Software
Houzz Logo Print
blueiris24

Do Front Loaders Not Clean as Well?

18 years ago

I have talked with two friends who purchased front loader sets this past year, and neither of them is happy with them. They both really like the dryers, but neither are happy with how the washers clean. They both have Kenmores, different models, and I realize different cos makes Kenmores, but they were so excited when they initially purchased these and they both feel it was a huge mistake. I have been looking at switching to a front loader, but my friends advised me not to do it. They are following the instructions to avoid mold buildup and cleaning the washers, and are using the proper detergents. They said 1) They don't get their whites very clean 2) Towels still come out smelling moldy, even following the cleaning instructions 3) Stains don't come as clean as they did with their top loaders, even using the separate stain remover setting, and pre treating. Has anyone else experienced these things?

Comments (47)

  • 18 years ago

    FWIW...I've had Duet 9400 FL for about 3 years. (has since been superseded) Much better cleaning (and capacity) than any previous machine owned. (All TL's over forty years)

    None of the problems you've described. Machine remains clean and shiny throughout. Looks like it came off the showroom floor yesterday. Never any mold, mildew, residue or any of that stuff. I just read the manual and did what it said.

    I've never understood all the various problems reported here and elsewhere. My machine is essentially exactly like everyone else's. I suspect operator errors and/or misunderstandings but really don't know.

    I have soft water and use Tide HE powder; about 1/3 cup for full load.

    Get one with a built in heater.

  • 18 years ago

    I agree with asolo... I had a maytag tl for 25+ years and then switched to a bosch fl... much larger capacity, much better cleaning... BUT they do take some getting use to and some 'adjustments' in how you do laundry... I think this is what asolo means by operator error/misunderstanding... and I also agree with the heater... using the wash cycles with the heater option definitely does a hands down better job.

    I have no mold or residue, I have no vibration issues on the second floor...

    My recommendation is to go with a fl with a heater, make sure you have it installed properly (download and read the installation booklet before they arrive to install for you) and make sure you have a level with you (they usually won't).. and make them stay through a spin cycle to make sure it's in properly... then read the user manual.... pay attention to how to make up loads, fabric types, weights, etc... and always always always use HE soap... and way less than the container says to use....

  • 18 years ago

    Reiteration about the on-board heater.....

    The new TL's have large metal inner and outer drums and large capacities. However, they use little water. Five gallons of 130F water flowing into that mass of metal and clothes will immediately decrease in temperature as the heat is bled away by these ambient-temperature masses. If you set the dial on "hot", between the pipe-run from the water heater and the mass of drum-metal and clothes, you'll be lucky to see 100-105F in the actual wash. I call that "warm", not "hot". The only way to bring the temperature up is with an on-board heater. I've yet to encounter a salesperson that is even aware of this industry-wide characteristic of the HE/FL's. If you set the dial on "warm", you'll basically get a cold wash -- perhaps 90F or less depending on your supply-point.

    My personal suspicion is that many people are actually washing in cold or warm water with these machines without even knowing it. Whether or not that is causing the problems described or contributing to them, I can't say.

  • 18 years ago

    I also believe it's exactly the opposite of the OP's friends' opinions. FLs provide superior cleaning, but you do have to know how to use them correctly. And you have to be ready to make adjustments in some of your washing practices in order to achieve optimum, or sometimes even just satisfactory, performance.

    Essentials: a good heater, proper detergent and dosing (not necessarily HE, but correct for your water chemistry) and the correct for your machine and particular load's makeup sorting and size. It goes without saying the machine must be correctly installed.

    After that I think you'll have noticeably superior cleaning results. AT least that's been my experience in more than 15 years of FL use.

    To the OP: Which machines were you considering? There are owners of almost every kind here who will be happy to give you the straight scoop about each one. I have European ones: Askos and Mieles.

    Molly~

  • 18 years ago

    I agree with everyone else - front loaders clean better and in my opinion are not as hard on the clothes. I have Kenmore version of the Duet at home and just got Affinity at my weekend lake place. Both work very well. I've never had any problems with mold, etc. but I take the "standard" precautions. I have no on board heater at home but did get one in the Affinity. Home machine is about 18 inches from the water heater - the Affinity is a lot farther away so I thought I'd try it.

  • 18 years ago

    Frontloaders in some cases may not handle particulates very well -- grass and burrs from yardwork, excess pet hair, and so forth. For straight-out cleaning, however, they can perform better than toploaders, especially when an onboard water heater comes into the picture.

  • 18 years ago

    Interesting about the heater, I'll have to look into that. Housekeeping, I'm not entirely sure which brands I'm interested in at this point, since I'm a little gun shy, but I'd love to hear about machines people are very happy with. We do a lot of laundry at this house!

  • 18 years ago

    When we purchased our washer and dryer after much, MUCH researching we finally went with top loader due to stories about that funk mildew/mold smell. Lots of people never have this problem but some do.
    To me it wasn't even worth the small chance.

  • 18 years ago

    I have a Maytag compact front loader (MAH2400AWW). It cleans very well and rinses beter than any other top loader that I've used. The trick of a front loader is to use the proper amount of detergent for your machine, load size, and soil level which is probably less than you think. As far as foul smells go, ALWAYS leave the door partially open when not in use and there won't be a problem.

  • 18 years ago

    As with any type washer, some front loaders clean better than others.

    Kenmore washers are made by different companies. I've learned to ask who made a Kenmore before buying one. I've had two Kenmore dishwashers - one made by GE and one made by Whirlpool. The second one is a zillion times better than the first was.

  • 18 years ago

    Another caution about who makes Kenmore, VERIFY who makes it. Salespeople at Sears are often less than knowledgeable about the products. A few don't even know that Kenmore doesn't make them. Many people have been given incorrect mfgr info from salespeople.

    I'm convinced that results are directly related to proper use. This includes proper treating, dosing, loading, temperature, timing and more. FL in theory should be better in many (but not necessarily all) situations. But many if not most people get very adequate results (and occasional superior results) with a TL.

    And I'm at the point I will take issue with people who just chant "get one with a heater". What good is the heater when it's not on? Most only heat during certain cycles and there's no standardization of what cycles are heated. Many machines with a heater still will not do a profile wash which is one big reason to get one. I don't think there's many if any that let you turn on the heater in every cycle you choose. So all these cycles without heat are essentially worthless if you need the superior cleaning of a heater! Don't be fooled by thinking that a heater will do something when it's not on. Now, a machine that has heated cycles that you will use can be an effective tool. Simple but basic and often overlooked. There oughta be a law...

    I don't think anyone's trying to mislead. But the problem occurs when someone gets so used to using a certain way with a certain feature on a certain machine that it's easy to forget the variety of machines and situations out there.

    Whodathunk there'd be so much to learn about washing clothes???? :)

  • 18 years ago

    It depends on what type of TL you had prior to switching to a FL and what FL you buy. I had a really cheap Kenmore TL before I switched to a Frigidaire Affinity FL. After I worked out the kinks and figured out how to use mine effectively, I must say I prefer my FL.

    If a person had a really nice TL and switched to a low end FL, they may not be happy with the FL in the long run. I stayed away from the Kenmores when I first got my FL due to all the bad reviews I saw on them.

    This is another one that comes down to personal preference.

  • 18 years ago

    Well, yes, there's personal preference, and other things as well *smile*. Our front loader seems to clean about as well as our old top loader, and is gentler on the clothes as well. The front loader also uses much less water and energy. Due to the fast spin, clothes spend less time in the dryer, which saves gas. So there's several areas where you gain.

    While it is certainly up to you which you choose, using less water and energy is good for everyone.

    -Roger

  • 18 years ago

    Just to clarify: There are HE toploaders which clean exceedingly well. I am totally enjoying my Maytag Bravos MTW6700 washer - no agitator, huge capacity (4.6 cu ft), best washer I've ever had.

  • 18 years ago

    I have a basic GE FL. I've had it about a year now and I love it, even though it does not have the onboard heater. The only issue I've had with it, though, is mold in the back of the detergent drawer even though I leave the detergent drawer open after I'm done washing. Now I remove the detergent drawer at the end of the day and dump the excess water down the sink (there's usually a decent amount left in there.) My theory on why this happens is because I live in a very humid area. I just got back from vacation and my husband had not taken out the detergent drawer after the last use and sure enough mold was starting to grow. Yes, this is a pain to maintain, but I consider it worth it because I think a FL is superior in every other way.

    Tracey

  • 18 years ago

    regus_patoff -- thanks for the Kenmore code information!

    Love my Whirlpool Duet. Cleans great, holds tons! But (as said earlier) it is important to understand the difference in how FL's work. Follow manual's instructions. Also, wipe the moisture from inside the door and leave the door open (as someone else already suggested) for a while after each use. This will help keep the enterior dry and prevent "souring" and any musty smells from building up.

    The down side to my wonderful machine with all its whistles and bells is that it is only 3 1/2 years old and I'm starting to get some electronic/digital error codes. So far, they haven't been fatal and I have a call in for service. But my OLD top loader worked years and years without a hitch! I guess it's true -- they don't make'em like they used to!

  • 18 years ago

    I use to have a Frigidaire FL for 7 yrs and we only had a problem of having to replace the struts "shocks" and yes I ended up with the mold problem, but I didnt know about leaving the doors open, but it cleaned very well, I replaced with a Whirlpool Duet and everything gets really tangled "braided" together, and it wont rinse the soap out. Whirlpool has replaced it and I still have the same issues, the tangling is with anything that has arms & legs, and I do have soft water. There are other people here that have the same machine and dont have that problem.
    I would agree with some that are saying operaters error, but like I said I didnt have those issues with my frigidaire, so I know that I am not doing anything to cause the issues, so No it is not operater error on every issue. If I wash even one long sleeve shirt it tangles and twists up with other clothes and everything is so wrinkled that I have to iron everything, and I still cant get out the wrinkles, I also have tried lower spin cycles and washing cycles. I have done almost every load size that the manual recommends and it still does it, I havent tried the 16 pair of jeans as they say that it can wash because the washer cant handle 5-6 pair. Also the techs have told me not to put the amount that they say because it will ruin the rubber seal. they also told me that it is misrepresentation to claim that. They also say that you "should not" wash any more than you would in a TL because it will have major problems. More than 1 tech told me that.
    I also have noticed that my whites arent coming out clean, they are kinda dingy looking and when my husband goes outside in his socks, they dont come clean.
    I posted pictures awhile ago, you can do a search under Follow up on my replacement washer, about 1/3 way down, *Pictures* there is a link Photobucket, you can see what happens.

  • 18 years ago

    mc58, your socks are not coming clean and whites are getting dingy because you are not using enough detergent. I know you say that you have suds and residue issues when you increase your detergent dosage, but you can only get things clean if you have enough detergent. My Asko manual recommends 1 TBS for 0-3 grains hardness, which is essentially the same as with a whole house softener.

    My 1 TBS dose of Charlie's Soap works just fine.

  • 18 years ago

    So you are telling her to add more detergent and create even more suds than she has? I don't want to think about it.

  • 18 years ago

    For all the discussion that has gone on about it with no resolution, MC58 apparently has some sort of unique situation happening that nobody here will be able to solve without going to her house for a direct look at it.

  • 18 years ago

    PLEASE I DONT EVEN WANT TO TRY!!!

    Since I recieved CS about 1 month ago, I use 1/2 to 1 scoop of CS and 1/4 cp bleach in my Whites and rinse 2-5 xs depending on if its a small load or med.

    YES I wish somebody could see this washer work, the techs cant even figure it out! Anyone in Ut.That knows FL WASHERS

  • 18 years ago

    I wish I could help you. I know that when my Calypso was knew, I read that it was supposed to reduce or eliminate that twisting and tangling. I was ready for that! And it did seem to do better -- until recently. For some reason, it started tangling sheets and some other loads until I thought I would never get them untangled.

    We had a pump and motor replaced a few months ago, and we found the clothes were washed better and were not as wet at the end of the cycle. I can't remember if that had an impact on the tangling, but I'll ask DH what he remembers.

    Was it a thread of yours, mc58, where folks were suggesting different ways of laoding the washer? Layering them in maybe? I would also think that the tangling problem might be worse with small loads since they are large machines and there would be a lot of room for things to fall and twist in the cycle. Is the load balanced when you put it in? I could see the machine going back and forth to try to balance the load -- same if the washer isn't level -- or maybe your machine is reading something as if it is unblanced for some reason.

    As for FL not washing as well, I'm a total FL newbie -- just a few days now, and everything other than some spots on 2 of my youngest's tshirts has come out fine. After washing those on different cycles, I gave up and took some bleach to them. That is something that could happen from time to time with my boys anyway, so I can't say anything is wrong with them. In fact, I washed some favorite sheets of my son's that had what looked like clear oily spots on them from the time they were new (not sure if they came that way or if something got onthem the first use). He loved the sheets, so we kept trying and nothing took them out. I washed them a couple of times in the new machines and even though the stains had been there at least a year, they are almost completely gone. I think some of my kitchen towels are fading out set in stains also -- so I think they are going to wash better. Everything else seems to come out well and a number of things are softer.

    I wondered if our first test load would have suds without adding detergent as I had read others did.... nope. I guess the old Calypso was still doing a good job right to the end.....

  • 18 years ago

    lascatx,
    Yes, I have tried all different things that people have suggested, folding before putting them in, 1 at a time etc.
    I have mentioned that the one thing that it doesnt tangle are sheets, well last night I did 4 king sheets 4 pillow cases and they were so twisted and tangled, I usually do 2-3 with 2 pillow cases with no problem.
    I have loaded it with a tech here to see if it would be better to wash a larger load, so we did what the manual suggested, it wouldnt spin, it had a very hard time, it was way too full, he had to take some out? So I dont know what is going on.
    Yesterday I did a load of 5 towels, 5 handtowels, 6 washclothes and I went to put them in the dryer and they were sopping wet, so I seperated them and washed them again because I dont think they finished the wash cycle, if I put more than 5-6 it does that.
    I have a tech coming out Tue.

  • 18 years ago

    If your sheets are like mine, 4 kings and 4 pillow cases would be an overload.

    If your towels, etc., are like mine the towel load would be fine.

    Don't know why the machine didn't spin them.

  • 18 years ago

    I dont know what kind of sheets you have. I have regular sheets, and for the towels, they are regular size towels, not thick or large.
    their suggestion
    Towels:
    10 bath towels
    10 hand towels
    14 washcloths NOT!! Maybe they ment Barbie doll size.

    I thought I would try a large load because people were suggesting it. But I was wrong on the load I did, it was (2 Queens, 2 Kings) 4 reg pillow cases. I didnt think it would be a problem, and they did get washed but they did tangle up. The washer was only alittle over half full without stuffing them in.

    Here is their suggestion for
    Mixed load:

    3 sheet ( 1 king, 2 twin)
    4 pillow cases
    3 shirts
    3 blouses
    9 T-shirts
    9 shorts
    10 hankerchiefs

    Maybe that is the problem, I guess I need to go buy some more hankies! and some more blouses! I would suggest them to be without any sleeves.

    their suggestion for
    Heavy Duty:
    4 jeans
    4 workpants
    4 workshirts
    2 sweatpants
    2 sweatshirts
    I would suggest that they all be shorts and short sleeve, I dont have a problem with those.

    What happened to the 16 pair of jeans that they claim it will wash??? as you see they dont suggest that, after you have purchased and go to do a load and do as the manual says. hummm!

    I expected the sheets to either not wash right or be tangled because I usually only do 2-3 sheets with 4 pillowcases with no problem.

    I was also told that I could wash big sleeping bags in it "NOT" you couldnt even get one to fit in, same as a King size comforter, I can barely fit a Queen size in it, I cant imagine how it would even wash a king size. Like I have read before on someones post I dont remember what washer, but they washed a comforter and the middle didnt even get wet, imagine that.

    As you can tell I hate the DUET 9200.

  • 18 years ago

    Still LOVE my TOP LOADER...it's a new Maytag. I used a Front Loader at a laundromat one day before I bought my new washer, and I was DISAPPOINTED at how little water sprays out into the wash drum. Filthy dirty clothes could never get as clean in that amount of water compared to a TOP LOADER of deep water.........Front Loaders don't compare.

  • 18 years ago

    I agree!!!
    but I use to have a frigidaire fl that I really liked, I should have bought another.
    But I still agree!

  • 18 years ago

    All I can say is I've been washing my own clothes for more than four decades in everything from mountain streams and motel sinks by hand through several generations of automatic machines in laundromats, in other's homes, and in my own home -- along with using the various changes in detergents. My current Duet 9400 with Tide HE powder and soft water is the best-performing combination to date -- cleaner clothes with less effort on my part. It is also quieter, cheaper to run, and its capacity allows me to wash things I used to have pay someone else for.

    I don't know what's wrong with mc58's set-up and operation. However, I would LOVE to have a shot at diagnosing/fixing this thing on-site. What's been posted has been some pretty bizarre stuff. I doubt the tech will do it. From her posted descriptions, it would likely take some observation during a cycle or two and I doubt the tech will be willing to expend the time. If there's something obvious in a few simple tests, maybe some help. Will be interested to see follow-up report.

    angelic one2002....with respect....you don't know what you're talking about.

  • 18 years ago

    I looked at the Whirlpool Duet 9200 on the Whirlpool web site. Next to 16 pairs of jeans is an asterisk which later on is explained to mean Jeans of various sizes.

    So I guess they are saying that you can't expect to put 16 pairs of jeans of the same size in at once. I guess a mix of kids small jeans with adult large jeans. Anyway it's advertising otherwise it would be stated in the manual.

    Are jeans this common that there is going to be 16 pairs in a household? I hope not.

  • 18 years ago

    asolo
    Oh now I understand, "First" you have the 9400 which is different than the 9200, like someone else has mentioned maybe they have something alittle different in the making that makes them work better. If you have read other posts I am not the only one that has the problems!!!

    "Second" maybe having to wash clothes in the mountain streams and motel sinks etc. it just seems like its a very perfect washer???

    "Third" I dont know why you even keep reading the posts that you dont understand or can even understand what others and myself have been going thru.

    jerrod6
    I also have read and seen the site and it does say various sizes, but the picture that I saw at the store of the pile of folded jeans, there was about 11 pair of mens jeans and about 5 pair of maybe a kids size 10? they were not toddlers and not size 5 womens. What I have tried to explain here, is that when I wash anything with arms and legs no matter how many in the load they get all twisted up, Im sure you seen the pictures. I have no idea why or why other people are having that same issue.

  • 18 years ago

    9400 has a heater and few additional cycles. Otherwise the same in every respect.

    I've read here and elsewhere for quite a few years. I am aware of the various problems being reported. I am certainly aware of the problems you've reported. I have never said they aren't real. What I've said is I wish I was there to work with the problem first-hand, so curious have I become.

    I'm not comparing washing in streams to current washing with my Duet. If that's what you've taken my "four decades of experience" statements to mean, I despair for what you may have taken from reading your machine's manual. I think you can't tell friend from foe.

    Hope your problems work out.

    My former sympathetic response wanes.

  • 18 years ago

    Saying sarcastic remarks to others as in "they dont know what they are talking about" is rediculous and it seems that your only wanting to start something, that is not trying to be a friend. Telling someone that their problem is Tales, bizarre stuff, operater error etc. is not trying to help anyone especially going thru what we have gone thru. It is frustrating enough without beeing told all that ----.
    So if you are trying to be a friend show us and quit saying rude comments.
    I too have been doing laundry for almost 4 decades and know how to operate a washer and read a manual, as I posted the suggestions have you ever tried washing any of the loads? I have, it doesnt work. I think I asked you once how many jeans or towels you wash you had no Idea. Like I said I am trying to find others that have same machine and problems, we do have real problems and dont need to be put down on every post that we do.
    Thank you

  • 18 years ago

    Good day to you then.....and maybe look up "sarcastic" sometime so you'll know the difference between it and a simple declarative sentence.

    I said what I meant to say. However, in the face of your astonishing powers of misconstruction I am forced to yield. I surrender and retire.

  • 18 years ago

    MC58

    I understand what you are saying.

    I just think the "number of jeans" information they are pushing is misleading but this kind of thing is often done by all manufacturers. Even so this doesn't explain why everything you wash gets tangled some time. I don't have any experience with tangling in my washer so have not said anything about that cause I don't know what to do about it.

    My grandmother had a FL and it tangled some things. I was young but I remember one time I saw her with her leg and foot up on the front of the machine while trying to pull some tangled mess out of it. You tend to remember scenes like this when it's your grandmother!

    In the mid 80's and early 90's I had the same brand she had but there was no major tangling problem. The only thing different between these was that hers had a titled drum and mine was not. I don't know if that makes a difference.

    This may have been asked before but how is your washer leveled? Forget about what the installers did cause maybe they don't know what they are doing for your situation. Maybe you could have the back feet raised up a bit or the front feet lowered so that the clothes could fall to the front more? Or maybe the opposite needs to be done. This might also let the water distribute better in the machine for rinsing.

  • 18 years ago

    Good Day!

  • 18 years ago

    jerrod6

    You made my day, thanks for the laugh, I can imagine that would stick in your mind forever :)

    I am wearie of tipping the washer alittle bit I dont know if it would work, but I will ask my husband if maybe he can, just to try it.

    This has been very frustrating and upsetting and maybe I am being to sensitive to some posts, I do appologize. I wish that I could be the one that keeps saying that my washer is almost perfect

    I did make a purchase of what I thought would be a really good washer to make it easier on me, being able to wash more at a time and at first I loved it, until it started to tangle in the fall with the long sleeves etc. Then it all started. And being told that I shouldnt wash any more than what I put in a TL, that was really upsetting to hear. I am thinking I should go buy a Speed Queen tl and sell this one, I am sure that would make things easier.

    Thanks for everyones help! I really do appreciate it.

  • 18 years ago

    At this point I think someone needs to film a documentary about mc58's washing machine experience!

  • 18 years ago

    Its not just my washer doing this! Read the consumer reports.

    I just think that I found this website to post on and all the others havent found it, and many dont do anything about reading and posting, There are also other reviews I have read, and Im sure that there are many many more people that just think they dont have a problem "YET" or if they do they dont report it.

    I think it should be a documentery about WHIRLPOOL!

    http://www.consumeraffairs.com/homeowners/whirlpool_washing_machine.html

  • 18 years ago

    Wow. Of course this is a web site for problems so it may be overstated compared to success stories but it is kind of depressing to read.

    Maybe Asko, Bosch and Miele, aren't so bad after all - at least they last a while. I still wonder if problem with water for rinsing in the newly purchased machines has to do with trying to meet the 2008 energy Star requirements. You don't always need a lot of water to wash, but you need more water in play to rinse or if it's not, you need more rinses with less water to get detergent out of clothes.

    You also need detergents that can be easily rinsed out.

  • 18 years ago

    I do think that it is the newer washers, they really do need more water to rinse, a few times I have seen water up on the glass about an inch when its on the rinse cycle, but I have only seen that 2xs put that much in. Lately I dont see any water, when the door lock will unlock for me, I have to push the clothes back to see any water, and then there is some about the middle of the drum.

    I do use Charlies but none on the towels.

  • 18 years ago

    I just browsed through the Duet manual for the latest model. I couldn't find mention anywhere of how many rinses the Duet actually does -- is it at least 3 rinses with a spin after every rinse?

    I just completed a few loads of laundry using CS, everything came out soft and clean without any FS. No suds during main wash either. Regarding the "agitation bubbles" I was experiencing during the rinse, I bypassed the water softener for one of the five rinses and the agitation bubbles disappeared. Turning the softener back on brought back some of the bubbles. I do not think this is detergent residue -- I think it is the chemical nature of the water causing this symptom.

    Our hardness is 30° dH, which is very hard. With the assistance of several web sites, I managed to calculate this into an equivalent of 534 mg/liter CACO3 (calcium carbonate). Water softeners replace the calcium with sodium, so the softener transforms this hardness into 534 mg/l of NACO3 (sodium carbonate) (washing soda). My washer uses approximately 9 liters per fill, which introduces approximately 4.8 grams (4,800 mg) of sodium carbonate into the wash just from the water alone.

    4.8 grams of NACO3 translates roughly into about 1/3 TBS, so my water softener is introducing 1/3 TBS of washing soda into every fill. Charlie's Soap is primarily washing soda, so even the clean rinse water contains roughly 1/4-1/3 of a full dose of Charlies Soap.

    After figuring this out, it makes total sense that there would be some bubbles in the water -- even my "clean" softened water will contain some washing soda. Your situation will be different based on your actual water chemistry.

  • 18 years ago

    Im not sure how many rinses there are I havent watched the whole rinse cycle.

    I still have suds in the towels after washing numerous times with no soap and water softner bypassed, we have very hard city water. The bubbles dont disipate it isnt like water bubbles it is soap bubbles. So I dont know what it is other than not enough water to rinse with.

  • 18 years ago

    Is there any chance that the little filters that is at the end of your fill hoses are clogged with hard water deposits and that the amount of water coming into your washer has decreased over time? I had that problem with extremely hard water on a top loader. I had to regularly clean those filters to keep the water level correct. It seems that the water fill was associated with a timer, not just the water level. It's just a thought.

  • 18 years ago

    No I dont think it would be that its only 2 months old. I have only bypassed soft water a few weeks.
    But its a thought, I will check that.

    Thank you

  • 18 years ago

    sshrivastava,
    your calculation about the amount of washing soda in your softened water is a little off. The amount of CaCO3 in the water is a theoretical number as the hardness in the water is made up by various calcium salts. CaCO3 is not very soluble in water (that's why you get deposits in hot water pipes and kettles) and most calcium is present as CaHCO3. The calcium ion gets replaced by a sodium ion by the water softener, but the weight of NaHCo3 (sodium bicarbonate or baking soda) is different (smaller) than that of CaHCO3. There won't be much actual washing soda (Na2CO3) in your softened water.

    mc58, something seems to be really strange about your water chemistry. I don't think that the washer is to blame for your issues. You stated that you haven't been using any detergent on your towels for several weeks/months. If that is the case, you have used many gallons of detergent free water to rinse out whatever residues are in your towels. If you still see large amounts of suds, I think something is wrong with your (softened) water.

    I have had a suds problem in my washer once after using just a hair too much liquid Tide HE detergent, but after a few extra rinses there was nothing left of that. We have fairly soft water and I don't have rinsing issues with the Sears HE detergent. Even at higher doses it doesn't create much suds during the actual wash cycle.

    I hope you can get your problem resolved soon. It does sound very aggravating!

  • 18 years ago

    Looser
    Thank you
    I have thought that it was the softner, than someone posted and said that it would have nothing to do with it. But I do believe that it isnt getting enough water in the rinse cycle. I understand that they use little water for washing but what about the rinse, should it be as low of water also? I Do see suds, they are going away little at a time. but I too can understand that trying to get soap out of a towel with about 3 cups of water isnt going to do it. That is how I see it, there couldnt be more than 2-3 gallons "in the drum" if that, I havent done the measuring of the water yet. but there is only 1 in. in front and 2 in. in the back to rinse out 5-6 towels full of suds, how could anyone expect it to get soap out of towels? I dont have a soap problem with casuals except the tangling, I do with 5 jeans 5 t-shirts.
    The tangling issue could be also not enough water to help pull them apart as they are tumbling.

    It is very aggravating.
    Thanks again