Software
Houzz Logo Print
hzdeleted_19703376

Cuisinart or KitchenAid Attachment Kit

16 years ago

I'm trying to decided whether to buy a Cuisinart Food Processor, or an Attachment Kit for my KitchenAid mixer with food mill and slice/shred attachments.

Both will cost me about the same, depending on which model Cuisinart I choose (I'm looking at 7 and 9 cup models).

My first project is to puree garden tomatoes for freezing. I'd also like to make pesto from garden basil. Later in the season, I'll be wanting to process pumpkin flesh.

Thank you for your help!

Comments (7)

  • 16 years ago

    Not much help I guess as I don't have either, just an inexpensive Westbend 9 cup food processor which works great for me doing both those things - tomatoes and pesto. But I would think either would work fine for what you plan.

    I guess if I already had the Kitchen Aid I'd go that route just to save having another appliance to store. But in some of the previous discussions on the KA attachments here some have mentioned the clean-up hassles/time with them. Which would be easier for you to clean after use?

    Dave

  • 16 years ago

    My opinions, as I have both the FP and KA attachments: The Cuisinart 7 cup FP only allows about 4 cups in the bowl, the 9 cup FP about 5. Disadvantage with the FP is that when the bowl is full you have to stop, take it all apart, and empty it. With the KA attachment you can just keep going because there is no enclosed bowl. But, the FP is useful for other things that the KA can't do, i.e., mixing pie dough, fine pureeing, making sauces, fine chopping bread crumbs, etc. Although the KA does puree it is a one shot through whereas the FP can keep going around to the finest level you want. The KA attachments have a storage issue (lots of pieces) but the motor on the KA is just about life-long where any food processor's motor may give out after a half-dozen years or so. The KA attachments retain a value second-hand, while the FP is rarely offered as such, only as new since those who buy one keep it or use it until it quits and discards it.

    My opinion/recommendation: Both are useful in the kitchen, but for what you said you wanted to do, the KA attachments would be better suited because of the volume you want to process. For making pesto, I'd recommend buying a mini-FP for about $15. I find this little gadget indispensable for chopping parsley, herbs, onions, celery, and nuts. It is simple to clean and fits into a drawer when not in use, where a seldom used standard-sized FP takes up a lot of counter space.

    Nancy

  • 16 years ago

    Thanks so much for your advice. Nancy, your post was especially helpful. I ended up ordering the strainer/food grinder attachments for my KA mixer. I'll have them tomorrow and then I'll do my first batch of tomato sauce.

  • 16 years ago

    I like the way my ground meat turns out better with the KA. Allows me to buy London broil and sirloin on sale for better, leaner hamburg since I trim all fat.

  • 16 years ago

    I made my first (ever!) batch of tomato sauce from garden tomatoes last night. I used my new KA attachment kit to process the tomatoes. I ran them through a second time to make sure I got all the good stuff. I was very happy with how this worked. It was easy to assemble, easy to use, and easy to clean up.

    I used Lunch Box determinate tomatoes, plus some Red Brandywines, Cherokee Purples and Japanese Black Trifeles- basically, all the ripe full size tomatoes that I had on the counter.

    I had close to six quarts raw, I didn't add anything to it, I just cooked it down to about 2.5 quarts.

    I divided it into 1 cup portions, put it in ziploc bags, laid them in a flat roasting pan, and then cooled them overnight. This morning, I put the roasting pan in my freezer.

    Tonight, I'll package them up in a larger bag using my foodsaver.

    Now I'm just sad that I may not have enough tomatoes for another batch of this size! Looking at what's left to ripen, I may be able to make about half this much in another week or so.

  • 16 years ago

    I just purchased my KA strainer/grinder attachment. I made tomatoe sauce last weekend and it was a DREAM!!!!! I have shoulder issues and I had no problems using this attachment. It was easy to put together, take apart and clean. I used raw tomatoes and only had to core them. When I make applesauce, I will only have to quarter them and put them into a pot with a little water and cook for a minete. The attachment will take out everything. It cost me 119.
    I love it!!!