Software
Houzz Logo Print
hzdeleted_3096145

Too late to overseed?

11 years ago

I'm in Zone 3A, is it too late to overseed? We get first snow usually around Oct 31.

If too late, what can I do with my lawn with the remainder of Fall?

Comments (10)

  • 11 years ago

    Canada. Our first frost was September 15.

  • 11 years ago

    Canada is quite large, but I'll use the standard for the Prairie Provinces, just north of North Dakota.

    It's too late to seed.

    At this point, when grass growth stops but the lawn is still green (not quite yet, probably, but soon), feed it with any good, high-nitrogen synthetic fertilizer at bag rate. I'm not familiar with what's available up there, but the numbers would look something like 29-0-5 or 32-2-8--a large first number, smaller second and third.

    That'll put it in good shape for late fall and spring, and give you the best survival chances possible.

    Then feed again around May 30th.

    Post that, fall seeding for you, with first frost of September 15, will be around August 1. Plan the first fall feeding around September 1 for next year.

    User thanked User
  • 11 years ago

    Thanks for all your advice, morpheus. Will keep all this in mind for next year.

    Would this be a good choice? Scotts Turf Builder Lawn Food (32-0-10)

    What are your thoughts on Fall fertilizers?

    Last question, what about aeration? Most lawn companies up here have Oct 31 as the cutoff date.


  • 11 years ago

    We have an ongoing war regarding aeration. My core feeling is that it neither helps nor harms appreciably, so don't bother, and on balance it's likely to set off more minor problems than it solves.

    October 31 seems rather late when snow is possible at that time, the lawn does need a bit to repair the torn root systems. Nor should you leave holes down into the root zone open in very cold weather, it increases damage to the roots over winter.

    >>Would this be a good choice? Scotts Turf Builder Lawn Food (32-0-10)

    Perfect! Without a soil test, I'm not a fan of supplying large amounts of phosphorus (0 here) or potassium (10 here). That amount of potassium is completely reasonable.

    >>What are your thoughts on Fall fertilizers?

    When not overseeding, I'd use a (calculating) schedule of May 30, August 1, September 1, and whenever the grass stops growing but is still green--probably early October for you, could be October 15.

    That delivers three quarters of the nitrogen to the lawn in fall, with a boost in spring post the growth period to help it generate carbohydrates for summer (not much of a problem in Zone 3).

    When overseeding, you don't want to set off grass growth while trying to bring in the new seed, so you skip that feeding. The lawn just has to bear up, but you can use an organic at that time instead if you want. Milorganite or any other off the shelf slow release organic fertilizer won't set off extreme growth.

    Organics are actually a good idea at any time, but that's your choice to make. I'm organic with a great lawn. Other people use synthetics and have great lawns.

    User thanked User
  • 11 years ago

    Canada does not narrow it down enough. Where in Canada?

    Why do you want to aerate? Do you have a problem you think aeration will fix? Or is it because you've always aerated in the fall? Because everyone else is aerating? Because all the lawn companies are recommending it? Because your parents aerated?

    Regarding fall fertilizing, what kind of grass do you have? Is it still green? Is it still growing?

    The time to seed is when the summer heat is ending and the evening temps cool down. Summer heat may never happen if you live too far north, which would change the timing. Morpheus assumed you live in the central south.

    User thanked dchall_san_antonio
  • 11 years ago

    @morpheus: I am trying to go organic but my lawn is really weedy. Have done a lot of weed-pulling. Lawncare kind of took a backseat to starting a organic veggie garden, though. I bought some horticultural vinegar recently that I haven't used yet. Normally I'd be worried it would kill the surrounding grass but...there's more weed than grass, really...

    @dchall: I live in southern Alberta, above Montana. We have cold winters and hot but short summers, where the sun doesn't set until after 10pm (it's definitely not like that right now). We have KBG as grass but I'm looking to add in some fescue since it's supposed to be better for my area. I think it is still growing. The soil is really hard. Have tried the shampoo/molasses thing, but found that manual weeding (i.e. pulling out clumps of dirt with the weed) heped a lot more with softening the soil. I don't have any experience with professional aeration - this is my first lawn and my parents never did anything past mowing & weeding.

  • 11 years ago

    The area north of ND in the states was more than close enough, then.

    Sometimes an initial shot to get the weeds under control is necessary, after which organic methodology will work fine. But I'm not sure what is and isn't legal to use in Canada these days--your arsenal is definitely more limited than it is here in the US. Something like our Weed B Gon with Chickweed, Clover, and Oxalis Control would probably take care of 95% of your issues with one shot.

    Horticultural vinegar can be used, but please wear eye protection. Blow-back can burn your cornea rather severely. It does tend to be more effective in hot weather, but it's worth a shot.

    Shampoo and molasses can take some time and several applications to work, and may or may not be effective depending on the chemistry of your soil. Again, I'm not sure what the soil testing options are up there, but I think I've heard of people shipping soil to Logan Labs. I'd check on the customs/environmental regulations on that before doing it, though.

    Both fescue and KBG should be workable in Zone 3, although neither will be any great shakes during your (long and very cold) winters. I'd tentatively say there's no chance at all of keeping it green through winter, but either should be a nice grass in spring, summer, and fall with appropriate watering and feeding.

    User thanked User
  • 11 years ago

    Morpheus, would dormant seeding work up there, or is that only good in transition zones?

  • 11 years ago

    It's worth a try. The seed should be more durable than even the adult grasses are, and they'll survive Zone 3 winters with no problems.