Software
Houzz Logo Print
krissie55

Cotton test versus blend fabrics.....

17 years ago

To find out whether a fabric is cotton or a blend do the following:

Use a match and burn a small scrap of fabric. If it burns clean, only ashes, it is cotton, if it melts it is a blend.

Comments (16)

  • 17 years ago

    ah ha....thanks for the tip!
    salijo

  • 17 years ago

    Could I please add a bit to this? An ashy residue can also be rayon, ramie (a vegetable fiber) or even linen (tho' linen's not seen that often). Rayon, FYI, is not synthetic, but processed a form of cellulose which is tree pulp & also made into paper.

    I also go by smell, not just the nature of the ash or burn residue. If after burning (& give it a minute for the smell to dissipate a bit), it smells papery it's a cotton or vegetable type fiber as above.

    If it smells like burned hair, it's protein based like silk or wool of a blend of both.

    Any residue which burns bead-like &/or smells like chemicals is a blend of some sort.

    I share these as I went to textile school & spent a lot of time studing different kinds of ash vs. bead residue, & also testing them strictly by smell.

  • 17 years ago

    I also look for the black smoke that synthetics give off.

  • 17 years ago

    You folks have me stumped. Now your burning your fabrics???

    I love this site!

  • 17 years ago

    Tom8olvr, You gave a smile this morning!

    Pirate Girl, Thanks for sharing. It is neat to have people who are willing to share their expert knowledge.

    Sally

  • 17 years ago

    Well, I imagine most of the fabric scraps from my sewing years (the 1980's) are either cotton or blends of cotton and polyester and are now probably considered (cough) vintage by now. LOL.

    But that is a fantastic way to tell the difference. I just hated to let them sit there in a box now that I'm getting back into the swing of things.
    Salijo

  • 17 years ago

    No Tom8, not burning the fabrics, rather its threads. I should perhaps have clarified, one can pull a thread or 2, & that's what one burns.

    We didn't invent it here; in the textile industry, it's commonly referred to as a Burn Test, its purpose to determine fiber content.

    (While content labeling of such is required by Federal law in America, that's not true elsewhere in the world. Elsewhere sometimes the term 'miscellenous fibre' is also used, which is restricted by law here, I think to no more than 5-10% of the overall content, 'cause it indiates nothing. My own pet peeve in this area is the term 'Microfiber' (like in my raincoat) which means nothing except tiny fiber (no indication of content). Other terms like the trademarks Dacron, Fortrel or Orlon (older terms I know, I graduated textile school in '79), are documented as indicating (the first 2) types of Polyester, the other, Acrylic (Orlon knitting yarns, ideal for baby clothes).

    PPatsy, the black smoke isn't such a certainty, I've seen white or gray as well. The Smoke can be more a function of various chemical finishes applied at end stage processing (called 'finishing' LOL, like starches or wrinkle resistance), rather than based on fiber content.

    Sally, thanks, I'm happy to share, since I spent soooooo many hrs. immersed in this, I feel I might as well pass it on to a community likely to find it useful. I feel the same thing when I read Sandra Ferguson here (I think that's her name) who seems particularly schooled in textile care & its history, etc.

    All that said, my first few quilts have blends in 'em, either 50/50 or 65/35 poly/cotton blends. I was a newbie, just learning, it's what I had on hand & I hadn't yet learned of the Quilt Police.

    I also (smartly) forbade myself to use prints (I'm too easily distracted by pretty fabrics). Restricting myself to solid fabrics helped keep my focus on understanding the mechanics of piecing & assembly & the key function of value placement (which STILL trips me up)!

  • 17 years ago

    "You folks have me stumped. Now your burning your fabrics???

    I love this site!"

    Tom8olver, it's known as offering up a sacrifice to the Quilting Goddess. LOL.

  • 17 years ago

    ha ha ha! Quilting goddess... Huh... I guess I should have a bon-fire to the Quilting Goddess - b/c I need some
    serious HELP in that department!

    I suppose that's better than I was envisioning (which is a
    lot more funny, to me anyway) - I'm a child of the 70's... when a 'burn test' meant something COMPLETELY DIFFERENT!

    Pardon if thou offended... I know you folks take this very
    seriously... and it shows, I can't believe what kinda work
    you gals and guys do! I'm always so impressed with your
    work and your advice. I hope that someday I will be as
    talented.

    At some point I should probably 'introduce' myself, huh?

  • 17 years ago

    Hi Tom8,

    I graduated HS in '74, college in '79, dare I say you were not alone in doing "those" burn tests ;>)

    I'm not above being a bit goofy, actually, I could stand to be goofier still!

  • 17 years ago

    it's good to know there's some of us '70ers out there quilting!

    I just don't want to offend anyone out there with my warped
    sense of humor. It's tough on e mail to know if someone's
    being funny or snitty. I always try and look at things with
    a sense of humor - but sometimes I miss the mark and offend-
    I apologize in advance!

    I do love this site though - I'm always very impressed
    with the projects you folks turn out - AND how many! I just
    cannot even imagine - you must spend all day and night
    quilting!! I'm also touched at the way you folks seem to
    care about each other - I'm a lurker, I noticed a bunch of
    you made a quilt for someone (with hearts) as a surprise -
    oh how thoughtful!!! Just nice to know there's some humanity
    out there... at a time when things are so uncertain...

    Thanks!!!

  • 17 years ago

    Tom8olvr...yes...these folks are very caring. My mother (the recipient of the quilt) has been a member on this forum for many years. I just joined last year. We've had a rough time in our family the past few months, resulting in my grandaughter passing away in December and my grandmother passing away last month, less than a month later. The ladies on the forum got together and made the "comfort" quilt for my mother.

    When I purchased my first home two years ago, before I was on the forum, I received a housewarming plant from an unknown entity called "grammyp". And I received it at work. The whole thing was quite bizarre, but made for a lot of laughs at the office after my mother asked me if I had received something and then filled me in on who it was from. Needless to say, I was very touched that someone I didn't know would send a gift to me.

    Salijo

  • 17 years ago

    Tom8olvr - don't feel bad. I thought the same thing when I saw 'burn test'. Yes, I'm a survivor of the 70's too. What I remember of it....

    I also love the concept of a sacrifice to the Quilting Goddess. I haven't been doing that and it may be the reason some of my quilting looks the way it does!

    Kate
    (HS '71, college '76)

  • 17 years ago

    "Groovy " Kate.............where'd you get that picture of me??????????
    also HS '71grad - college '75

  • 17 years ago

    I have seen a quilting book using a burned edge technique, for a wall hanging. I didn't look at it too closely, just filed it away under 'wow, the things people do!'

    I've bought "100% cotton" off Ebay that felt funny, and melted on burn testing. Got my money back twice.

  • 17 years ago

    I'm solely impressed - little secret admirers!!

    I'm sorry for your losses. That's a lot of loss in a very
    short period of time. I'm sincerely sorry. I've had a lot
    of loss in my life all at once like that and when I look back
    now it's like a blur... I'm so very sorry. No one should
    EVER bury a child. NEVER. I've always
    thought from loss in general that you can't make sense out
    of non-sense. Loss like that doesn't make sense. With time sometimes
    we can come to peace with it. I hope you and your family
    find peace - somehow.

    On to other topics... sparking one up... :)