Software
Houzz Logo Print
honey1_gw

mechanic's lien

16 years ago

Quick question...or two. One of the subs has put a lien on the GC, which is really on us. He (the genius of a GC that we have)won't pay it as he is claiming that the sub is inflating what he owes. We are carrying the construction loan. The title company will not allow us to close with this lien. Anyhoo,I think (pray) we are going to pass the final inspection very soon. Can we move in with the CO without closing? The anniversay date for our loan is in a few months. What if we don't close before the anniversay? Can the bank sell our home? Yes, we have another appt. with a real estate attorney, but I can't wait. We met with him last week, but I forgot to ask this question. So many questions run through our minds once we leave the office. Does anyone have any advice/experience with something like this?

This has been a nightmare. Our little one's carpet is in and he said yesterday when we were about to leave from our visit,"I wish we could stay a little longer." He's so happy, but we don't know when he'll be able to have his own room. :'(

Comments (8)

  • 16 years ago

    "Can we move in with the CO without closing?"

    That depends...on your contract with the builder, on your bank's rules. Do you own the property and house now, or does the closing transfer title from the builder to you? in my case, we were able to move in once we had the CO even though we hadn't "closed" with the bank because it was a construction loan converting to a perm loan...we owned the house and were the GC.

    Why would the bank sell your house? The bank doesn't have the lien, the sub does.

    How much money are we talking about? What does your contract say? Who owns the house?

  • 16 years ago

    We own the land and I guess the home as we are carrying the construction loan. We've been paying the interest along with renting a house from our inlaws. Both combined, are more than what our "true" mortage will be. We are just waiting to go to perm, but we can't with this lien on the property, which is roughly 4K. Attorney says if he (GC)doesn't take care of the lien we are going to have to sue him. I really don't want to go through that.

    I'm just wondering how long can we live in the house without closing and without receiving some sort of repercussions in the long run.

  • 16 years ago

    The attorney's fees and court costs, to sue your builder will probably be more than $4K.

    It appears that your attorney is advising you to pay the Sub, who will then remove the lien so you can 'close'. You are then advised to take your builder to court to recover the $4K. (Which in the end will be a wash, as you'll have attorney fees etc. to pay.)

    Perhaps sitting down with the GC, and Sub will help see where the overruns occurred. They may be legit and maybe not.

    Some give and take from everyone will save YOU a lot more grief than the $4K.

    Good Luck!

  • 16 years ago

    We moved into our house the first week of September and still haven't closed on the mortgage. LOL It's really not funny, since the interest on the construction loan is racking up... We were originally supposed to have closed Sept. 2, but it keeps being put off through no fault of our own. The latest snafu is something about the appraisal, which I don't understand since we're borrowing well under 80% of the appraised value. We thought we'd be done for sure yesterday, but they put us off until friday.

    Anyway, yes, you can move in if you own the house already and not the builder. :-) Have you tried talking directly to the sub?

    V

  • 16 years ago

    ditto what emily said. Find out exactly where the discrepancy is in detail.

  • 16 years ago

    Your attorney is advising you to pay the sub to remove the lien, then sue the GC to collect what you are owe.

    This is the most sensible approach.

    Not sure how lien laws are written in your state, but in mine, a lienholder can actually force the sale of the house in a Sheriff Sale to satisfy the lien amount.

    But since the sub is not the primary lienholder against the property (your mortgage lender is) this can end up like a "foreclosure" with the bank ending up owning your house and land.

    It is therefore in your best interest to resolve this issue quickly.

    Your builder does not have your best interest in mind at this point, but rather his.

    So do what you need to do to protect yours.

    Luck

  • 16 years ago

    Have you fully paid the GC at this point? If not ask your attorney if you can withhold the payment and pay the sub to remove the lien.

  • 16 years ago

    Liens are often not properly handled by a sub. Has the sub actually filed a claim of mechanic's lien at the county recorder's office? Where you provided with a written notice describing the goods or services at issue within the time limit after delivery?