Software
Houzz Logo Print
12crumbles

Accessibility and electrical receptacle for DW

11 years ago

My kitchen layout which now cannot be changed includes a 9" cabinet with pull out shelves that lies between the sink and the DW. My electrician has told me that code requires that DW to be plugged into an accessible receptacle and a receptacle behind the DW is not considered accessible because the DW will be screwed into the cabinet somehow so it's not the same as opening a cabinet door or pulling out a drawer.

Any thoughts or suggestions on what I can do at this late date? TIA.


Comments (22)

  • PRO
    11 years ago

    Put the outlet in the 9" Problem solved

  • 11 years ago

    Put the outlet under the sink and use a 9" longer cord on the DW. The DW installation instructions will tell you where in the cabinet back you need to have access for routing both the cord and the water line.

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    The cabinet has this organizer in it.

    It is not at my house yet so I cannot check this out - can the sliding shelves be removed so that the back of the cabinet is "accessible" ? ( I have to say, I am not sure why it would be OK to run the plug wire through the DW and sink cabs to an outlet under the sink but not OK to run it through the 9" cab as well to a receptacle under the sink.)

  • 11 years ago

    Thank you weedmeister. It sure seems as if that would be a reasonable solution, and I bet it's done that way frequently because it is practical. However, there is something in the NEC standards which says that the receptacle must be "adjacent to" the DW cabinet/space, although "adjacent to" is not defined. (I've been googling.) Then there is the not-yet-effective revision for household DW wiring Revision: 422.16(B)(2) – Built-In Dishwashers here.

    And the UL Certification

    A problem seems to be the prohibition of running a soft wire through walls and I guess cabinet "walls".

  • 11 years ago

    I do not believe this is considered a case of running "soft wire through walls" since you are just running it through a cabinet wall, not a framed wall. From what I've seen, its quite common to run it through the DW cabinet wall and to a receptacle under the sink.

    You mentioned shelves in the 9" cabinet. How do the dishwasher drain lines get from the DW to the sink drain? It seems that if there is a good path through that cabinet for drain lines (which are relatively large) there should also be space for an electrical line.

    I think its a viable option to either extend the cord 9" to reach under the sink, or to put the outlet in the back of the 9" cabinet. However, I think it would be less confusing for future maintenance to swap out to a longer cord and put the receptacle under the sink, since that is most typical.

    Bruce

  • 11 years ago

    Frankly, under the sink is common and legal and convenient. I disagree with him. Behind the dishwasher is, at least as far as the National Electrical Code, accessible. Having to unscrew the clips retaining on the dishwasher isn't "damaging the finished surface." That being said, a lot of local jurisdictions don't want the disconnects behind the appliance. Even the microwave and wall ovens in one of my houses are in the cabinets above the units.


  • 11 years ago

    Thanks to each of you for taking the time to respond. My electrician won't be back for another week, so I have a little time to think about this. I'm having a hard time grasping why the plug cannot be under the sink. That would be the first place I would look for it (if I knew it was not supposed to be behind the DW).

    Ron, isn't the NEC problem that "accessible" means no tools are required to get to the outlet? If retaining clips have to be unscrewed (I don't know what they are or where they go) doesn't that mean that a tool is required to get to the outlet and it is therefore NEC "inaccessible"?

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Accessible or not, you can cut power to the DW at the panel, it is supposed to have its own breaker, and GFCI protected also. Although it is cheaper to GFCI protect with an accessible outlet. There are some dishwashers that are direct wired also, not common but they note that in instruction manuals still.

  • 11 years ago

    Another option would be to put a switch under the sink, or elsewhere, that controls an outlet placed behind the DW.

    12crumbles thanked ionized_gw
  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    If you're going to use the breaker for the service disconnect and you can't see it from where you're working on the dishwasher, you need to have some mechanism to lock it. Many panel manufacturers have a cheesy little locking tab you can add to the breaker to accomplish this (In fact, my townhouse has such a tab on the wall oven breaker as there is no other disconnect). I have no idea what Vith is saying there. There's no strict requirement for a dishwasher to have it's own breaker.

    As ionitzed says a switch will also suffice. I disagree with weedmaster, even the proposed 2017 code doesn't prohibit things. The "tools" portion comes from the definition of "readily accessible" but the corresponding section on the disconnecting means of a cord and plug device just says accessible which is still defined as not enclosed by the finish of the building. Moving the appliance (even if it takes tools) doesn't make it not accessible.

    Whether your dishwasher requires GFCI depends on what the code in force is in your area. This has changed a couple of ways in the past two code versions. Probably safer to make sure you do provide GFCI.

    12crumbles thanked Ron Natalie
  • 11 years ago

    I'm starting to feel better that there may be a reasonable solution. Maybe the electrician is not quite as knowledgeable about code as I need, although it does seem as if the code - or how it is interpreted - is not too clear. So the "accessibility" meaning "no tools" does not apply to the disconnect as long as the disconnect is visible and reachable, like normal people would think of it? And I don't need a separate 20A circuit (he said I did)? And a switch, like I used to have for the GD, can be the disconnect? So "pull the plug" is a disconnect but also somewhere else along the line there could be a switch (if plug behind DW is not acceptable) that could be the disconnect?

    Although I will be speaking to the building inspector, but I need to understand as much as possible because I will also have to speak to the electrician. I'm in a small town and the electrician doesn't usually work here. I have a feeling that a regular town electrician would be assured of passing inspection with any of the suggestions made here. Not that anything unsafe would be approved but anything requiring interpretation by the electrician would be acceptable. Maybe I'm too jaded.

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    You would be better off with a separate circuit, it may not be 'required' to do so, but over engineering is better than under. Dishwashers pull about 12 amps by themselves. If you turn on a kitchen appliance on the same circuit while the dishwasher is running its gonna throw the breaker.

    I agree the switch as a disconnect would work also.

    Tell the electrician, you want a separate 20A circuit with an accessible disconnect near the dishwasher (or under the sink) and GFCI protection. You could choose either a GFCI breaker with a switch disconnect, or an outlet with GFCI.

    12crumbles thanked Vith
  • 11 years ago

    OK, it's probably going to be several days before I make it in to the building inspector's office, but I feel prepared to ask questions, and more questions if I don't understand first time around. Thanks all, I will let you know the answers I get.

  • 11 years ago

    Vith's response gives me second thoughts about the simplicity of a switch controlling an outlet that is inaccessible behind the DW. If it needs to be GFI, you would not want the GFI outlet inaccessible. You can fix that by putting a second outlet in the same junction box with the switch, or use a, more expensive, GFI breaker.

    Does the DW need to be GFI

    Is there any possibility that the DW can be hard-wired?

  • 11 years ago

    As of the 2014 code all receptacles under the sink need GFCI. As of the 2014 all outlets (whether hard wired or feeding receptacles) serving dishwashers need GFCI.

    One good note here, the GFCI controls (test/reset) need to be readily accessible. While you could put the disconnect behind the dishwasher, if you have to resort to tools to get to it, you can not put the GFCI there.


  • 11 years ago

    As of the 2011 NEC, 422.31(C) no longer allows a lockout on a breaker as a disconnect for motor-operated appliances rated over 1/8 horsepower. A dishwasher is 1/4 - 1/3 HP.

    12crumbles thanked User
  • 11 years ago

    Another good catch, Fred.


  • 11 years ago

    I wasn't trying to imply that there was some kind of prohibition. Just that the 2017 NEC proposals don't apply now. And the author of the article finished it up saying that there were 'differences' in how the UL and NEC were addressing this and that they would need to come to agreement at some later date.

    I think what you said in that the NEC considers a 'wall' to be part of the structure of the building. Hence a cabinet side is not considered a 'wall' and can be penetrated by cordage. But I figure once you've notched out the back of the cabinet in order to pass the water and drain lines, there should be plenty of room for a power cord.

    12crumbles thanked weedmeister
  • 11 years ago

    Fred S - I guess my inspector isn't up on the 2011 code! He was a bit testy when I wanted to confirm that it would be OK to run the plug wire through 9" cabinet to an outlet under the sink like I would be running the DW discharge hose. He read the code to me again (about "adjacent") and said he would have to look up how NEC defined "adjacent", then decided that it couldn't run through the 9" cabinet because that is not an adjacent space. He said to hard wire it and use a breaker with a thingy on it in the main box.

    I'm going to wait a few months in the hope that he will forget about a call from someone who wanted to know if through a 9" cabinet would be OK.

    From the comments here I decided that this is what I am going to have done: A GFCI receptacle under the sink. Wire with plug run through the 9" cabinet and sink cabinet, using cord management grommets to protect the wire from abrasion (probably unnecessary). I'll have a thingy put in the fuse box anyway, so there will be two disconnects. Maybe he will be so smitten with my fail safe double protection that he will forget that there is a wire through the cabinets to a receptacle that is not in a space directly adjacent to the DW.

    If it doesn't pass I'll have it redone - hard wired and thingy in the fuse box even though that sounds stupid to me. Or hardwired with switch under the sink like some GDs and a thingy in the fuse box.

    Thanks to everyone for your ideas and exchanges with one and another! Very helpful to know that there is no one answer and how it is that you electricians think things out.

  • 11 years ago

    Be sure to use "tingy" when you talk with officials. They love that ;-}

  • 11 years ago

    An under the sink GFCI receptacle should be fine at any level of the code. This is how it is almost always done. We can argue the vagaries of the code requirements, but there's really no point in making this harder than it really is.