Software
Houzz Logo Print
newbiev

Floor indecision - please help first time home owners

11 years ago

We just bough our first house and are agonizing over what shade to do the floors. We have to replace all of the floors in the house, and want it to look clean and modern but also timeless (so we don't need to go through this again in 10 years).

This is our wish list:

Something that makes the house look bigger, or at least less small

Something that makes the house look clean and bright. The house gets quite a bit of natural light but we took some darker floors there to see how they would look and they looked very dark!

Floors that don't show dust, dents etc too easily and are low maintenance. We were looking for some texture

A wood that is not too grainy


We know we don't want too dark, too old-fashioned, too trendy or too rustic looking - just a normal, nice floor

We are looking at medium/natural tones but are now worried that they may be too light. We were originally looking at much darker shades. We are going to do the walls in a neutral light grey colour with white trim.

I have attached a photo of the floors we are considering (Applachian - Haute Couture - Linen colour or Applachian - Era Design - Rococo) as well as some "before" photos of the house. The two floor are similar. Both matte. One is wire-brushed and the other isn't. We are ripping up all of the carpet. The whole house is fairly small, about 1100 sq ft on two floors

Please help! All opinions welcome.




Comments (27)

  • 11 years ago

    Grey wall: light, go with med floor, med, go with light floor. How light of a grey are we talking? Can you give us a name of something you're interested in?

  • 11 years ago

    Oh, I am such a newbie! Paint colour selection will be our next dilemma! We are thinking something like BM Barren Plain, BM Calm, CIL Touch of Grey, BM Cement Grey, BM Affinity Wish. Something light without blue undertones. Thanks!

  • 11 years ago

    Are those wood shades medium?

  • PRO
    11 years ago

    Lucky Dog - a Kelly Moore color is nice

  • 11 years ago

    I like the bottom floor and try to find a taupe grey or it'll look blue. finding the right grey is harder than you would think.

  • 11 years ago

    Look into maple flooring as it doesn't have nearly as much grain as woods like oak that are going to give you that old fashioned rustic look. It's much more epensive, but like you said, you don't want to do this again in 10 years.


  • 11 years ago

    Thank you all. Yes - we are thinking of a taupe grey. Want to decide on the floors and then move to the paint selection. At least we can get to sample to try out for that.

    We were looking for a maple with some texture, but it proved hard to find. That's how we ended up with the white oak.


  • 11 years ago

    Floors should be the 1st & most important. I say the lighter, the better. I am so happy to see more people turning to the lighter floors. Now we need to get away from everything grey. Painting should be the last thing you do unless you just want to prime it before moving in. Paint is your cheapest item in décor. Good luck in your new home owning adventure.

  • 11 years ago

    I like the grain of the bottom one better. I would not recommend any red oak, if you are ever headed in that direction. I have it and would have preferred a more neutral, whiter color wood.

    newbiev thanked User
  • 11 years ago

    Thanks, everyone. I think we will go with one of the two floors (we like the bottom one too). Next we need to decide whether to go with 4 or 5 inch planks - too many choices! The paint colour is a whole other thing. I will definitely consult this board again when it comes to paint colours. I think we are leaning towards a slightly darker tone, thinking about getting some contrast. I'll post some pics once we have some samples up. Thanks again!

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Have you considered hardness? We are renovating a 100+ year old home and decided to go over all the old pine floors. Ironically we bought the house because of the pine floors but 2 kids and a dog destroyed them in about a week. Our new floors are going to be hickory. Scratches happen but you should check to make sure that when scratched it dents. A few samples we brought home left a nasty white streak on the floor. As for matching-. Better to match the walls to a floor you like then vice versa. The floor will look unique in your space and its best to wait to choose a color!

    newbiev thanked srobertb
  • 11 years ago

    Yes, we have. We were hoping to find something in hickory or maple but have now sort of settled on white oak. I think the hardness is ok and the finish is supposed to be dent-resistant as well. Thanks!

  • 11 years ago

    There is always bamboo, which now comes in many colors and finishes. It is so durable and will hold up to the traffic you mention. There are so many manufacturers now too, that choices should be optimal.

  • 11 years ago
    Both good choices, I would go with the wider planks. I prefer oak to other woods for floors. You can scratch the sample to see if you can live with the way they appear.
    newbiev thanked ycity
  • 11 years ago

    That's a great idea. Thanks.

  • 11 years ago
    We did white oak but stained it in this rich darker shade. It makes out house feel so warm we went with lighter walls and white trim. Looks sharp!
  • PRO
    11 years ago

    Go lighter...area rugs can then make it what you wish later.

  • PRO
    11 years ago

    You stated that you want a light, bright, clean and modern look for your home and a wide plank quarter sawn oak will definitely complement your vision. Oak is a great choice for flooring because it is a hardwood and plentiful. One thing to consider with a light stained floor is that it can show black heal marks easily but the wire brushed oak should help prevent that. The process of wire brushing actually removes the softer wood fibers from the plank leaving the hardest parts of the wood along with a nice texture.

  • 11 years ago

    Moved into a condo 2 yrs ago, I agonized too ... ended up purchasing a good quality laminate at "Lumber Liquidators" ... showroom is awsome, they have large areas laid in their store and you can get a feel for the flooring. Price was right too ... I shopped for 2 mnths :)

  • PRO
    11 years ago

    Kids, Grand Kids? Dogs? Check out Armstrong Flooring and others for vinyl floors.

  • PRO
    11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    One of most popular selections now sounds like it could fit the bill of all the things you're looking for...wide plank , white oak, in an oil finish which can be re-oiled over time rather then sanding... spot treated in high traffic or pet areas... or let it wear naturally! It's not the wood that scratches - it's the finish. You can get it with a UV finish and a little bit of color if you like or stay natural, or white wash. Good Luck!

  • 11 years ago

    Thanks KE&CO, the Era Design collection from Appalachian is an oil finish and we are leaning towards that

  • PRO
    11 years ago

    I think you'll love it!!

  • 11 years ago

    Look at the Durango Line offered by The Masters Craft. There is a Natural Hickory and a Hickory Toast that I think would look great with your choices. If all else fails you can always go site finished!

  • 11 years ago
    I would choose a light neutral floor with a plank size 3 1/2"-4" wide and a satin finish. As far as stain, stay away from from anything with a decidedly yellow or orange undertone especially, if you are using gray wall color. These midtone yellow/orange wood floors are unappealing/dated and create nightmares when choosing wood tones for furniture and colors for upholstery.
  • 8 years ago

    Hi newbiev, how do you like your Appalachian floors? What color did you install and how do they hold up to wear so far? We are considering their Era Design maple floors with oil finish and desperately need a feedback on them. Thanks!