Software
Houzz Logo Print
katyde

Island top qustion - need help!

16 years ago

Hi guys, I have NO pics to show, cabinets are not installed yet: but here is a description:

We will have a 6 ft by 2 ft bank of cabinets serving as an island in the middle of our new kitchen, the island will have wainscoting on 3 sides and will have an overhang of granite along one 6 foot long side - the overhang can be to 13 inches deep. There are 2 corbels to hold up the overhang (but my contractor will also be reinforcing it with steel).

Our room is transitional/classic, with the perimeter cabs painted white, and the island is a rich bordeaux stained cherry, the granite for everything is called Ice Brown - similar to BA in color. Stainless applinaces.

So, would you guys make the entire island top a rectangle, or would you curve the seating side? Any reasons for or against a curve? AND if you prefer a curve do you like the cure to go all the way to the ends or to have a stepped shape? And what would the overhang depth be at the sides vs in the middle to get a nice arc? (eg: 10 inches at sides / 13 inches in middle?)

I appreciate Any and All suggestions! And photos of course!

Comments (9)

  • 16 years ago

    I think curves are nice but you could lose seating. We have an overhang that is only 10" deep and although I wish it were deeper, it is still functional. The bar is 6'7" long and we have 2 stools. How many stools are you planning?

    Anyway, if you can curve it but have the ends be no shallower than 10" it should be okay. But really a 6' length isn't that long so just be careful you don't end up with an overhang that only seats 1 or 1.5 people, lol. Your granite fabricator should be able to help you with this. They should make you a template that you can put on your row of cabinets so you can see what it looks and feels like before they cut the granite. That's what our soapstone people did anyway.

  • 15 years ago

    Wow we are hoping for 3 stools. I know they will need to be small-ish.

  • 15 years ago

    A curve is much better for conversation. Do you have room to extend the center to more like 15? I am doing the curve with the stepped shape on the ends. It will go from 15 to 12. Even though the ends are shallower, you are sitting at an angle which helps compensate some.

    I love the stepped look and it would go great with your traditional style.

  • 15 years ago

    We have a bi-level island with the seating area curved. We love it, but I do agree that you will lose some seating this way. I was hoping to have 3 stools in our area (and our island is very big), but only 2 fit comfortably. If we used different stools, though, there would be plenty of room.

    I don't know the angle we used, and had probably intended to do a full arc. Instead, our sides come out a bit straight and then ease into a curve. We love this configuration.

    I think the arc adds interest, but you do lose some seating capability.

    Sorry the 1st photo is blurry.

    In this picture, you can't see much of the island, but you can see how the 2 stools work in the space:

  • 15 years ago

    I don't think you have enough length to do what you want. If you want 3 stools then each stool gets 2 feet. So if you do the ends at 10" out then you are going to wind up with a bump and not a nice arc to get to your 13". And if you do an arc right from the ends you won't get enough depth to do the 3 stools. I would leave it.

  • 15 years ago

    Thanks! I think we will better know when the base cabinets go in (maybe this week) how much room there is behind the island to allow for seating. I think a 13 inch overhang all the way across - straight line, may be the best option. Will post photos ASAP!

  • 15 years ago

    Since you only have 13" for an overhang...already 2" less than the minimum 15" recommended (assuming counter-height), I agree that your best option is straight across. While others say that 10" is fine, it's really not, not if you want comfortable seating...unless only small children (but small children do not remain small for very long) or short-legged people will be sitting there.

    As to the # of stools, 24" per stool is fine if you have adequate overhang. So, 3 stools would work, again, as long as you have adequate overhang.

    If you have bar-height seating, then the minimum recommended overhang is 12" and you might be able to do a very slight curve...but not much to maintain at least 12" at each end.

    I also have to ask...how is your contractor "reinforcing it with steel"? To work, it must done properly and with the proper materials/items, not just a straight steel plate. You do need corbels or similar b/c you have more than a 6" or 10" overhang...6 & 10 Rule:
    If 2cm thick stone, you need to support any overhang greater than 6"
    If 3cm thick stone, you need to support any overhang greater than 10"

    You must also have a corbel or support for every 30" of unsupported overhang.

    Check out the thread below for more information, especially toward the end where there is discussion about supporting overhangs and links to a couple of threads.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Thread: Stone Information and Advice (& Checklists)

  • 15 years ago

    I did not know that adding a curve would actually *decrease* the amount of seating. Hm. Anyway, we started out planning for a 9in overhang, but I changed it to 12in after throwing the idea around here on GW. I'm glad we made the change.

    I'm not sure what you mean by reinforcing your overhang with steel, but we used these hidden gussetless brackets:


    Here's a pic of them installed, before they were hidden by decorative panels:
    {{!gwi}}
    Here's an after pic. While the website where we bought the hidden brackets showed plenty of pics of bars being held up with only these brackets, they still include a disclaimer that additional support with a gusset is recommended. At any rate, we had decorative brackets installed on the ends because I thought they were pretty. It's overkill; my bartop only needed 3 supports, not 5, but it makes me feel better.
    {{!gwi}}

  • 15 years ago

    I thought I would post some images so you can see which
    might work better for you. Curves can be beautiful but I
    agree you might loose seating. The space around the island
    is a factor too. So many things to consider...
    ~boxer

    Macguire House

    Remodeling Center

    Seattle Mag

    Villa Estrella

    Carribean Home

    Palo Alto Kitchen Design


    Keating

    Huntington

    Home Paradise


    Dallas Design