HI -- They are both real nice . The light one goes with the bedspread and has longevity - she could have for many years BUT it will get dirty real fast with a teenager . And black is what teenagers like and will not show dirt etc. and would also last her into adulthood .

is this the actual room? go with the black....it will probably be covered with stuff soon enough. black can transition when teenager changes her mind in two years....and she will.

Thats exactly why I'm torn between the two.

definitely white or ivory. animal print is even better.

Pretty in pink and what a lovely choice of bedspread and pillows! We are finding animal prints to be a top pick from teens. Pink and purple tones and pink and browns are still color combos that teens are choosing as well. - Kelly

the black may seem out of place with the shabby chic light pink night stand and so much pink light pink. the off-white fits better.