Personally, I like the weathered wood ones, but then again, I'm the guy; I don't pick 'em; I just paint 'em.

I don't like GAF, but maybe they've improved over the years.

I much prefer the weathered wood color, and also the shadow lines of the Timberline.

Wait; I just reread this thread and the third picture says "What is already on".

The house isn't already shingled, is it?

Thank you for your opinions. The photos are from the builder's website- their colors are the same as ours. We just recently moved in, but we had hail storm. So we will have to replace the whole roof!

May i ask why you don't like GAF? In comparison to OC oakridge (not duration), GAF timberline is better choice, i thought.

I haven't used GAF in 15 years, so they may be different, but I found GAF to be (in the same warranty range), thinner than CertainTeed, and I found lots of inconsistencies in their sizing. The sizing thing, however, isn't your concern. I always liked CertainTeed better.