Software
Houzz Logo Print
kristimama

Does such a product exist?

17 years ago

So, who knew that when I decided to find a more eco-friendly alternative to the liquid TideHE I've been using for years, it would lead me to a minor in chemistry and teach me all sorts of little factoids about slimy outer drums and laundry balls and particulates. Certainly more than I ever thought I'd want to know about laundry detergents when all I wanted was a simple change to something more "natural." LOL

I had narrowed it to Charlie's Soap, until I learned that I would need to add either STPP, Borax, Oxy, Calgon (if I can find it) or Baking Soda (or some combination of these) to every load to make it ultimately effective in the short term and the long term.

That got me to wondering, does any such product exist that has a cleaning agent already mixed with a water softener? The idea of mixing in a tablespoon of this and a cup of that with each load is a bit too DIY chemist for me.

Is there a liquid or a powder available that already has the water softener loaded in? Something that doesn't have fabric softeners and optical brighteners?

Thanks,

KMama

Comments (4)

  • 17 years ago

    You are missing a point about softening the water. If your water is so hard you require a water softening agent in the wash, you should ALSO add it to the rinse.

    You might glean more information about softening water and the types of detergents best for hard water from the link below.

    -Grainlady

    Here is a link that might be useful: Hardness in Laundry Water

  • 17 years ago

    Thanks Grainlady. Really interesting PDF. In fact, it showed me I may not in fact have hard water. Everyone here in the SF Bay Area says things like, "oh we have hard water" but our municipal water says on their site that it's in the range of 1-7gpg which according to your pdf isn't all that hard. So maybe I'm worrying too much about this. And maybe it just means that CS doesn't work all that well for me. I dunno.

    I do use vinegar in the rinse cycle, and didn't notice much difference. Were you suggesting using a water softener like borax in the rinse cycle? Or does vinegar do the job.

    Thanks for the help. I was never much for chemistry in school and this is all kind of overwhelming.

    -k

  • 17 years ago

    Yes, the products you've described--"a cleaning agent already mixed with a water softener"--definitely do exist.

    Charlie's Soap powder is just that: "a blend of coconut oil based surfactants" = the cleaning agent, + "washing soda" = the water softener.

    Persil has this combo, too, but uses phosphates as the water softener.

    I have hard water, and for me, phosphates work much better than washing soda, so I was really surprised when you mentioned that you thought Persil didn't do a very good job getting your kids' clothes clean.

    If Tide liquid has been working well for you for two years, and you like the scent, maybe you should just stick with it... after all the whole point of doing laundry is getting things clean. :-)

    If you want your laundry to be more environmentally friendly, have you considered putting up a clothesline?

  • 17 years ago

    Crypt, thanks! You know, I didn't realize Persil has phosphates... I was using a couple scoops given to me in a ziploc baggie by my mom. I am not sure which of the Persil products it is, but it's a powder. She doesn't use the liquids or megaperls. Do all the Persil products use phosphates?

    And that's funny you say that Charlie's has a water softener in it, because he pretty much says on their website that if you have hard water you need to use STPP or TSP to make their stuff work. Maybe I'm reading it wrong. From the posts here at GW, you either love it or you hate it.

    I was switching from Tide liquid because I just wanted something with less additives and less harsh chemicals... I may end up back there but I keep wanting to give Charlie's and Persil a chance.

    Ahhh... the laundry line. LOL It's on the list of things I keep nagging my DH for. He already caved on letting me turn 1/3 of our front yard into an organic veg garden, but I am not holding much hope for a laundry line. Our front yard/lawn area faces the street and I'm not sure what laundry hanging in the yard would do for our curb appeal.