces them. I like to grow stuff organically but with jb its just not possible. There are 100s of them. They don't seem to like anything in my garden except for basil but this is like the herb i like the most (genovese to be exact). First year i didn't know what the heck they were and when i figured it all out it was to late and they killed my one basil plant that i had. Last year i got started and i went looking for them every couple of hours on the weekends and when i got home from work on the weekday and sprayed sparenly with pesticide. I know jb are attracted by other jb so i wanted to try to prevent that early on. Well it was a loosing battle and the jb ended up winning. This year i know i HAVE to use pesticide. Im wanting a pesticide that i can maybe spray the plant weekly and will take care of the problem and it shoudl be realively easy to find. I guess i just want something that will forsure take care of the problem and i don't have to go out and spray it on the plant daily.

Please advise.

thanks,

ncage

Comments (11)

  • 20 years ago

    Someone recently posted a possible answer... but for the life of me I can't find it now. Anyway, the person noticed that the JBs seemed to like the white flowers best and then massed themselves on a freshly washed white sheet hung on the line to dry. She said that she now hangs an old white sheet out for them to congregate on then brushes them off into a bucket of soapy water.

  • 20 years ago

    Last year I grew raspberry plants which attracted the beetles, who left my basil relatively untouched. But I still got out with a bucket of warm soapy water to remove the bugs, otherwise I don't know if they'd have finished off the berry plants and then gone on to the basil for dessert. Certainly they don't seem to have many (any?) local predators.

    A friend recently gave me some row covers, basically fuzzy fabric that you put over plants to keep them warm and keep insects out. Worth trying on a few plants. Along the same lines, some cylinders of porch-screening material might permanently solve the problem, in the same way that people use coarser mesh to keep birds away from fruit.

    If you belong to a farm co-op or CSA, try asking the farmer what organic methods they use to keep pests off basil.

    There are hormone traps you can buy, but I've heard from some that they do more harm than good by attracting beetles to the vicinity of your garden. Has anyone tried them?

  • 20 years ago

    Guys thanks for the comments but ive already made up my mind that i wont be growing my basil this year orgianically. Everything else will be organic though. Im just looking for which pesticide i should use basically.

  • 20 years ago

    Grow your basil under floating row cover. If you insist on spraying for JB, use Sevin. But it's a contact insecticide so you have to keep it up. Floating row cover is a lot easier.

  • 20 years ago

    oldroser: Is there any pesticide that isn't a "contact" pesticide and i can just spray once a week with good results?

  • 20 years ago

    I've got to agree with nygardener - throw in even a couple of raspberry plants and you won't ever have a problem with JB's on your basil. They'll all go to the rasberries and you'll be annoyed with a different set of problems! I haven't found anything that works on JB's that doesn't require re-application after a good rain except row covers - yet. Milky Spore works really well as long as you're either 1) a ways from your neighbors and you can cover a good swath of the surrounding area or 2) if you can convince your neighbors to join in.

    I'd look at when your JB population is getting bad (usually 4th of July in my area) and just cover for a few weeks until they mostly disappear for the best option. Either that or Milky Spore the lawn and feed the basil like crazy and hope they can survive it.

  • 20 years ago

    The problem with spraying basil with anything is you will be eating the spray when you eat the basil, no way will it all wash off. I would try the row covers or screen.

  • 20 years ago

    Thanks for the great reply makalu. I think the reason i have such a big problem with them is i have a field like 10 feet from my garden which there is nothing i can do about. They rotate the crop every other year. One year its corn and the other year its soybeans. They seem to be even worse when the soybeans come. They house right next to me have a lot of roses which probably doesn't make things any better. This is why milky spores or whatever won't work where im at because if i kill them on my property then they will be nearby anyways. JB will travel up to 5 miles to feed so milky spores wouldn't help that much.

    My father lives about 10 miles from me in a subdivision that is surrounded by woods. He doesn't have one bit of problem with JB.

    You brought up a good point of just covering them for a few weeks when the populations get heavy. That is a pretty good idea.

    Ncage

  • 20 years ago

    You might try a "vegetable safe" insecticide that either contains a horticultural oil, like neem oil, or that is pyrethrin-based, or that is a combination of both. Neem oil is harmless (works by asphyxiating the bugs) and pyrethrin breaks down very quickly and doesn't build up systemically in the plants. The combination products claim that that the residual effect of the horticultural oil allows an application every one or two weeks. The pyrethrin is a contract insecticide, so you need to hit the beetles to kill them quickly.

    The link is just an example of one product. I use something similar on my indoor herbs in the winter. There are many more out there and should be available at your local nursery. Whatever you use, be sure to wash your herbs thoroughly before using.

    narcnh

    Here is a link that might be useful: Example of a combination insecticide

  • 20 years ago

    Here's a good article on organic control methods.

    Using pesticides will harm predatory insects and arachnids, and that will invite more harmful bugs to your other herbs. You'll just be creating more problems for yourself.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Japanese Beetle: The Continuing Struggle to Achieve Successful Biological Control

  • 20 years ago

    I know this sounds crazy, (but if your not allergic to bees/ wasps and don't have kids) order some wasps. Your local garden supply should have them, or you may have to mail order them. The solitary paper and mud daubers don't usually attack humans but they love most garden pests. I get my lady bugs and lacewings from "Tip Top Bio-Control" I'm sure they probably have the species of wasps you'd want, and I think they have an online site, (not sure mine come to me via my garden store).
    Or I've heard that diatomous earth deters most pests. You could give that a try too.

    '