Software
Houzz Logo Print
paul_ma_gw

Need lighting advice (cross post)

18 years ago

I posted this on the lighting forum, but I'm getting no responses. This forum is much more active and helpful, so I'm hoping I might get some help here.

I'm redoing my kitchen and at the same time upgrading the lighting of the rest of my first floor. I have a general concept, shown in the following picture. But I'm having trouble figuring out exactly what fixtures to use in the DR/Office.

Here is the floorplan:

Its a bit hard to describe. The LR and kitchen all have a ceiling height of 7'6".

The area behind the garage is the part I am struggling with. It has an even lower ceiling (7'2") extending half way back. (To where the dashed line is.) The other half has a cathedral ceiling. It is about 12'6" high in the middle, dropping to 7'6" at the rear wall. The width of this space is about 12'. From the end of the room to the window is 2'6", the window is 3'6" wide, and from there to end of this space is and 5'11".

The bump out at the rear of that area is a window. It extends up and becomes a skylight almost to the ridge of the ceiling.

This area is currently sparsely used. The furniture shown is how I plan to use it. It will have a dining table that will do double duty as a misc work surface. (I rarely eat at the table. Only holidays and sometimes on weekends.) I will normally be using the space as an office. But I don't work from home so it will not be used extensively.

I have planned to put a couple of cans in the low ceiling. For the other part, as shown, I have been planning on track lights, mounted low on the vertical surfaces, probably about 8' off the floor. I was thinking I would point the lights on the long track at the sloped ceiling, to bounch down and provide ambient lighting. And I would point the lights on the short track down to light the table.

My problem is selecting specific hardware, and getting the right amount of light. I went to my local lighting store (a branch of Fergusons). They have some things to look at, but not a lot of selection, and the people there don't know much. They could give me no help on sizing the lights.

I was looking at a Lightolier catalog there and found some interesting things, but they were all special order so I couldn't see them or even get prices.

I'm afraid that a lot of the heads I am seeing may not put out enough light for my needs. But I'm just guessing. Note that my house (condo) has few windows and is surrounded by trees, so it doesn't get a lot of light. However the window/skylight in this room provides more than anywhere else. At some times it can be very bright. But at night it is a light sponge.

Some specific questions:

How *much* light do I need in there?

When selecting light heads, what kinds of bulbs should I be considering? (PAR, MR, ...) and what size/wattage? (Since its a small space I would prefer small heads, but still want enough light)

What are the pros/cons of low voltage vs line voltage for this application?

Where are good places online to pick from?

Is there a place in the suburban Boston area where I could see a broad selection of options, and that might actually *know* something?

BTW, I'm looking for a contemporary style - with heads probably in brushed stainless/nickel.

Here is a link that might be useful:

Comments (10)

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Make an appointment at a reputable lighting store in your area (Must be many in Boston area) with a lighting designer. I did and they looked at my plans, went over my needs, (what size table, what do you use it for)and told me what I needed, what size, what scale, how many ect. There was no charge for this service and I met with her for 2 hours x 2 visits. They had tons of books to look for something to fit my needs. I also checked online after I picked out my fixtures and the quote at the high end lighting store was less then any I could find online for the exact same fixtures. Smartest thing I did in my kitchen remodel

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    amylville,

    I'd appreciate some suggestions of a "reputable lighting store". The place I went to is AFAIK considered to be such in my area. Its J.D.Daddario, a part of Ferguson. They were bought by Ferguson a couple of years ago. Since then they seem to have lost a lot of what seemed like competent people who have been replaced by people who seem to be trying but don't really know anything.

    I am in Boston suburbs, near I495/I290. So if anybody can recommend a good place that is hopefully not too far, that would be great! (I'll go into Boston if I must, but I would rather not.)

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Talking to myself again. :-(
    (I hate it when I do that.)

    My cabinet person referred me to Yale Electric.
    I've heard of them. But they are far from convenient for me. I suppose I will go anyway.

    But if anybody out there can suggest someplace good that is closer for me (further west - in greater Boston, not CA), I would appreciate it.

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I'm near Boston--sorry I can't recommend a lighting place since our architect is doing that for us-- but if Yale Electric is the same as Yale Appliances, I would call them first and make sure they offer this service. If it's Yale Appliances, they have a huge kitchen showroom, but then just a smaller area with lights; it seemed like the lighting was not their main thing.

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    chewtoy,

    I just checked, and yes, it is the same place. You say you have been there and they are heavy on appliances and light on lights?

    I have just heard of them, never been there. Anybody else have feedback on them?

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Have you looked at Wolfer's lighting in Waltham MA (129/90)? I am planning on going to one of their free consultations...

    Good Luck!

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I mean Route 128 north of the Pike...

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Since this post woke up again I will report back.

    I went to Yale, and I also went to Standard Electric/Wolfers.

    Yale seems to push Juno. I saw the Juno mini track (low voltage) for undercabs there. They didn't have Seagull. I found a track light system for my FR that I liked ok, and it was about the cheapest thing Juno makes.

    At Wolfers they don't show Juno and push Lightolier. They didn't have any tracks that I liked very much.

    So in the end I went back to Yale and bought the Juno tracks. I suspect I could have found it a lot of places. (Sears popped up on a Froogle search.) But I just needed to get it done, because the electrician was waiting.

    I finally decided to go with the Seagull for undercabinet. (The electrician is getting it.)

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    paul_ma-lighting question

    Hello,

    I am wondering how far From the wall or cabinets you have placed the lights that are over your counter?

    I need to reposition the recessed lights since they were originally placed 36" from the wall and they cast a shadow over the counter when I stand there. But everyone tells me that undercab lights will eliminate that shadow. Are you going to use undercab lighting too?

    Thanks,

    Anna

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    anna,

    I can speak with authority now because the lights are actually in. (In the kitchen anyway. The track lights in the other room are sitting here but haven't been installed yet.)

    The lights in the diagram that appear over the edge of the counter are in fact installed so that they are centered over the edge of the granite. Now that they are in, I am happy with that - seems like the right decision. That puts good light on the front of the counters, the fronts of the upper cabinets, and on some of the floor. (When you aren't standing there.)

    After much discussion with the electrician and the other workers, the light in front of the frig/pantry was pulled out a bit so it is centered over the open floor space there. And we decided to add one more light, lined up with that one, in the center of the open space in front of the sink, and the corner of the L in the floor.

    Everybody thought it was a lot of lights. But I think it is good. Since they are all on dimmers I can have as much or as little light as I want.

    In retrospect I think I might have pulled the lights over the peninsula a little bit further from the hood. As it is, a good chunk of the beam from each one hits the hood. But I still get good light on the counter. And the hood has its own lights.

    Here are a couple of pictures that show the lights to some degree: