Neil, thank you for asking my advice, there are many here far more knowledgeable than I, so it's nice :)

I know there is a variegated Gollum, not yellow variegated, though, I think, and a variegated Fingers jade, like a skinny-leaved Gollum, which is called Legolas; the people who know about those here are Kaktuskris, Josh, Laurent, Ben and Mike. I think Legolas is white variegated too. If there is a yellow-variegated type of any of the above, someone will come and tell you soon, hopefully, but I am not aware of them.

I have two types of yellow-variegated Hobbit - one is called Red Horn Tree, but, similarly to Hummel's Sunset, there is a great deal of yellow in the variegation. When it came from France it was very bright, but February and March in Ireland turned it rather dour - it is now recovering its bright coloration. When I posted a pic of the other on the forum, people thought it also was Red Horn Tree. It has similar colours, but is a different plant, it grows differently, the new leaves appear in a different way. I will try to get a picture of the difference for you eventually. But as you know, you know your own plants, and can see these things.

Yes of course. Knowing your plants you would spot things others would miss. I saw the Gollum variety in a mixed container at a show. It was mostly yellow with hints of red at the tips and gradations of a lime green just below. My first thought: I've never seen one like that before. And of course the next thought was: I just have to get one!

The container it was in was about 24 inch mixed planting and cost a couple of hundred dollars otherwise I would have bought it.

Honestly, I still am unsure if what I saw was a Gollum or hobbit. I still get them mixed up especially when they're younger plants. But I do know I haven't seen that color variation on either one before.

Thank you and I will research the legolas now.

Neil