Software
Houzz Logo Print
calbay03

marvin windows - old news

18 years ago

This is to share a few new and old research tidbits regarding Marvin Windows. It seems some new readers are posting comments without carefully researching all the facts and details. They are posting OLD as NEW, a common occurrence on the internet nowadays.

There was a class action suit against Marvin Windows that was settled way back in the late 90's. It had to do with rotting of wood windows manufactured between 1985 and 1989. It was not entirely Marvin's fault. A Federal Court found the preservative manufacturer at fault. The class action suit was then settled and all Marvin customers who experienced the rot problem could file for settlements by 9/30/2004.

We have owned AL-clad wood interior Marvin windows for five years, we have not seen any problems and hope to never see any. A friend of ours has a new house built with custom all wood (no clad) Marvin windows and doors and these are six or seven years old; no known problems. I have no stake in Marvin except as an owner and will want to know immediately if indeed there are known defects. If there are none, I wish to not be led on a merry-chase for no purpose.

I am a homeowner and an engineer and I value accurate information. When we do research on-line about a particular product, we need to read the info carefully and be objective about what we are reading and seeing. Until we are dead sure, there is no point rushing to post. No point spreading false information even if it is accidental and unintentional. It stirs up concerns and worries where there should be done. We are then NOT doing anyone any good by posting here.

Here are some links so you can all read for yourself regarding the class action suits:

http://www.taymadeservices.com/News%20For%20Homeowners.htm

http://www.bizjournals.com/twincities/stories/2005/03/21/daily40.html

http://www.bobvila.com/wwwboard/messages/236067.html

A little research goes a long way. A little critical reading and thinking also saves a ton of angst.

Cheers!

Comments (15)

  • 18 years ago

    Wooops! I meant to write "...as an owner of their products...".

  • 18 years ago

    Hehehe

    Owner? I read it how you meant it...but still funny in the context of the second message

  • 18 years ago

    Looking at Marvin windows now so I had to read this!

  • 18 years ago

    IIRC, other wood window manufacturers, such as Pella, had problems too because of the faulty preservative.

  • 11 years ago

    I also have Marvin Windows in my home. I started replacing the old windows which were the original in the house built in the 40's. It is impossible now to stop the continual rot of the windows that we are seeing. Every winter I think about what the spring will show on the windows. We have decided to replace "AGAIN" all of the marvin windows but are unsure if anything is going to last as long as a coffee pot. I regret ever touching the old windows. All we had to be concerned about was recaulking the windows. God wasn't that the nice days.

  • 11 years ago

    Old news is right. An almost 7 year old thread!

  • 11 years ago

    My window problem is current. You have problems having an old thread with newer information then contact houzz.com. Just wanted another opinion known about Marvin windows. Impossible maintenance, poor quality product and no service.

  • 11 years ago

    Laurie, no offense but if you are having that much issue with "rotting" wood windows you may need to look at other areas for the underlying cause. As Ken asked how old are these "Marvin" windows. I have been in the window and door business for 30 plus years and even the bottom of the barrel wood windows last 10 -15 years generally before r"rotting" with any sort of maintenance (the bottom of the barrel more than likely will not open and shut or operate properly but not rot)

  • 11 years ago

    My soon to be old windows are all wood and I am not asking for assistance, just stating the facts. The windows are rotting because of the quality of wood that Marvin uses. They might as well be made out of balsa.

    The windows never have a problem opening and closing and they "rot" in all the exact same way. It starts where the end grain hits the sill. The mold runs up the end grain side and across the sill. The windows are maintained PERFECTLY so all the Marvin shills can shuffle off somewhere else.

  • 11 years ago

    Sounds like it was the problem they had with the wood preservative not necessarily the type of wood used. I'm assuming these were installed in the late 1990s early 2000s which the class action suit referred to in the links the originally OP posted. When did your warranty period end?

  • 11 years ago

    That class action lawsuit was for wood windows and doors manufactured between 1985 and 1989. This is NOT when my windows were manufactured.

  • 11 years ago

    "The windows are maintained PERFECTLY so all the Marvin shills can shuffle off somewhere else."

    Not a shill and I could actually careless what people buy or use, and I haven't sold a wood window in years. I don't shuffle, and I am not going anywhere sorry to say. I just try and offer help and potential advice. I stated no offense to you but since you retorted. You come on here and blame the windows 100% and slam Marvin (could be any brand doesn't matter) yet offer no info on the age of the windows or how they are installed. You state PERFECTLY maintained but we have to accept your word on that. Does wood wick water thru end grain, yeah. Does it do it frequently yes it can. Are they ways and steps to minimize this, yes there are and in my opinion if you are having this issue repetitively and with all your windows they are not or could not be perfectly maintained. Every window company uses wood with end grain as realistically it is impossible not to and Ponderosa PIne


  • 11 years ago

    So when we're your windows installed? I'm assuming the warranty expired?

  • 11 years ago

    We've had Marvin Windows for years. No issues until we installed new windows about six weeks ago and we already have wood going bad. Just plain defective right out of the gate. Marvin hasn't exactly been falling all over themselves to straighten this out rapidly. I totally agree with the poster that said the wood is like balsa wood. It's just nothing like the product Marvin used to sell. Just for the record that's not water damage that's where the factory applied paint is coming off the wood. If you can enlarge the image or look closely you can see the entire frame is de-laminating. FWIW these are aluminum clad. I have all wood windows from Marvin (2006) that are built like a Sherman tank.