Hey Houzzer! Your current rug was a good match for the dining table set you have so we're assuming you're trying to match that same type of color scheme.

We notice that you already have two prospective choices. The first rug does look good, and is probably durable enough to serve your needs. If you are anticipating having company often, and if this is your main dining area, this rug will hold up for a reasonable amount of time while still providing comfort and style under-foot. It also seems to be a lower pile height, which is ideal for a dining room because chairs will be moving around on it often and the pile will not impede movement. Conversely, that first rug is a hand-tufted and made of wool, so it can eventually shed and perhaps receive some imperfections from sustained pressure or friction. Also, with the hand-tufted rugs with dense (but not high) piles, they can sometimes be difficult to clean in the event of a spill or stain.

The second rug, which we cannot find more information on, seems to be a wool jute, which is a flatweave (machine-woven) rug with tight knots that are known to hold up well against wear-and-tear. The jute rug may not be glamorous, but it is hardy. One disadvantage of a jute rug is the texture, and some jute rugs are known to be "scratchy" and may catch objects that are in contact with it. However, some jute rugs are easier to clean (less delicate knots to worry about damaging, less dense pile, no dyes) and tend to be harder to notice stains on. If possible, you should inquire about the proper cleaning of this rug (or any prospective choice) because the conditions can differ. Some jute rugs, especially if the fibers are dyed, can lose color if they come into contact with cleaning solvent. Other jute rugs have very easy cleaning instructions, and one can basically take them outside and blast it with a hose and shampoo. Again, an important aspect to consider is always the process of cleaning.

It's up to you to decide the right mix of functionality and style for your rug, but hopefully these comments will help you make your mind up. Personally, we think the colors of the top rug are a great match for your interior, while the jute rug may be too light of a shade for your floor and dining set. Of course, there are many shades and types of flatweave jute rugs, and it shouldn't be hard to find the right one for your purposes.

Good luck with your project!