Software
Houzz Logo Print
davidfairport

Having trouble understanding AC electrical

10 years ago
last modified: 10 years ago

I understand DC electricity very well. I understand volts, amps, resistance, etc. I have a good feel for what is going on with DC wiring, circuits, and devices, and understand how to design and wire safe circuits.

AC is a bit more elusive to me, though. Again, the amps, watts, etc. are all straightforward, but the reversing current, sine waves, and especially the neutral wire and bus are very mysterious to me. Neutral is not considered hot, but you still shouldn't touch it, for some reason. Why wouldn't neutral be hot, if the current reverses itself each cycle?

I have done work on home wiring circuits, including adding new ones to the breaker box, and am comfortable with it, until now.
My next project is to install a back-feed generator circuit controlled by a lockout switch, which turns off the main breaker when the generator is connected.

That neutral thing has me confused, as usual.
As far as connecting generator feeds through a dedicated breaker, a couple people have said that if you try to connect a 110v generator to both sides of the panel, after turning off the breakers for all 220v circuits, you can fry your neutral. I have no idea why, or if this is true, and if they mean a neutral wire or the neutral bus.

I am tempted, for the sake of getting my head around how current flows through these circuits, to just imagine it's DC, with hot + and neutral -, but I'm sure there is a flaw there.

So let me know your thoughts. I appreciate any help I can get.

David

Comments (11)

  • 10 years ago

    Comparison to DC would better be done by comparing to a system with positive, ground and negative. That is not perfect, however, so not all that helpful either.

    In conventional wiring in the US, the neutral is bonded to the ground at the main service panel. This is really the only tangible difference between the neutral and hot. In a balanced 240 circuit, you have no current on the neutral wire. That is why on a wholly 240 circuit, there is no neutral. Look at at wave diagrams for voltage and current in a US 120/240 service. The net voltage or current at any time in a balanced circuit is zero. As the circuit is unbalanced, a neutral conductor is needed because current is no longer net zero between the two legs. Now think again, a balanced circuit yields no current on the shared neutral conductor. As the load becomes imbalanced between the two hots, the current on the neutral increases to a maximum at the maximum current in the higher load leg while the lower load leg is zero. (Think all the breakers on one buss bar turned off.) That is why the neutral conductor is normally exactly the same size as both hot legs. If you have a neutral shared between two circuits and they get put on the same leg, all of a sudden you have the potential for the shared neutral to have double its allowable current without a circuit breaker tripping.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Wow, ionized_gw. A lot of great information. I'll spend some time re-reading it and digesting it. At first glance it seems to make sense.

    When you talk about the neutral conductor being the same size as both hot legs, where do you mean? Do you mean the neutral bus bar? I'd be supplying a mere 20a from the generator to the panel, so the neutral bus bar could certainly handle that. Or are you talking about a neutral wire in an individual circuit somewhere?

    Obviously I am planning on powering only a couple 110v circuits at a time, and strictly limiting the total current draw in the house while on generator, to keep it below the 20a generator output.

    Thanks for your help.

    David

  • 10 years ago

    My explanation may not be the best. I am neither am I an electrician, nor an engineer. Even though you may not be in any danger of overloading neutral bus bars and wires, the installation that you are proposing violates building code, probably your agreement with the power company, and could easily pose problems that I have not thought through, like what is really going on in those 240V circuits.

    A genset producing 20A is very small. (I thought that you might be considering borrowing and RV-type genset for the house outages as they are 120 only and somewhat larger capacity.) Are you sure that you want to do this rather than use an extension cord? Another alternative that can probably be done on the up and up, is moving all the circuits that you really want to power to ONE hot bus bar that you will power with the portable genset. I believe that this can be done compliant with electrical code. In addition, you will have the ready option of adding the other hot circuits someday if you want to go 120/240 with a larger genset. Please consider this carefully.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    I appreciate the response. Connecting this interlock switch is perfectly acceptable and safe. It is sold by the panel manufacturer, Square D, for just that purpose. The only thing I am considering doing differently is connecting it to both sides of the panel, rather than just a single side as is usual. This will necessitate turning off any 220v breakers.

    I realize that this is is a small generator, but it will only be used as an emergency backup for short periods during the very rare power outages here, once every few years. Mostly for a couple lights, the fridge, or a small (500w) space heater, all carefully monitored to not overload the generator. The same way any of us are careful not to overload any individual circuit in our regular home lives. If there is an overload on the generator, it simply trips its own breaker.

    I emailed the Square D tech guy. They don't prohibit jumper-ing to both sides of the panel. Their tech guy said it would cause a problem if the generator had a GFCI (which mine doesn't), and suggested having an electrician check everything over (good idea), but didn't have a reason why it shouldn't be done.

    Here's what I picture as the worst case: I forget to turn off a 220v breaker, and a 220v load tries to run on 110v generator power. Maybe the motor browns out, but probably the 20a generator breaker just trips.

    I would like an electrician to look it over before I use it, but want to look for potential problems before I run all the wire, etc. If I have to I could just use it as designed and only power one side of the panel, but it would be so convenient if I could do both sides, as the circuits I really want to use are fairly evenly divided between the two.

    David

  • 10 years ago

    I examined the breaker layout in my panel again, and it turns out that all except one or two of the breakers I would use during a power outage are on the left side, so if I just move them over there I can use the interlock exactly as intended, without having to worry about turning off the 220 breakers or jumpering to both sides of the 220 backfeed breaker. So I might as well keep it simple!

  • 10 years ago

    I would be surprised if connecting both hot bus bars to the same conductor from a genset/transfer switch would pass an inspection, but I don't know. Others that post here are much better versed. At any rate, I am glad that you can use the single phase on one bar and get what you want most powered that way. It seems like a better solution all the way around. I someone gives you a 120/240 genset some day, you can then drop that in very easily.

  • 10 years ago

    "I examined the breaker layout in my panel again, and it turns out that all except one or two of the breakers I would use during a power outage are on the left side,"

    What kind of panel do you have that makes everything on the left side be on the same 120V phase?

  • 10 years ago

    I didn't know what you were trying to say, Fred, (the sarcasm didn't help) until I thought about it some more. Of course the breakers in the same column alternate bus bar sides! So I instead need to have all the breakers for the circuits I want during a power outage to be in either every other one on a side, or directly across from each other.

    Thanks for the heads up!

    David

  • 10 years ago

    Well I got everything hooked up according to the manufacturer's instructions, and code. I turned off the main breaker, flipped the interlock, and turned on the breaker for the generator feed. The lights flicked on for a couple seconds, then dimmed and flickered for a few more, then went out completely. The generator throttled up, and strained at full throttle before this happened. I quickly disconnected the generator.

    Dang! I was so discouraged. What the heck had I hooked up wrong? I checked all my panel connections, and my voltage from the generator into the breaker. I went through the house and turned off everything except a couple lights.

    Then I noticed the two laser printers. When the power comes on, these both boot up and pull a heck of a surge current. I notice it when I print; the lights in my office flicker and dim for a second. Well, with both of them booting up simultaneously it pulled way too much current for my little 2000W Honda.

    I turned both of them off and the generator worked perfectly. This has gotten me thinking that I don't want both of them powered up on the same circuit anyway, generator or not.

    But the good news is that I got my interlock working right.

    David


  • 10 years ago

    I am glad to see that you are up and ready for the next power failure. If those two laser printers have not tripped the breaker yet, why worry?

  • 10 years ago

    You make a good point, ionized_gw. I guess I'm a little extra careful, and don't like the idea of a big surge being pulled over wires that aren't rated for it, even if a breaker is in place.

Sponsored
Bella Casa LLC
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars17 Reviews
The Leading Interior Design Studio in Franklin County